PDA

View Full Version : Should I Buy This Second Hand Powerbook




blinkie
Jun 18, 2008, 02:30 PM
Hi, A friend of mine has offered me her powerbook g4 for about 400. It's 1.67ghz with a 17inch screen and 512 mb of ram. It seems like a pretty good deal to me but I wanted to check first with all you experts just incase I'm missing something, like a better option.

I'll be using it sometimes for video editing, some audio too. and photoshoping.

It should, I think, be a big step up from the 466 desktop I use now.



iDAG
Jun 18, 2008, 03:04 PM
In my opinion, you should not buy any Mac that does not have an Intel processor in it these days. This is because of the rumored Intel only release of Mac OS X Snow Leopard and even the old Core Duo processors are way more powerful than any G4.

iknowyourider
Jun 18, 2008, 03:57 PM
In my opinion, you should not buy any Mac that does not have an Intel processor in it these days. This is because of the rumored Intel only release of Mac OS X Snow Leopard and even the old Core Duo processors are way more powerful than any G4.

This is a good post, but if you need an economical upgrade, you might consider a G4. I'm not good with euro but if I could get a female-owned, 17" G4 Powerbook for less than half the cost of a low-end intel macbook...I would probably do it.

IMcD23
Jun 18, 2008, 04:00 PM
I have a iBook g4 with upgraded ram. it doesn't run very well, i would get an early macbook (pro). i have come across apps that do not work on ppc also

mBurns
Jun 18, 2008, 11:29 PM
In my opinion, you should not buy any Mac that does not have an Intel processor in it these days. This is because of the rumored Intel only release of Mac OS X Snow Leopard and even the old Core Duo processors are way more powerful than any G4.

I have an "old" Core Duo and it runs like a dream. I am going to upgrade the HD this summer.

That being said, I do not think there is anything wrong picking up a PPC machine if the price is right. Though, 400 seems like a hefty price for a machine that is going to be most likely superseded in the next OS release.

SuperCompu2
Jun 18, 2008, 11:43 PM
The upgrade over the 466MHz G4 you have now will be immense, I definitely recommend getting this unit. I'd offer something like 350 or 375 though, as 400 is almost touching on refurb Intel prices.

My PowerBook G4 handles everything I throw at it well (Lightroom was an experience, but I knew it would be). Bump the RAM to 2GB and you'll be flying in both Tiger and Leopard in no time.

erikislame
Jun 18, 2008, 11:55 PM
Are you people out of your minds? This is a total **** deal.

A refurb MacBook will run about the same, be covered under a 1yr warranty, and have a far better spec sheet.

Whatthechrist.

ps: Apple refurbs are awesome and indistinguishable from out of the box new product--not like the PB your friend has touched with god-knows-what on his/her hands. (Ehhhhhhh? Just like YOU.)

e: that price would be fine if it were euros, not pounds.

erikislame
Jun 19, 2008, 12:02 AM
This is a good post, but if you need an economical upgrade, you might consider a G4. I'm not good with euro but if I could get a female-owned, 17" G4 Powerbook for less than half the cost of a low-end intel macbook...I would probably do it.

See how they mention "female owned"?

Now you know what i'm talking about. No one wants to be handling some stranger's "jack handed" keyboard.

dmw007
Jun 19, 2008, 12:03 AM
That seems like a decent price for a 17" PowerBook G4 (granted, I would probably see if your friend would accept an offer of 350 to 375 as per SuperCompu2's advice).

This would be a huge increase in performance over your existing system. :)

erikislame
Jun 19, 2008, 12:21 AM
All my joking aside, OP--your friend is giving you a crap deal. And the people ITT are not looking close enough at the true eBay gray market average.

Getting this machine for anywhere near this price is a garbage deal compared to the spec sheet of ANY refurb MB or MBP. Either would be a performance bump for you.

I browsed for you and here's a general benchmark spec sheet on why PPC now in fact, drools, and intel now rules.

http://www.geekpatrol.ca/2006/03/imac-geekbench-comparison/

I hope for godsake you don't listen to silly voices....

Go the extra step for an intel box and it will last you a good damn while.

daneoni
Jun 19, 2008, 06:44 AM
If it is going to be your sole machine i'd strongly advice you pick up an intel machine (core duo) from ebay for about the same price or just splurge and extra 200 for a certified Core 2 Duo refurb with warranty from Apple. You can also search for promotional coupons on the internet which might get you further discounts.

400 for a 17" high-end G4 is doable but its not the most cost effective path to take. You'd have to upgrade the RAM to get decent performance out of it and DDR RAM is more expensive now...So it starts adding up to more than 400

I recently got a maxed out 12" PB for the same price and that was because...its was maxed out (1.25GB RAM/100GB 7200 RPM drive/1.5GHz G4/Superdrive etc) so i wouldn't need to spend a penny more AND it was in pristine condition AND i have an iMac already to do the heavy lifting and was just looking for a portable to surf and write papers with on the go.

So i'd advice you seek out a refurb but truth be told there's no cheaper way to get a 17" Apple Laptop but if you don't mind a macbook, you can get a core duo i'd imagine from ebay for around the same price and a core 2 duo from Apple refurb for about 200 extra which would give you longevity as well.

