PDA

View Full Version : Will I need an InvisibleShield with iPod classic?




writeous
Sep 19, 2007, 12:04 PM
I was just wondering, with the matte finish on the iPod Classic, does it really acquire protection like the 5G iPods? I have a 30 GB 5G with, which is swarmed with dead pixels, so I'll only be using it as a spare harddrive, cause Im not chucking out 60 plus bucks to get it fixed. But anyway, it has an IS on it, so I also wanted to know would that fit the Classic model, because I was just going to get a replacement for my 5G 30 GB iPod until I saw the Classic.



ivi7
Sep 19, 2007, 12:07 PM
I was just wondering, with the matte finish on the iPod Classic, does it really acquire protection like the 5G iPods? I have a 30 GB 5G with, which is swarmed with dead pixels, so I'll only be using it as a spare harddrive, cause Im not chucking out 60 plus bucks to get it fixed. But anyway, it has an IS on it, so I also wanted to know would that fit the Classic model, because I was just going to get a replacement for my 5G 30 GB iPod until I saw the Classic.

I don't think you'll need the shield.

slu
Sep 19, 2007, 12:23 PM
I have a 160 GB classic and I put a 60/80 5G agent18 case on it. It fits fine. While the matte finish will not show scratches, if you want to watch any video at all, I'd recommend screen protection at least. Plus, I don't like scratching up the back.

But is all comes down to what you can deal with. I know people that never watch video and use no case or shield and their iPods are all scratched up...but they don't care.

Me, I watch video and want to protect the resale value of the iPod (even though I have never sold one!), so I use protection :D

Roy Hobbs
Sep 19, 2007, 02:08 PM
I ordered an Invisible Shield last week, the chrome back on the Classic will scratch just from you looking at it.

I like to keep my iPods as scratch free as possible so I can sell them easier.

k91191
Sep 19, 2007, 02:32 PM
DO NOT BUY AN INVISIBLE SHIELD

I just got mine for my 160GB Classic today... It didn't fit at all.

The plastic circle for the middle button was smaller than the button. The scroll wheel was okay. The front left about a 2mm gap around the whole click wheel.
And the back didn't even reach the sides of the iPod and the whole for the dock cable was huge.

I had to call up for a replacement and they said it'd arrive in 1-2 weeks! :eek::eek:

What kind of business are they trying to run?

superman1988
Sep 19, 2007, 04:00 PM
Is the invisibleshield a good product? i have heard good and bad things about them, anyone like or dislike them?

SamIchi
Sep 19, 2007, 04:14 PM
DO NOT BUY AN INVISIBLE SHIELD

I just got mine for my 160GB Classic today... It didn't fit at all.

The plastic circle for the middle button was smaller than the button. The scroll wheel was okay. The front left about a 2mm gap around the whole click wheel.
And the back didn't even reach the sides of the iPod and the whole for the dock cable was huge.

I had to call up for a replacement and they said it'd arrive in 1-2 weeks! :eek::eek:

What kind of business are they trying to run?

Sucks to hear that, Maybe they are redesigning it, cause they've had too many complaints? I dunno. I'm thinkin about a 160 gigger and shield was the first thing that came to mind. Maybe I'll wait til more people get it and see if it improves.

Is the invisibleshield a good product? i have heard good and bad things about them, anyone like or dislike them?

I got one for my Gen 2 Nano, Worked great, fit nicely. The screen was prolly the only thing that need protection but I got the whole thing covered. I haven't used it with any other pods, but the next one I get I'll probably get the shield. I hate cases, and the sock is unreliable. I used the sock on my 4G Clickwheel pod and got 2 scratches on the screen when the sock was on :( I still like the sock but the shield gives indeniable coverage.

JDN
Sep 19, 2007, 04:20 PM
I got the socks today, brilliant! So simple, and do the perfect job. I hate invisible shield things and hard cases, all i wanted was something to keep the classic in so it didnt get scratched. Socks, get them, love them, be done with it!

Andrew07
Sep 19, 2007, 04:56 PM
As a kid, my mom would always put stickers on my toys for me. I got my girlfriend to put the crystal film shield on my iPhone. Unfortunately she was at work yesterday and I attempted to put a full-bodied invisible shield on my iPod video...BIG MISTAKE. It is extremely flimsy so I found it nearly impossible to line up the corners and apply it across evenly. And even though I followed the directions to avoid finger smudging, the corners smudged up instantly. Also, since it's sticker-like there no easy way to peel it up and off to get rid of crap/air bubbles across the screen without introducing more marks across it.

Roy Hobbs
Sep 19, 2007, 05:08 PM
As a kid, my mom would always put stickers on my toys for me. I got my girlfriend to put the crystal film shield on my iPhone. Unfortunately she was at work yesterday and I attempted to put a full-bodied invisible shield on my iPod video...BIG MISTAKE. It is extremely flimsy so I found it nearly impossible to line up the corners and apply it across evenly. And even though I followed the directions to avoid finger smudging, the corners smudged up instantly. Also, since it's sticker-like there no easy way to peel it up and off to get rid of crap/air bubbles across the screen without introducing more marks across it.

spray a little more solution on the invisible shield and its like new again

writeous
Sep 20, 2007, 06:55 AM
As a kid, my mom would always put stickers on my toys for me. I got my girlfriend to put the crystal film shield on my iPhone. Unfortunately she was at work yesterday and I attempted to put a full-bodied invisible shield on my iPod video...BIG MISTAKE. It is extremely flimsy so I found it nearly impossible to line up the corners and apply it across evenly. And even though I followed the directions to avoid finger smudging, the corners smudged up instantly. Also, since it's sticker-like there no easy way to peel it up and off to get rid of crap/air bubbles across the screen without introducing more marks across it.

The air bubbles and marks go away after a month or two. Atleast thats what happened with mines.

MattG
Sep 20, 2007, 07:09 AM
I have a 160 GB classic and I put a 60/80 5G agent18 case on it. It fits fine. While the matte finish will not show scratches, if you want to watch any video at all, I'd recommend screen protection at least. Plus, I don't like scratching up the back.

But is all comes down to what you can deal with. I know people that never watch video and use no case or shield and their iPods are all scratched up...but they don't care.

Me, I watch video and want to protect the resale value of the iPod (even though I have never sold one!), so I use protection :D

Another vote here for the Agent 18 case -- I just got one and it rocks.