Incase Slider or Protective Cover for iPhone 3G???

[Mr. Giver '94]

Hi. I am looking to purchase a case tomorrow when I exchange my iPhone 3G for one that isn't cracked. I know that these are both good cases, but I would love to have some of your opinions on which one you think is better. Thanks in advance for the help. :)

[ismoker]

whichever case you are gonna use, best is protection skin + case.
scratches are usually made by those little tiny dusts
so it's much better to apply protection skin although you keep your iphone in the case most of the time

[gldelx]

I just picked up the incase slider today and it is a super tight fit (as in it was work to get it on over the volume rocker switch)! Once it was on, I really like it even though I was originally after a silicone case, but after trying a couple and not finding one that felt right, I went with this one.

[tchait]

I originally purchased the protective cover when I got my iPhone 3G but recently traded that case for the slider. The slider case has a much better feel and seems like it will last longer.