MacBook Pro 7200 RPM effect on noise, battery life, performance?

I'd like to know this too.

Spies said:

I'd like to know this too.

Click to expand...

Whatever it is the performance benifit has to be worth it. When i book my G4 PB off an external FW hard drive it FLYS!!!

Good question.

As I will usually run my MBP as a desktop replacement I didn't even consider the 7200rpm (which I opted for) vs. 5400rpm in terms of battery life.

The difference in battery life is negligible. Barefeats.com did a comparison not long ago. Go for the 7200 rpm drive.

5400 is a thing of the past. This 7200rpm whips along. I suggest it, highly.

What are some benchmarks for this faster drive? Everything starts up fast with the slower drive I can't see the point of having a faster drive. What apps would take advantage of it?

BornAgainMac said:

What are some benchmarks for this faster drive? Everything starts up fast with the slower drive I can't see the point of having a faster drive. What apps would take advantage of it?

Click to expand...

Spotlight, Finder, starting any program, copy/pasting files etc.

BareFeats has a nice benchmark comparing the MacBook Pro with the stock 5,400rpm HDD vs. the 7,200rpm HDD.

http://www.barefeats.com/5472.html

fyzle said:

Spotlight, Finder, starting any program, copy/pasting files etc.

Click to expand...

the barefeats article above suggests that you will not realize any speed advantages with the above unless you are transferring very large files (video, audio)

Winstonp said:

5400 is a thing of the past. This 7200rpm whips along. I suggest it, highly.

Click to expand...

And here I am on a 4200RPM iBook.

dmw007 said:

BareFeats has a nice benchmark comparing the MacBook Pro with the stock 5,400rpm HDD vs. the 7,200rpm HDD.

http://www.barefeats.com/5472.html

Click to expand...

Looks like it's time to upgrade the crappy 4200 rpm drive in my PB.

Another vote for 7200, can't even hear the 7200 in my mbp when its accessing, also the power requirements difference between it and a 5400 drive are miniscule, so no battery issues either.

i defy anyone to work out whether it makes an mbp hotter! there all hot and besides apple wouldn't offer it as an option if it couldnt handle it would they?

Zips along too

If I had a 7200 internal, I doubt it would make too much noise/heat difference to me, especially when most of the time I have a 7200 external also plugged in making noise louder than my 5400. As for battery life, for me I have my MBP plugged in most of the time at the moment, (no Airport as of yet, still hanging in for Express AV in the near future). If it was unplugged, it would perhaps mean dropping 20 minutes of life I guess.

It's the 7200 all the way.

As an owner of a MacBookPro (only slightly gloating) with a 7200RPM drive, I can say that I am fine with the battery performance. I also notice that the finder is very snappy and I attribute some of that to the drive speed. I didn't even hesitate when I purchased mine, and I don't regret that aspect of it. (What do I regret you say? That maybe I should have waited for the 17". Ahh well.)

Are you guys doing the install yourself or taking it to somewhere else? I don't want switching out the drive on my MBP to ruin my warranty. Thanks.

lilstewart said:

And here I am on a 4200RPM iBook.

Click to expand...

Same here....

kkapoor said:

The difference in battery life is negligible. Barefeats.com did a comparison not long ago. Go for the 7200 rpm drive.

Click to expand...

I read the same on Toms Harware. Here's an article showing some in depth battery and speed benchmarks.

http://www.mobilityguru.com/2003/10/31/fast_and_furious/page3.html

Basically, battery life changes by 5-10 minutes, but boot time, applications opening and read/write are all greatly improved.