I use cheap screen protectors, not the Zagg or whatever scratch proof ones, because you can barely tell they are there and they prevent even the smallest of scratches from happening. I don't see any reason not to use them.
I read all these posts about the glass being difficult to scratch. I'm pretty anal with my stuff and keep my screens clean with iklear and a clean microfiber. And then my iPhone is kept in its own pocket in my purse, never in contact with keys, etc. Even being so careful, my iPhone got some scratches after only 2 weeks of use. The only thing I could even vaguely think of that could have scratched my screen is wearing earrings when using the phone. However the scratches were not near the top of the phone so it's a mystery. I wanted to go naked on the screen but ended up with the SPG Glas.t.r which is really nice - no loss of clarity or feel.
So a screenprotector together with a decent sleeve is the best option in your opinion?
I am using just a sleeve for my HTC. It works fine and has almost zero damages.Actually I have had all my iPhones in cases. In the past I wanted the case for some d. rop protection and a better grip - plus I have young grandkids that love to play with my phone. Then I have dropped my husband's phone on the pavement and also did the same with my iPhone 4 S. This time around, I really wanted to go naked and purchased AppleCare. My point was to just say the hell with it and enjoy the phone for itself and not spends months and a ton of money in search of the perfect case. In the end, I couldn't do it. I could envision dropping it on the pavement and having some scratching and dents but not enough to replace under AppleCare. As my slight scratches on the screen drove me to quickly put on a protector, I knew I just couldn't go with a naked phone. But that's just me.
So far my favorite case is the Switcheasy Tones. I'm actually finished with my case search and my new phone is settled in nicely.
Those SGP Glass T protectors are also pretty tough, aren't they? Might get one of those.To all the people saying the screen protector got scratched so it saved your phone screen, remember that glass is much, much tougher than a plastic screen protector. You need something at least as tough as the gorilla glass on your phone (diamond for example, or sand if you're not careful) to scratch your screen.
Those SGP Glass T protectors are also pretty tough, aren't they? Might get one of those.
That's why I might get a sleeve and a screenprotector.They are. (I'm biased as I use one of my 5.)
I don't really know what to tell you, but here's my thought process. The iPhone 5's screen, as with the 4S, 4 etc, are extremely durable and can take a beating without scratching. That being said, were all human, we all make a stupid mistake every now and then. When that mistake happens, I personally would rather have something close to the screen protecting it. Would a sleeve work? Sure, but once you take it out of the sleeve then what? Maybe this is just my excuse to justify buying the Glas.T, but at the end of the day, different strokes for different folks
It's a matter of preference. How do you expect people to quantify how necessary it is? The best you'll get is anecdotal evidence which really means nothing. Some people don't scratch their screens. Some do. Taking one person's experience or even attempting to aggregate the experiences of forum users still means nothing. Even if most Macrumors users go naked and never scratch their screens it doesn't guarantee that you won't.How necessary is a screenprotector?
By definition material A has to be harder than material B to scratch material B.You need something at least as tough as the gorilla glass on your phone (diamond for example, or sand if you're not careful) to scratch your screen.