Which Screen Protector Do You Like The Best?

[Crevice]

Since there seems to be several threads scattered around about screen protectors, I figured I would make a poll, and maybe keep the screen protector discussion in here. I am just trying to figure what people use and recommend. I myself have the Power Support Crystal but the fingerprints are really bad, I have used the anti-glare for a day, but I couldn't handle the graininess. I am thinking about trying to anti-glare out again. What about everyone else, what are you using?

[EliteKiller]

The 2 that come w/ each Switcheasy Colors case work well.

[r6girl]

I like the Brando screen protectors.

[jjk454ss]

I like the crystal film from Apple, but so many cases make the screen protector come up at the edges and you get a bubble underneath. I like the Incase slider and the Agent18 case, but they both make the screen protector look so bad.

[Dembo]

Brando Ultraclear - beats everything out there

[allurbase]

SGP anti-fingerprint is much better than the PS anti-glare. I wonder how many ppl who voted have actually used both.

[Crevice]

SGP anti-fingerprint is much better than the PS anti-glare. I wonder how many ppl who voted have actually used both.

Does the SGP anti-fingerprint leave the color looking grainy like the Power Support anti-glare? And also how is putting it on, are there a lot of air bubbles? I might pick one up

[pocketdoc]

Brando Ultra Clear is best. Better than PS.

[Crevice]

Brando Ultra Clear is best. Better than PS.

My question is how is the Brando for fingerprints? I never had a problem with Power Support for quality, just the crystal leaves way to many fingerprints and smudges. I bought the anti-glare tonight, and will try it out for a bit.

[creamycole]

Does the SGP anti-fingerprint leave the color looking grainy like the Power Support anti-glare? And also how is putting it on, are there a lot of air bubbles? I might pick one up
SGP A/F is an anti-glare film like P/S anti-glare.

[bobr]

Have an Invisishield on my iTouch and Crystal on my iPhone.... If I had to choose, I'd say the Invisishield is stronger, but the Crystal is WAY quicker and easier to install.

[r6girl]

My question is how is the Brando for fingerprints? I never had a problem with Power Support for quality, just the crystal leaves way to many fingerprints and smudges. I bought the anti-glare tonight, and will try it out for a bit.

The Brando Ultra Clear protector is glass-smooth and collects fingerprints just as easily as the iPhone's screen without a screen protector. Their anti-glare version is far better in this respect, showing only the greasiest fingerprints and nothing else.

[crackinglouis]

The Brando Ultra Clear protector is glass-smooth and collects fingerprints just as easily as the iPhone's screen without a screen protector. Their anti-glare version is far better in this respect, showing only the greasiest fingerprints and nothing else.

Can I see the protecor picture?

[r6girl]

Can I see the protecor picture?

Click here (http://macgirl.net/reviews/reviews/brandofilm.html).

[Crevice]

Is the Brando anti-glare like the PS where it looks grainy? I just want a screen protector that doesn't leave finger prints, and isnt grainy

[Heimlich]

how about DLO anti glare? Anyone try it? It's advertised as being "clear" but anti glare too.

[coronamakers]

how about DLO anti glare? Anyone try it? It's advertised as being "clear" but anti glare too.
DLO difficult to install...

[r6girl]

Is the Brando anti-glare like the PS where it looks grainy? I just want a screen protector that doesn't leave finger prints, and isnt grainy

A little bit of graininess, but I've ceased to notice it at all and it doesn't detract from watching videos or any other activity. It's only apparent when holding it side-by-side with another iPhone with no screen protector, and that's it. See for yourself - all pics of my 3G iPhone on my site are with the Brando anti-glare protector installed...

