PDA

View Full Version : Ripping off Apple icons... legal?


mulletman13
Dec 9, 2005, 05:52 PM
I checked out a couple Vista screen shots, and found their "revolutionary" QuickSearch to be a bit familiar.

Granted, the idea to search metadata/everything is fine... it's expected and a necessary advancement, however when they rip off the icon thats entirely different.

Here is a quicksearch bar with a Spotlight bar mirrored and laid on top.

http://www.filefarmer.com/mulletman13/Screens/comparison.jpg

hrmmm :-\

Jschultz
Dec 9, 2005, 06:02 PM
I checked out a couple Vista screen shots, and found their "revolutionary" QuickSearch to be a bit familiar.

Granted, the idea to search metadata/everything is fine... it's expected and a necessary advancement, however when they rip off the icon thats entirely different.

Here is a quicksearch bar with a Spotlight bar mirrored and laid on top.

http://www.filefarmer.com/mulletman13/Screens/comparison.jpg

hrmmm :-\

My spotlight magnifying glass points to the left?

mulletman13
Dec 9, 2005, 06:04 PM
Yeaa, the image is mirrored, but the pixels line up ... =(

Jschultz
Dec 9, 2005, 06:08 PM
Yeaa, the image is mirrored, but the pixels line up ... =(

Whoops, missed that part!

Yeah, it is kind of scary, isn't it? Oh well. Here's to leopard!

killuminati
Dec 9, 2005, 06:09 PM
Well it is a magnifying glass, I think it is kind of a universal symbol for searching.

desenso
Dec 9, 2005, 11:53 PM
Well it is a magnifying glass, I think it is kind of a universal symbol for searching.

Agreed. Microsoft's stem is longer anyways

GoCubsGo
Dec 10, 2005, 12:33 AM
Agreed. Microsoft's stem is longer anyways
Totally! Thank god I was worried they stole some idea!

NewbieNerd
Dec 10, 2005, 01:10 AM
Whoops, missed that part!

Yeah, it is kind of scary, isn't it? Oh well. Here's to leopard!


CHEERS!

Abstract
Dec 10, 2005, 01:20 AM
Well it is a magnifying glass, I think it is kind of a universal symbol for searching.

Actually, it isn't. It is the symbol for "zoom" though.

MS copied Apple. They probably use Macs once in a while to see the strong points of OSX, and either stole the symbol knowingly, or subconsciously did so without realizing it. I'm hoping the latter is true, but MS really could have copied it.

And the tilt of the magnifying glass isn't universal either, as they don't need to be at an angle to signify anything. It's weird that the magnifying glass is tipped at the same angle, but in the opposite direction.

iMeowbot
Dec 10, 2005, 01:21 AM
The old Windows find dialog had one too.
http://www.duke.edu/~dhewitt/images/find.jpg
It must be a conspiracy! :eek:

killuminati
Dec 10, 2005, 11:32 AM
As much as I hate microsoft, I have to say that what you guys are saying is ridiculous. I'm sure if I had nothing to do with my time, I could look around OS X and find something that they 'stole' from microsoft.

Who cares if windows has the same search icon as macs, maybe if they stole the mail icon for outlook I could see why it would be worth discussing but really. :rolleyes:

MacFan782040
Dec 10, 2005, 11:45 AM
The old Windows find dialog had one too.
http://www.duke.edu/~dhewitt/images/find.jpg
It must be a conspiracy! :eek:

Ugh that picture is so ugly. :eek:

steveedge
Dec 10, 2005, 09:40 PM
Icons like all other "original" images are controlled by copyright, so to know the answer to this dilemma, one would need to know if the "original" icon in question were copyright protected.
It may seem silly as a user of these apps that contain the image, but if you created the original image, it wouldn't seem so silly. ;)
However, all these companies know this "fact" so it is very unlikely that any of them would use an unlicensed image without permission....unless they just like to gamble ;)

mulletman13
Dec 10, 2005, 11:19 PM
Yeaa, a couple hours after posting this I realized it was kindof stupid to post about.

Cheers to posting while under the influence :o