As far as i'm concerned Tiger was the end of the line for G4 machines.

danielhayter
Jun 19, 2008, 06:59 AM
I would say no. Save up an extra 100 and buy a refurbished Macbook. It's faster, is definitely compatible with Snow Leopard, new battery, 1 year warranty...

blinkie
Jun 19, 2008, 11:52 AM
Thanks for the comments, they've help me realise that it's maybe not the best deal out there (I'm watching some ebay stuff and the prices are cheaper than I'd thought). I agree with what some are saying about intel macs, but they are more expensive, maybe just a little but that makes a difference. What are your thought on macbooks for video editing? This was one reason I thought the Powerbook was handy. Would a macbook's extra processing power outweigh the powerbooks dedicated video card??

Snow Leopard. Hmm I'm not so sure I really care about it. I still love Tiger and I don't chase App upgrades as much as others. If it ain't broke don't fix it.

daneoni
Jun 19, 2008, 12:25 PM
depends on your workflow and app you'd be relying on. Video editing for the most part is CPU based i.e. apps like final cut rely on CPU but some apps like Motion are heavily GPU intensive

For the most part the MacBook will handle video editing just fine but if you're doing production-high-end stuff and use apps like Motion then you might wanna look at the MacBook Pro

Either way i'd guess that the GMA X3100 is on Par with the G4's Mobility Radeon

TheLordsServant
Jun 19, 2008, 04:53 PM
I must confess, after being a die hard PPC user, and said that I would NEVER own an Intel Mac, I am typing right now on a new aluminum iMac. It's hundreds of times better than my G4 could ever hope to be. I had a Mirrored Drive Door Dual 1Ghz, with a Radeon 9600 and 2GB RAM, but my iMac is 100x better. I say find a good deal on an Intel. 400 euros, if my memory is correct, is around $800 USD, but don't quote me on that, and for around $1000, you can get a Macbook with the X3100, which I'm quite sure would be on par with the Powerbook's Radeon card. It's up to you, however, that is a decent deal for the computer it is.

iDAG
Jun 19, 2008, 07:43 PM
I must confess, after being a die hard PPC user, and said that I would NEVER own an Intel Mac, I am typing right now on a new aluminum iMac. It's hundreds of times better than my G4 could ever hope to be. I had a Mirrored Drive Door Dual 1Ghz, with a Radeon 9600 and 2GB RAM, but my iMac is 100x better. I say find a good deal on an Intel. 400 euros, if my memory is correct, is around $800 USD, but don't quote me on that, and for around $1000, you can get a Macbook with the X3100, which I'm quite sure would be on par with the Powerbook's Radeon card. It's up to you, however, that is a decent deal for the computer it is.

400 Euros is $620.06 USD, not $800 USD. The dollar isn't that bad (yet :().

blinkie
Jun 20, 2008, 03:53 AM
Just to clarify, I'm talking 400 not 400.

GuntherS
Jun 20, 2008, 04:13 AM
Just to clarify, I'm talking 400 not 400.

That's about $788,16 or 507,79.
That's too much for a G4 imo.
I should buy a Intel Mac if I were you.

blinkie
Jun 20, 2008, 05:14 AM
Watching ebay gives me the fear. Computers like this are going for around 500!

heatmiser
Jun 21, 2008, 01:01 AM
Watching ebay gives me the fear. Computers like this are going for around 500!

That's because people on eBay are greedy.

As others have said, this is a Very Bad Deal.

eXan
Jun 21, 2008, 01:23 AM
Get a Core Duo or early Core 2 Duo MacBook Pro instead if its your main machine.

Getting a G4 as a main computer right now is madness, especially at this price.

Neil321
Jun 21, 2008, 01:33 AM
Apart from the price,as someone else mentioned it's intel all the way now dude & dudet's

arj8138
Jun 21, 2008, 07:09 AM
I just sold my 17in Powerbook 1.5GHz processor for 1130USD but that was w/ final cut pro and some other pieces of software. If you do get this, I would suggest upgrading to 1 gb RAM RIGHT AWAY!!

I used FCP to edit for almost 4 years on this machiene and if the keyboard didnt crap out and if I still had more than 1gb of internal storage I would have kept it for another year or two. But its almost impossible to use FCP if you dont have 1gb ram.

maccompaq
Jun 21, 2008, 08:41 AM
Keep in mind, you are buying a laptop that has been banged around, even if carefully. Batteries keep getting harder to find and more expensive for older lappies. Memory is more expensive for it, and you definitely need more than 512. That price is way too high for such a relic.

leighonigar
Jun 21, 2008, 08:54 AM
Watching ebay gives me the fear. Computers like this are going for around 500!

In the UK, market wise, that price is fine. I probably wouldn't buy though, because of the intel thing. US people doing currency conversions are nuts, almost everything costs more here.

jonswan
Jun 21, 2008, 08:57 AM
Those machines go for those kind of prices - of course you'll get some people who would never pay that, and others do. Me? I'd offer 300-325 max. Why? Because these days a lot of people are clearly trying to offload their PPCs and are switching to the much faster Intel machines so there are a lot of those around. A 1.67 will still be pretty fast - it depends on your needs. But, there's no guarantee so it's a bit pricey. Play with it first is my advice.

tsice19
Jun 21, 2008, 09:19 AM
Why don't you just buy a refurb MacBook? It'd run circles around the G4 any day.

Not to mention, 512 MB of RAM isn't enough these days. You need at least 1GB.

blinkie
Jun 21, 2008, 10:36 AM
Why don't you just buy a refurb MacBook? It'd run circles around the G4 any day.

I know that Macbooks are good and, believe me, I really want one (like I want a lot of things) but they cost too much for me right now. That is the ONLY reason I don't already own one. ;)

kitch95
Jun 21, 2008, 11:48 AM
try www.wegenermedia.com for a early macbook pro 15 and 17 inch (they ship to the uk)