PDA

View Full Version : debkafile: saddam not hiding, but was held captive




zimv20
Dec 16, 2003, 01:59 AM
link (http://www.debka.com/article.php?aid=743)

i don't put a lot of stock in this, but it's an interesting theory...


Saddam Hussein was not in hiding; he was a prisoner.

After his last audiotaped message was delivered and aired over al Arabiya TV on Sunday November 16, on the occasion of Ramadan, Saddam was seized, possibly with the connivance of his own men, and held in that hole in Adwar for three weeks or more, which would have accounted for his appearance and condition. Meanwhile, his captors bargained for the $25 m prize the Americans promised for information leading to his capture alive or dead. The negotiations were mediated by Jalal Talabani’s Kurdish PUK militia.

These circumstances would explain the ex-ruler’s docility – described by Lt.Gen. Ricardo Sanchez as “resignation” – in the face of his capture by US forces. He must have regarded them as his rescuers and would have greeted them with relief.

From Gen. Sanchez’s evasive answers to questions on the $25m bounty, it may be inferred that the Americans and Kurds took advantage of the negotiations with Saddam’s abductors to move in close and capture him on their own account, for three reasons:

A. His capture had become a matter of national pride for the Americans. No kudos would have been attached to his handover by a local gang of bounty-seekers or criminals. The country would have been swept anew with rumors that the big hero Saddam was again betrayed by the people he trusted, just as in the war.

B. It was vital to catch his kidnappers unawares so as to make sure Saddam was taken alive. They might well have killed him and demanded the prize for his body. But they made sure he had no means of taking his own life and may have kept him sedated.

C. During the weeks he is presumed to have been in captivity, guerrilla activity declined markedly – especially in the Sunni Triangle towns of Falluja, Ramadi and Balad - while surging outside this flashpoint region – in Mosul in the north and Najef, Nasseriya and Hilla in the south. It was important for the coalition to lay hands on him before the epicenter of the violence turned back towards Baghdad and the center of the Sunni Triangle.



g5man
Dec 16, 2003, 09:23 AM
I don't buy this article at all.

First of all Saddam had a gun with him and $750K. I doubt he was a prisoner. Now in one sense he was one simply because he no longer had the freedom to move like he did prior to the war and he had to rely on others for info with no way to verify if they were telling the truth. His condition indicates the state of his followers and their anti-American movement.

The issue of the $25 million reward was settled since the info regarding his location was obtained through the capture and interogation of one of his associates. He did not come forward voluntarily with the info.

mactastic
Dec 16, 2003, 09:38 AM
Is this from the black-helicopters-hovering-overhead file?

zimv20
Dec 16, 2003, 11:01 AM
Originally posted by mactastic
Is this from the black-helicopters-hovering-overhead file?

actually, the debka guys are some pretty right-wing israelis.

they've got the occasional crazy theory, but sometimes they're in the know about something days before it shows up in the US media.

mactastic
Dec 16, 2003, 05:26 PM
Well if there is any truth to it, it wouldn't stay secret for long. Specially since I'm assuming Saddam intends to hire some pretty top-drawer lawyers to defend him. Once he gets access to them of course.

Unless the election was a week away, I wouldn't put much faith in this theory.

Edit: Hey, I wonder if Mark Geragos could use a new despicable client!