[stringbeanie]

I tried the power support crystal (shows way too many fingerprints...as bad as naked screen) and the power support anti-glare (which imo is just too grainy...blurry almost). I just installed a bodyguardz screen protector and am thrilled with it. It is not TOO tricky to install (the back protector is though). I couldn't have asked for a better solution. It shows minimal fingerprints if any and is crystal clear. It looks awesome without the orange peel look of the invisishield. Bodyguardz is charging $14.95 for 2 front protectors (plus shipping). http://www.bodyguardz.com/Apple_iPhone_3G_p/iphone3g.htm?Click=9273

oops free shipping

[gasiphara]

I tried the power support crystal (shows way too many fingerprints...as bad as naked screen) and the power support anti-glare (which imo is just too grainy...blurry almost). I just installed a bodyguardz screen protector and am thrilled with it. It is not TOO tricky to install (the back protector is though). I couldn't have asked for a better solution. It shows minimal fingerprints if any and is crystal clear. It looks awesome without the orange peel look of the invisishield. Bodyguardz is charging $14.95 for 2 front protectors (plus shipping). http://www.bodyguardz.com/Apple_iPhone_3G_p/iphone3g.htm?Click=9273

oops free shipping
what is the orange peel?

[richxps]

bodyguardz FTW
Full kit installed and the phone feels great, no bulky case made of plastic. I can just a use a pouch or some sort of rubber skin if needed.

[Crevice]

bodyguardz FTW
Full kit installed and the phone feels great, no bulky case made of plastic. I can just a use a pouch or some sort of rubber skin if needed.

Does the bodyguardz come with anti-glare? I am curious because I just want something that doesn't show fingerprints to much but isnt too grainy like power support. If it does have an anti-glare how is it compared to powersupport, is it as grainy as their version?

My problem with Power Support anti-glare (to explain my reasoning) is that they have changed their formula or something has changed for sure. My friend has the original iphone PS anti-glare, and I have the 3G PS anti-glare, we put them side to side, and mine had a definite rainbow effect and is more grainy, which is really annoying while surfing the web. I just put a order in for the Brando anti-glare, hope that clears the rainbow effect, and gives me a little more clarity.

[stringbeanie]

Does the bodyguardz come with anti-glare? I am curious because I just want something that doesn't show fingerprints to much but isnt too grainy like power support. If it does have an anti-glare how is it compared to powersupport, is it as grainy as their version?


The bodyguardz does not come in anti-glare but curiously doesn't show fingerprints that easily. It is like having the naked screen but without the fingerprint issue, which to me is the perfect solution.

I have used Brando screen protectors going back for years (back in the old palm pilot days) and they are superb so you should be fine with those.

Someone else asked about "orange peel" look and to answer that question, it just has kind of a dimpled look when viewing from an angle. It doesn't appear too smooth...kind of annoying to me but some don't mind it.

[Dr. Cabrera]

bodyguardz front shield is the best screen protector you can buy

Refer to this thread if you want a review of all these products

http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=569101

[Crevice]

I ordered a Brando anti-glare, but in the meantime I took off the power support anti-glare I had on before because I couldn't handle the rainbow/graininess, and I put on one of the Switcheasy screen protectors that came with my Neo. I never put the Switcheasy protectors on my phone because I thought they sucked, but I am actually really impressed. I like them way better then power support crystal as they don't show fingerprints as easily. If the brando doesn't work for me I'm going to go back to the Switcheasy, anybody who has em should try them out.

[RobbRock]

I have a privacy screen it works great!

[nimda0]

I've used a TON of screen protectors trying to find the best one, and I can honestly say I've narrowed it down to ONLY ONE that is worth having.

It very well may come down to personal preference... like whether or not you like the anti-glare or crystal look, and whether or not you care about finger prints or not.


HANDS DOWN, if you want absolutely ZERO FINGER PRINTS on your screen, there is only 1 screen protector worth having, and that's the:

Power Support Anti-Glare

It will not show any finger prints, it looks clear when the screen is turned on, and is smooth when using the touch screen. It applies to the screen VERY easily. It does NOT attract dust like a lot of screen protectors do. I keep mine in the front left pocket of my jeans, filled with lint, and never have anything on the screen or "in-case" silicon case.


Other revirews:
Power Support Crystal: Horrible. This screen protector leaves every mark, smudge, finger print, and dust particle on the screen from anything that contacts it. DO NOT BUY IT. It's crystal, so it is clear and shiny looking, but a real hastle to keep clean. If you're like me, you have just a little OCD to you and it will drive you nuts.

SGP Steinheil Anti-Fingerprint: Comparable to the Power Support Anti-glare screen protector, except it still shows finger prints every now and again. Not bad at all, but not as good as the Power Support Anti-glare. Anyone saying otherwise simply must have never tried the power support one.

