Arn,
What I appreciate is your being the second person in the Mac rumor/speculation game to be open minded about public discussion of the topic. In fact, I'm very pleasantly amazed.
The other "rumor sites" are run by guys who hide behind their byline, and never engage in open, online discussions (I have two very specific such sites in my mind...).
There are two reasons MacWhispers exists, and will continue to exist. First, I enjoy writing, writing about what I know and love, and I know and love the whole Mac scene and lifestyle. That makes MacWhispers a joyous hobby for me. Secondly, because of my work developing products for DVForge, I have recently (since late October) found myself in the unusual position of having daily communication on a wide range of hardware directed topics with many dozens of "behind the scenes" engineering and manufacturing company personnel... many from within the very same companies from whom Apple sources its own components and services.
MacWhispers gives me a public forum to do something I have long wanted to do, but have not until now had the information sources at hand to do: Knowledgably promote discussion about Apple's hardware development efforts and newest products.
I'm a fairly public person, with an unusual willingness to open most of my life up to public scrutiny, and have intentionally maintained that attitude for many years. As a result, I've been both praised and blasted many, many times over the years, and so much more so since the web has come of age, that I'm all but inured to it all.
This winter I attracted a great deal of virtual ink painting me as an evil villain over my past felony convictions and my one-day misadventure in misrepresenting my reseller status of Green Design's nice computer desks on a start up web store I opened. While that was happening, I was divesting several business interests, and was accepting the job of managing a start up computer product manufacturing company, DVForge. Our first products have received more praise than panning, so that's going well. We had a wonderful time exhibiting at MacWorld Expo, and have been growing very rapidly since then.
I love being immersed in the technology lifestyle, and in the daily online Mac community very much. Consider me a fixture here.
The Mac rumor scene has fascinated me, as it's grown through the years. What I've noticed more and more is that a great many people don't read these sites as "entertainment;" they read them thinking that all or most information shown is true, and they then really make their buying decisions based on what they read. To me, rumor sites have been only a lighthearted bit of entertainment. But, I have realized a lot of very nice people depend on "some" degree of accuracy from these sites.
Raw speculation on a public site, connected with any attempt to legitimize it as more than that can hurt people. Folks, to a degree, believe this stuff. So, I've been shifting the MacWhispers format more toward clearly delineating between the facts and the speculation. And, while I have to be fairly careful about explicitly stating my sources for any particular information, I do consider a flat statement from a manufacturing manager (for instance), one with a prior record of providing accurate information, to be "fact" within the scope of a future products discussion. Anything less than that I consider merely a "whisper," and I editorially note it as such.
I won't speak to Ryan's and Nick's efforts at sustained accuracy and adherence to a no-bull editorial policy wih their sites; but, I will say that I am growing to like the tack chosen by MacRumors... a lot. I especially like the growing idea I see you implementing where you lean more and more toward a conservative interpretation of available info. That's the way to grow credibility and, more importantly, not to hurt the visitors who take what you say as gospel.
I appreciate your willingness to talk about what has been previously promoted by others as some sort of highly clandestine, secret activity. It isn't. It's just a few people within our industry who have better access to information than the general public making an honest effort to share some of what we know.
Keep up the good work here. (and... when I get the MacWhispers forums running in a month or so, feel free to drop by, any time.)
Jack Campbell
MacWhispers