PDA

View Full Version : AFI - DecemberUnderground; a short review




Scarlet Fever
Jun 5, 2006, 09:42 AM
PRENOTE: All comments made here are personal opinion, unless otherwise noted. Please express opinion, but not flame others; music is a very personal subject. If its not constructive, dont say it. Sorry about the slightly hipocritical title :p

I got a copy of AFIs new album, DecemberUnderground the other day.
ive heard the Davey Havok said he wants each album to be different to the last. this one sure is different.

It starts off with what i think is the least AFI-style intro. Initiation on the Art Of Drowning was an intro; Prelude 12 21 isn't. The notes at the start sound almost like something from Harry Potter. Then the drums come in, ever so slightly reminicent of STS - Miseria Canteri. The strings in the background sound like something from a modern R&B/Rap song. As you can tell, its not my favourite intro ive heard.

Kill Caustic starts off sounding like slipknot, then moves to the distinctive modern AFI song. This is probably my favourite song on the album. Hunter put distortion on his bass! :eek: Davey seems to have learnt how to scream every organ in his body out in this song :p

You can feel a bit of the band we love in Miss Murder, but its very deeply hidden. The giveaway is in the bridge. It starts off sounding something like Green Day, then moves onto something which resembles AFI. Davey shows that he has matured a lot in the recording of this album; his voice is almost unrecognisable from the old-school AFI songs. This song has its peaks and pitfalls. To me, this song is good, but its not what i thought the band was. More screaming and a definative, rocky chorus, makes this song is a memorable one.

Summer Shudder has a heavy use of electronics in the intro, and a sound similar to P.O.D. The chorus is addictive, but not AFI. Jade seems to remain the simple guitarist, not showing off like some other bands of the same genre. Its a good song overall, but i can't seem to bring myself to say i like it.

In the time between records, Davey's voice has changed dramatically. The Interview starts off with his voice with that same kind of nasal tone as Placebo. The verses are relatively quiet, but picks up in the choruses. It ends with a sound like something you would hear at a church, ironically enough.

As the album progresses to Love Like Winter, i was wondering what band i was listening to; a modern disco band or the same people who wrote the shortfastloud music of Very Proud of Ya. It sounds like something played at a school formal, not its afterparty by underground bands. They have changed so much in their decade-and-a-half in the music industry. Its an alright song, not the worst. I think it would be great in a dark room with lighting effects and a smoke machine, but not on the same set as File 13.

Affliction is probably the most rocky song on the album, with a definate AFI vibe at the start. The chorus isn't, though. A good song, but not the highlight of the album.

The Missing Frame starts off with a drum beat similar to the Grates Trampoline. Then Jade comes in with a distorted guitar and a wah pedal. Davey sings his stuff, and takes it into the chorus. Adam does the standard disco drum beat, which is a step in a different direction for him. Overall, a good song, which i can find a lot to like about.

Kiss And Control starts with the new typical AFI style; electric drums, davey singing softly. In some parts of the start, it sounds a bit like a folk song. Very slow and dark.

The Killing Light has a catchy chorus, which i enjoi. Hunter has another (failed) go at a bass solo. There is more effects than skill in him now, which is sad.

The album continues on to 37mm, which shows just how much each member really has changed; the drum rythm is nothing like anything else the band has released before. The guitars are full of effects. The vocals have reverb all over the place. And Hunter had a day off from his deathly quick bass work.

Endlessly She Said has a nice mix of guitar and bass in the intro, and the bass continues into the verse, and to an extent in the chorus. Not a great song, but not bad. If it came on while i was gaming, i would leave it on.

The last song on the album leaves me with a sense of emptyness, wanting, or maybe expecting more from the band i love. Like the intro, and most of the album, its just not AFI. I think the best intro/outro they have done is on the Art Of Drowning. Morningstar was an awesome close to an awesome album.

Overall, it is definately a change. If you liked STS, you will probably like this album as well. For people like me, who love their older, teen garage rawk style, this album will leave you disappointed. I can't bring myself to say i don't like it, but i think it is their least talented release ever.
I hope for the bands sake that it does well, because they are living their dream. This is what they have always wanted, and its right at their fingertips. They have it set.
I give it 2.5/5, plus half a mark for daveys awesome tat on his back and Hunters awesome Fender Jazz Bass :p



XNine
Jun 5, 2006, 11:35 AM
Personally, as a fan of AFI from BEFORE their MTV sellout, I haven't liked anything they've done since before they were on MTV. MTV ruins bands. Producers ruin bands. When you can tell the band has gone out and hired some preppy record producer that does things the industry way, instead of providing any actual talent, you know the band is no longer worth listening to. This is what led to Metallica's undoing with the Black album. After that, it was all down hill, and their last album, Saint Anger only proved how bad they've become.

Same goes for AFI.

63dot
Jun 12, 2006, 10:02 PM
last week i saw the singer of afi, sans makeup of course, in a guitar center store in california...my guitar buddy pointed him out to me

later when i saw him on the mtv music awards, i noticed the same tattoo he had on is arm

...he was with his friend, or bandmate, checking out the bass guitar wall and none of the workers noticed them...i guess anonimity is a good thing and i wonder what marilyn manson looks like without the makeup

Diddiyo
Jun 14, 2006, 03:03 AM
I dont like it that much yet. Maybe i need some time to get used to hit.

Scarlet Fever
Jun 15, 2006, 07:20 AM
...he was with his friend, or bandmate, checking out the bass guitar wall and none of the workers noticed them...i guess anonimity is a good thing and i wonder what marilyn manson looks like without the makeup
you saw Hunter?!?!?! Can i have your eyes? :p

Hunter is my idol, my god (before STS and DecemberUnderground came out). Art Of Drowning was an awesome album. I can nearly play it straight through!

Warbrain
Jun 15, 2006, 07:45 AM
The reason why his voiced changed in between records is because he had to have throat surgery to remove cysts that had developed on his vocal chords. The result is that a person's voice while singing is deeper.

63dot
Jun 16, 2006, 06:44 PM
you saw Hunter?!?!?! Can i have your eyes? :p

Hunter is my idol, my god (before STS and DecemberUnderground came out). Art Of Drowning was an awesome album. I can nearly play it straight through!

very regular looking dudes, compared to what i saw on the mtv music awards, but i have no idea if they use that much makeup all the time in their shows

years ago, i got to talk with steve wynn of the dream syndicate about gigging and playing guitar and he was a nice guy...a lot of my friends who worshipped the band were jealous of me but i wasn't into the dream syndicate at all

another time i got to talk with kelly johnson of girlschool and again i wasn't a fan of her band

i would love to run into someone i really admire, like neil young or coldplay, and talk with them...or even someone very obscure, but who i like