17th Street Photo - any bad experiences?

[Westside guy]

Hi,

These guys seem to have really good reviews - how have your experiences been? They have the Sigma 10-20mm in stock, and I'm about ready to pull the trigger (B&H and Adorama are out of stock).

Thanks!

Edit: I just saw Lovesong's positive comments on another thread - man I hate Macrumors search dysfunction.

[Grimace]

http://www.resellerratings.com/store/17th_Street_Photo

Looks good. Lots of shady camera places in NYC but this isn't one of them.

[seenew]

I've used them before to buy my dad some filters for Christmas. No problems here (just with UPS leaving the package where the dogs could tear it open).

[Westside guy]

Thank you both for the feedback. So, I pulled the trigger... but at the last minute, after reviewing a lot of example pictures over on Nikonians and DPreview, I went with the Tokina 12-24 instead of the Sigma 10-20. I felt like the distortion the Sigma has at the extreme edges would drive me batty (but that's just me - I know a lot of people love the Sigma). The Tokina has worse CA, but that's much easier to deal with.