PDA

View Full Version : Illustrator, photoshop




davidwes
Jan 11, 2006, 09:35 AM
Can someone explain to me the main difference between these two programs?

Also can someone recommend one. My company is trying to create postcards and these are the file formats the printer will take. We have a couple of pictures that we want to put together with some text, and maybe edit the pictures as well. We have used both pictures of real people and drawn cartoon images as well.

Thank you for your input.



iGary
Jan 11, 2006, 09:38 AM
Can someone explain to me the main difference between these two programs?

Also can someone recommend one. My company is trying to create postcards and these are the file formats the printer will take. We have a couple of pictures that we want to put together with some text, and maybe edit the pictures as well. We have used both pictures of real people and drawn cartoon images as well.

Thank you for your input.

One is vector one is raster.

Have a look at those on Google.

kretzy
Jan 11, 2006, 09:42 AM
Basically, Photoshop is for editing and manipulating photos and using them in a variety of ways. You would be able to created cards etc with it. Illustrator is more like a freehand "Paint" style program, though much much more advanced. Photoshop is the most widely used program as it allows both the photo editing abilities and to an extent the features of illustrator. I don't use these programs very often, but when I do, Photoshop seems to be the better program. I'll add, this is a VERY basic summary. There are many other people who make a living from these programs who can tell you more. ;)

Sdashiki
Jan 11, 2006, 09:46 AM
One is vector one is raster.

Have a look at those on Google.


'nuff said.

if you dont know the difference between Vector & Raster then you dont need to know the difference between PS and Illustrator.

Lol. Right?

Seasought
Jan 11, 2006, 10:02 AM
Also can someone recommend one. My company is trying to create postcards and these are the file formats the printer will take. We have a couple of pictures that we want to put together with some text, and maybe edit the pictures as well. We have used both pictures of real people and drawn cartoon images as well.

Can you get both of them?

If you had to pick one I'd say go for Photoshop. Now, if your postcards are going to be primarily all text with text effects you're better off with Illustrator in my opinion.

davidwes
Jan 12, 2006, 04:04 PM
Can you get both of them?

If you had to pick one I'd say go for Photoshop. Now, if your postcards are going to be primarily all text with text effects you're better off with Illustrator in my opinion.

Well, I looked at the pricing, and with photoshop going for 649, and indesign going for 699, but those two plus illustrator as a bundle will only cost 899.00!!!

So I should get both it seems.

I suggest pages for the layout program, but they wanted something that was cross platform. And most printers do not take pages format (or pdf format).

Blue Velvet
Jan 12, 2006, 04:08 PM
And most printers do not take pages format (or pdf format).

Most, if not all, printers will take a PDF.

But you have to know what you're doing to put a PDF together properly for print... in fact, whatever software you're using, you have to know something about how to prepare files for press.

Don't expect the software to do it all for you.

lazyboy922
Jan 12, 2006, 04:49 PM
'nuff said.

if you dont know the difference between Vector & Raster then you dont need to know the difference between PS and Illustrator.

Lol. Right?


LOL! My thoughts exactly. In this case, maybe MacPaint will suffice ;-)

ATD
Jan 12, 2006, 06:37 PM
Well, I looked at the pricing, and with photoshop going for 649, and indesign going for 699, but those two plus illustrator as a bundle will only cost 899.00!!!

So I should get both it seems.


If you are willing to spend a little more you can get Acrobat as well. The CS is great deal.

Boelman
Jan 12, 2006, 10:34 PM
I love photoshop. I am still working out how to use everything that it has to offer, but for professional graphics and presentation it has everything i need. I have just been using illustrator, and as I am not much of an artist, this has proved to be a bit harder to work out. Still learning

cgratti
Jan 12, 2006, 11:26 PM
If your going to do more with photographs then get photoshop, if you want to make logos and illustrations, then get Illustrator.

Both of these programs have a learning curve, you wont learn these overnight.

dogbone
Jan 15, 2006, 06:22 PM
Well, I looked at the pricing, and with photoshop going for 649, and indesign going for 699, but those two plus illustrator as a bundle will only cost 899.00!!!

So I should get both it seems.


You mean "so I should get all *three*"

You've just answered you're own question haven't you.

For what you have described you will find that a combo of Photoshop and InDesign will be all you need.