Is the MacPRo a LOUD computer?

[jigen08]

I've had a MacPro since February. For the past month and a half it's become loud with noisy fans. I can be working in Maya or Shake (processor intensive) or watching a DVD only and it's loud. Also the revving often shifts, with periods of greater loudness, without me changing activities.

Here are my current temps (it's nosiy now):

CPU A - 104
CPU B- 106
Mem Module 1 - 173
Mem Module 2 - 189
Mem Module 3 - 167
Mem Module 4 - 158
Power Supply 1 - 121
Power Supply 2 - 121

I called AppleCare to ask if this is a problem. They're able to handle OS questions, so my questions were a little beyond their domain: they couldn't tell me if these temperatures were bad or if the MacPro is characterized as a noisy computer. They said I should take it in if it shows signs of problems (slowdowns, crashing, etc.) but otherwise it's probably fine. I've had no problems, other than having to turn the speaker up to hear a DVD, no slowdown, etc.

I keep going back and forth on deciding to take it in, as it's a day (or half) wasted, I don't have a car right now, and it might be fine (and although I like the Apple Store I find shopping malls monstrous and unbearable).

So the question is...Is the MacPro a noisy computer? Is it just the post-winter temperatures running it warmer? If it is noisy, is there anything I can do to make it quiet, besides headphones?

Thanks, Happy Memorial Day to everyone.

[drbrog]

I've had mine since August and its whisper quiet.

[dpaanlka]

Did you put non-Apple-spec memory into it? My Mac Pro is one of the quietest desktop computers I have ever owned.

[spaz8]

Are those temps in fahrenheit? i'm assuming its not celcius.

[Sedulous]

It could be your optical drive.

[chelsel]

Those temperatures, especially memory, seem extraordinarily high...

[Cromulent]

Put it in Celsius for gods sake :). I've never got fahrenheit.

[Dark Dragoon]

Do you have the ATi X1900XT graphics card, if you do check the intake it might be clogged with dust.

Though the temperature of the RAM seem a little high.

[cwedl]

Put it in Celsius for gods sake :). I've never got fahrenheit.

whats this fahrenheit you talk of? hasn't been used since metric. :p

[Eraserhead]

CPU A - 104
CPU B- 106
Mem Module 1 - 173
Mem Module 2 - 189
Mem Module 3 - 167
Mem Module 4 - 158
Power Supply 1 - 121
Power Supply 2 - 121


Temperatures in Centigrade:

CPU A - 40
CPU B - 41
Mem 1 - 78
Mem 2 - 87
Mem 3 - 75
Mem 4 - 70
Power 1 - 49
Power 2 - 49

I used the conversion factor of [(deg F) -32]/1.8=(deg C)

The RAM is clearly overheating, if it's Apple RAM call Applecare to get it replaced. They should be able to post it straight to you to fix.

FWIW when my PC overheated, the company Evesham (a local company) could deal with what temperatures were too high, if AppleCare can't then that's very poor, and in that case ask to talk to their supervisor.

[AppleMan101]

I know it may sound a little stupid, but have you checked that there's nothing blocking the vents?

I vacuumed out the dust of my 18 month old iMac and saw a reduction of about 60% in all my fan speeds and it's only on my desk...which isn't very dusty. If you MacPro is on the floor, or even worse on a carpet floor, it's likely to suck up a lot of dust, so it's worth checking that out.

If everything else fails, try repairing permissions, resetting the PRAM, fsck-ing and all the usual witchcraft.

[Eraserhead]

I know it may sound a little stupid, but have you checked that there's nothing blocking the vents?

I vacuumed out the dust of my 18 month old iMac and saw a reduction of about 60% in all my fan speeds and it's only on my desk...which isn't very dusty. If you MacPro is on the floor, or even worse on a carpet floor, it's likely to suck up a lot of dust, so it's worth checking that out.

Very true, that's a good idea, computers on the floor collect stupid amounts of dust (like a tumble dryer), though the RAM is still very very hot.

[Evergreen]

You can put heatsinks on the ram if they don't have them already.

[fairnymph]

My MP is very quiet, except for the dvd drive, which is INSANELY loud -- I thought it was defective using it at first!

[jigen08]

Thanks for the help. Sorry for not using Centigrade; I keep forgetting we (the US) haven't conquered the rest of the world yet and forced you all to convert to our old ways.

It is Apple memory and I think I'll take it in after all. If it's a "quiet" computer, mine is clearly abnormal. I've owned two G5s and neither sounded like this. I've checked inside for dust and it seems clean, although I'm unable to pull out the fans like I can with my G5s - is this normal? Should I be able to pull the fans out?

Thanks again.

[jigen08]

My G5 fans seem to run over 1100 rpms.

My MP fans run in the 500-600 rpms. Is this perhaps the problem?

[synth3tik]

It's the RAM. The other temps seem normal at least compared to my MP. The RAM though is high. I use non-Apple, but Apple certified RAM from OWC, and my RAM temps are around 15-20 degrees cooler. Also my fans are so quite I get irritated by the sound of 4 HDs spinning. If you have Apple RAM send it in, If its non-Apple. Check that is is certified and has the certified heat sinks. If not you'll need to bit the bullet and by new RAM.

[trainguy77]

My G5 fans seem to run over 1100 rpms.

My MP fans run in the 500-600 rpms. Is this perhaps the problem?

are ALL your fans running that speed? because thats normal if its running at 500-600rpm and being really noisy something is very wrong. Mine run at 500 RPM for everything but the powersupply which runs at 600 RPM and the exhaust is also 600. So if yours is noisy open it up and see if somethings on the fans.

[jigen08]

I thought I'd revisit this post and say thanks again for advice and suggestions and let you know what the final result was. I took the MP into the Apple Store (which is a great place, the only shop I actually enjoy going into, but a little bit of a pain for me to get to - hence my initial reluctance) and let the Geniuses work their magic.

It turns out it was a faulty graphics card which was probably causing additional heat issues; they swapped it out and two days later it's back and blissfully silent.

So now I can say it is a quiet computer. If yours isn't quiet, take it in to the Geniuses.

Thanks again all.

[gkarris]

Thanks again all.


YOU'RE WELCOME...:p