Firewire 3.5" Enclosures - Recommendations? Things to Keep in Mind?

[Xtreambar]

I'm planning on buying my own enclosure and HD instead of a pre-made package because 1) the prices are generally a little cheaper and 2) some hard drives have 5 year warranties (most externals only have 1 year, Seagates have 3 year).

1) Do you have any recommendations for 3.5" enclosures with Firewire?

2) Do you have anything to keep in mind when buying? Perhaps some brands to just stay the hell away from? I know I should buy a metal case with a passive cooler rather than a plastic case with a fan.

[Consultant]

With all externals, when powering off, after ejecting, wait 10 seconds or so for the drive to spin down before powering off.

Yes, metal one would work, but somehow many metals ones use non-heat-conducting plastic tray or rubber washers for mounting the drive.

[operator207]

Oxford 924 chipset for the firewire. NOT Prolific. Prolific suck.

Something that takes SATA2 inside and eSATA outside. If your lucky, you can keep at least the enclosure around for a laptop or 2.

Fan's are ok, as long as the case is not crap. I have one with and one without. The fan really does not do much, but does more than nothing.

I bought this: Rosewill RX81-MP-SC- SLV 3.5" SATA to USB & 1394 a/b & eSATA External Enclosure (Silver) - Retail (http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817182123) at NewEgg. Then bought a 1tb drive to put in it.

The only downfall is the blue LED. Its pretty damned bright. it stays on, and blinks when data is being written or accessed. Electrical tape can fix that.

The case it built pretty tough, their is an inner case that slides inside of the outer case. All aluminum.


I bought my external drive this way because I did not like the specs on any of the all-in-ones out there. It might be a few bucks more expensive, but I have a "server class" 5 year warranty drive in an enclosure that will do FW400 FW 800 eSata and USB2. Most of the other ones I looked at had 1 or maybe 2 connections, and had a warranty of 1 year.

[rpaloalto]

If you want to make your own always look for ones that have the oxford fire wire chip-sets like the last poster commented about
owc has very reliable low cost enclosures I have used many of theirs for both optical and HD

http://eshop.macsales.com/item/Other%20World%20Computing/MEFW912U2/

[Dimwhit]

This is the one I have:

http://eshop.macsales.com/item/Other%20World%20Computing/MEFW912AL2/

I love it. They have a single-drive version of the enclosure, too.

[xisforextreme]

Hey,
I'm also looking to buy an external HD for my Macbook (2Ghz core duo first edition).
Firstly, sorry if this is a stupid question but I've been out of the Mac scene for a while (1 1/2 years on expedition in the south pacific) so I have no idea what's going on :(.
Is it possible to boot from a USB external HD with my current Macbook? If it is possible is it desirable (ie. stable/fast enough)? I ask because I remember having huge problems with my iMac g4 and iBook g4 trying to find a compatible disk.
Secondly, say I don't use the ExHD as a boot disk - would you guys give a usb link-up your seal of approval?(If say the drive was just used as a file storage/backup drive):o
Thanks!

[Xtreambar]

Macbooks can't do Firewire 1394b, correct?

[wjk94061]

The enclosures with Oxford chipsets (see http://www.oxsemi.com/products/storage/das.html) seem the most popular with MacOS X users. These come with single and duel SATA drives bays. Oxford's 936 (hardware RAID 5) chipset is coming. I expect it'll take 6 - 9 months to get the software (e.g., rebuild array from drive failure) right. While the Oxford chipset keep up with Firewire 800, keep in mind a lot of the bandwidth of modern SATA drives is left in the enclosure. Take a look at the datasheet for the Barracuda ES.2 (http://www.seagate.com/docs/pdf/datasheet/disc/ds_barracuda_es_2.pdf).

Today, I'd go with a duel drive, Oxford based enclosure, and two ES.2 running stripped (RAID 0 - see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RAID). In 18 months (another turn of Moore's Law - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moores_law), look a buying a quad drive enclosure with RAID 5 or 6 in hardware.

[jollyraider]

I bought this: Rosewill RX81-MP-SC- SLV 3.5" SATA to USB & 1394 a/b & eSATA External Enclosure (Silver) - Retail (http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817182123) at NewEgg. Then bought a 1tb drive to put in it.

The only downfall is the blue LED. Its pretty damned bright. it stays on, and blinks when data is being written or accessed. Electrical tape can fix that.

The case it built pretty tough, their is an inner case that slides inside of the outer case. All aluminum.


I second the Rosewill! These are the perfect enclosures for Macs. They are indeed tough and come in aluminum in black or silver(aluminum) with a MacPro-look. The Oxford chip is rock-solid and provides every connection you'll need for a long time: SATA 3.0 inside, FW800, FW400, USB 2.0 and eSATA outside. For some reason I've never felt comfortable buying an external HD w/o being able to choose exactly what's inside. :rolleyes:

[joaoferro37]

I got raidstream twin
2bay firewire raid box. totally hot swappable and trayless.
simple slide your hard drive into the enclosure and turn on the power.
I got it from machollywood but I also found out Amazon does carry it
http://www.amazon.com/RAIDSTREAM-TWIN-Trayless-Multi-stream-Uncompressed/dp/B001CNCLVU/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&qid=1217531839&sr=8-1

[pinktank]

Pay attention to cooling, it usually helps with keeping your data safe

[joaoferro37]

Pay attention to cooling, it usually helps with keeping your data safe

I have this unit and it is very quiet.
The fan was built in the back, check this picture.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/images/B001CNCLVU/sr=8-1/qid=1217531839/ref=dp_images_all?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&qid=1217531839&sr=8-1

[zephyrnoid]

That looks like a great option. May I ask which drives you chose for it?
I have this unit and it is very quiet.
The fan was built in the back, check this picture.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/images/B001CNCLVU/sr=8-1/qid=1217531839/ref=dp_images_all?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&qid=1217531839&sr=8-1

[joaoferro37]

I would choose hitachi only, got it for 197 dollars from AMazon
http://www.amazon.com/gp/offer-listing/B000PDK53E/ref=dp_olp_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1218569397&sr=1-1

[joaoferro37]

One thing, the RAIDstream twin enclosure rocks.

It suports RAID 0, RAID 1 and JOBD and I can simply swap out the drive, change different RAID level without turn off the computer and shut down the enclosure. Simply insert new hard drive and hit reset.

I used to have a G-RAID but I can not change any RAID settings and I can not swap out my own drive.
I use a lot of hard drives for backup and scratch disk and getting external drives for each project is just a big waste.