Invisible shield: Garbage. Tried this, it began pealing, was very cheaply made, and not thick enough to really protect the screen appropriately. Personally, I thought it still left tons of smudges and finger prints and was annoying to look at.

Buy the anti-glare power support and neer look back.

[Heimlich]

Yeah it all comes down to whether you like the anti-glare or clear kind. We can't really say the PS Crystal is better than the anti-glare. We have to compare apples with apples.. (hey... apples hahaha)
anyway, if you like anti glare better, you should tell which anti-glare product is your favorite. And if you like clear better; which clear is your favorite. kk

[gabrieljoye34]

Yeah it all comes down to whether you like the anti-glare or clear kind. We can't really say the PS Crystal is better than the anti-glare. We have to compare apples with apples.. (hey... apples hahaha)
anyway, if you like anti glare better, you should tell which anti-glare product is your favorite. And if you like clear better; which clear is your favorite. kk

What is PS Crystal film? where on it?

[Heimlich]

What is PS Crystal film? where on it?

Power support crystal

[medroarr]

SGP Steinheil fingerprint more clear than PS antiglare~

[kicko]

I liked the PS crystal, yes there is fingerprints but its the closest to the naked screen. I'd rather use it as it was intended - OG

[THE JUICEMAN]

SGP Steinheil fingerprint more clear than PS antiglare~

this would be great if this is true. do you have any pictures? also can anybody else confirm this? thanks

[jjk454ss]

this would be great if this is true. do you have any pictures? also can anybody else confirm this? thanks

I had the Powersupport Crystalfilm, and just replaced it with the SGP Antifingerprint. The biggest difference is that the Crystalfilm is a better fit, less exposed screen around the edges. Both are very good, but the Crystalfilm is a better fit. If I had to say which one is more clear, I think the SGP might be ever so slightly clearer, but I am not really sure. They seem very close to me.

[THE JUICEMAN]

I had the Powersupport Crystalfilm, and just replaced it with the SGP Antifingerprint. The biggest difference is that the Crystalfilm is a better fit, less exposed screen around the edges. Both are very good, but the Crystalfilm is a better fit. If I had to say which one is more clear, I think the SGP might be ever so slightly clearer, but I am not really sure. They seem very close to me.

did u mean you have the powersupport antiglare?

[jjk454ss]

did u mean you have the powersupport antiglare?

No, it says Steinheil Anti Fingerprint on the package.

[THE JUICEMAN]

no. i was trying to compare the Powersupport anti glare vs the sgp anti finger print. in your post you said you were comparing the powersupport crystal vs the sgp anti fingerprint. i guess the size issue you touched on is fine for a comparison. but i wanted a anti glare vs an anti fingerprint comparison. thanks though

[gospel9]

Power Support Crystal


I tried the matte but I hate the feel on it compared to the crystal film.
The reflecting screen... on the other hand did not bother me.

Both Power Support protectors are a little thicker than some of the others I have tried. Another thing that I really liked about the PS Crystal film is that it's really virtually transparent. Side by side with my cousin's iphone without a screen protector, neither of us can tell a difference.

And yes, the iphone 3G screen does scratch easily. Even by delicate use. My girlfriend's phone had minor scratches showing up probably gotten from her large earrings. That was only after a week of owning the phone!

[jjk454ss]

no. i was trying to compare the Powersupport anti glare vs the sgp anti finger print. in your post you said you were comparing the powersupport crystal vs the sgp anti fingerprint. i guess the size issue you touched on is fine for a comparison. but i wanted a anti glare vs an anti fingerprint comparison. thanks though

Sorry, yes I was comparing the powersupport antiglare to the SGP antifingerprint. Not the Crystalfilm, my mistake.

[THE JUICEMAN]

Sorry, yes I was comparing the powersupport antiglare to the SGP antifingerprint. Not the Crystalfilm, my mistake.

no problem. thanks for the input.

anybody have problems with your fingers sticking to these screen protectors when trying to slide around? I know the anti glare ones don't do this

[jjk454ss]

anybody have problems with your fingers sticking to these screen protectors when trying to slide around? I know the anti glare ones don't do this

Not with either of the ones I've tried. I used an iPhone with the Zagg Invisibleshield the other day, that was terrible. The screen protector was on good, and looked OK(nothing like the SGP or Power Support though), but your fingers just wanted to stick and drag across it. It would have taken me about 10 seconds to take that one off and throw it in the garbage.

