Vaja or Casemate? Owners of these please help

[Merser]

Ok guys, I have narrowed down my choices to the following 2 cases but I have a few questions for those of you who have used these cases.

My first choice would be the Vaja iVolution.

http://www.vajacases.com/home/home_en.html?Prod=mobile-apple-iphone&ini=cap30Ii&c=6&it=1&s=1

I dont mind dropping the money on this case cause it simply looks beautiful, but heres my question for users...

Do you find that the "home button" is difficult to press. I read one review somewhere that mentioned the leather covered home button requires an annoying amount of pressure to use. Would you agree??

I know there are other options in the vaja line that offer an exposed button, but I want this design due to its 4 corner coverage.

My second choice would be the case mate.

http://www.case-mate.com/phones/apple/iphonesignature;jsessionid=0a0014481f43ea3a3e85ad7743f68864c2fe7b2522e4.e3eTaxiNaN0Te34Pa38Ta38Qaxv0

This design does away with the covered button, but is it as high quality as the vaja? I still want something with quality build and construction. Also I noticed that the belt clip pin is a screw on design. Anyone find that this comes unscrewed easily? Anyone have the optional holster that you can buy with it? Does it hold it in there securely?

I would be curious as to your feedback on these cases. Please let me know.

Thanks in advance...

[yOyOYoo]

how thick are these cases compared to, say

1) Agent 18 (too thick and too slippery)
2) Seidio Rubberized case (which I currently have and love the thinness, but hate the poor quality of)

[Lenow]

I have owned both the Casemate and the Vaja. There is simply no comparison in terms of quality and longevity. The Casemate has a serious design flaw in the belt clip; it isn't sewn into the body, but glued and it will come off after just a little use and a little pressure. The Vaja leather is beautiful, form fitting and the clip is indestructible. I have owned Vaja for other PDAs and they just make the best product of any manufacturer.