Out of these two cases which one should i get for my iPhone?

[Dayron14]

i found these two cases online. they look pretty cool. i just cant decide which one. what do you guys think?

1. http://store.apple.com/us/product/TP487VC/A?n=iphone1&fnode=home/shop_iphone/iphone_accessories/cases&mco=MTQwOTE&s=topSellers

2. and this one http://www.rocketfishproducts.com/pc-110-7-rocketfish-silicone-case-for-apple-iphone.aspx

so what do you guys think? thanks in advance! :D

[LoMonkey]

I would definitely go with the second choice, with my sole reason being that it's all one solid piece. I had the first case on my first gen iphone and it came apart on me. The blue part started detaching from the black; it was all down hill from there. It was nice and cushioned, but the pieces just didn't stay together and the case fell apart, leaving my first gen NAKED!