Hmm...I don't think it's may be stolen just because he don't have the book and the CD. I own a Laptop and I lost the CD and book myself. Think because he said may have scratch because he just being honest. Maybe the scratch is not visible but examin closely enough it may have scratches. I think you got a sweet deal, however you should have ask if it come with Apple Care. If it does, then you got a sweet deal. I don't think it quite a good deal if it doesn't still have Apple Care on it. Apple product are extremely expensive to repair when the time come. Some people skim out on Apple Care, I don't blame then. Apple Care is ways expensive. But there is many horror story for broken Mac. 🙁