Their new company website is almost done and the owner isn't falling in love with any of our alternative logo options.
There seems to be a familiarity bias - he says he wants a new logo but he always picks his old logo over various alternatives we've presented. The old logo strikes me as having design issues that make it objectively bad, so I'm not sure how to proceed. His feedback has been limited to: "I don't hate it but I don't love it." How do you handle client situations like this?
Does anyone have suggestions for how to improve any of these options, or a different approach altogether? Should I take a poll here or somewhere else? Thanks in advance!
(Old logo issues - top image: Weak font, name is actually one word not two, middle arm of "E" is shifted oddly upward - looks too playful, elongated shadow beneath symbol looks unprofessional, symbol itself is too rounded and unfocused - supposed to be a stylized "IT" but just looks like a strange arrow.)
There seems to be a familiarity bias - he says he wants a new logo but he always picks his old logo over various alternatives we've presented. The old logo strikes me as having design issues that make it objectively bad, so I'm not sure how to proceed. His feedback has been limited to: "I don't hate it but I don't love it." How do you handle client situations like this?
Does anyone have suggestions for how to improve any of these options, or a different approach altogether? Should I take a poll here or somewhere else? Thanks in advance!
(Old logo issues - top image: Weak font, name is actually one word not two, middle arm of "E" is shifted oddly upward - looks too playful, elongated shadow beneath symbol looks unprofessional, symbol itself is too rounded and unfocused - supposed to be a stylized "IT" but just looks like a strange arrow.)