[THE JUICEMAN]

Not with either of the ones I've tried. I used an iPhone with the Zagg Invisibleshield the other day, that was terrible. The screen protector was on good, and looked OK(nothing like the SGP or Power Support though), but your fingers just wanted to stick and drag across it. It would have taken me about 10 seconds to take that one off and throw it in the garbage.

yea I took my zagg off not to long ago. it was good for protection but sucks as far as looks and dust go. I have a switcheasy on right now and it's good but my fingers were sticking a little bit. maybe becuase my hands are dry or something who knows LOL

[mocciat]

Bodyguardz

[larapumkin]

SGP Steinheil Crystal
i really like this film..
i don't really know about their case cuz theirs is not quite my taste but they really do good on films imo

[PSiBeR]

SGP Steinheil Crystal
i really like this film..
i don't really know about their case cuz theirs is not quite my taste but they really do good on films imo

+1

I also like this screen protector over the PS Crystal Film. I however don't like how long it took for them to ship.. 3 weeks!! But they made up for it, in the quality of the screen protector. I've had the PS Crystal on for a good 2 months. Till a couple days ago I applied the SGP Crystal.. and wow!! It's really clear, fingerprint wise a bit better then the PS. I also like that they included a squeegee and a microfibre cloth ;)

[jjk454ss]

+1

I also like this screen protector over the PS Crystal Film. I however don't like how long it took for them to ship.. 3 weeks!! But they made up for it, in the quality of the screen protector. I've had the PS Crystal on for a good 2 months. Till a couple days ago I applied the SGP Crystal.. and wow!! It's really clear, fingerprint wise a bit better then the PS. I also like that they included a squeegee and a microfibre cloth ;)

I was actually surprised how fast I got my screen protector from sgpstore.com. Maybe they were out of stock or something when you ordered yours?

[larapumkin]

I was actually surprised how fast I got my screen protector from sgpstore.com. Maybe they were out of stock or something when you ordered yours?

i used to shop overseas a lot and i assume that delivery works fast within domestin but not for international..
i mean those stores usually ship out my orders next day but if it becomes an international shipping, how fast they ship out does not really matter, it is all about the custom......
i've bought a pair of shoes from italy, the store shipped it next day of my purchase but it took 4 weeks after they shiped out...
i don't know why custom and post office take so long for inspection...

[Merlosso]

Anyone using an Incase Slider with a screen protector? I had the Case-Mate protector (which I liked) but the slider pushed up the edges all the way around and I had to take it off. I tried the Ghost Armor but I didn't like the gummy, tacky feel of it. Then I tried the DLO protector that comes with the Jam Jacket and the Incase Slider pushes it on the top.

Now I'm back to square one and looking for a non-fingerprint attracting, no-rainbow having, orange peel-less, screen protector.

[stoich]

Ill let my signature speak for itself. :) Ive used zagg and Bodyguardz and Ghost Armor definatley performs the best. much luck!

[THE JUICEMAN]

Anyone using an Incase Slider with a screen protector? I had the Case-Mate protector (which I liked) but the slider pushed up the edges all the way around and I had to take it off. I tried the Ghost Armor but I didn't like the gummy, tacky feel of it. Then I tried the DLO protector that comes with the Jam Jacket and the Incase Slider pushes it on the top.

Now I'm back to square one and looking for a non-fingerprint attracting, no-rainbow having, orange peel-less, screen protector.

Your best choices are the Powersupport Anti Glare or the SGP anti fingerprint. These both do what your describing here.

[yntbrgrstar]

yea i got steinheil and it works really great! well mine is for ipod touch though..but they should have made out of all the same materials :)

[andyblila]

Anti Glare all the way.

[phinbob]

Your best choices are the Powersupport Anti Glare or the SGP anti fingerprint. These both do what your describing here.

I couldn't agree more. I got the Invisible Shield for my iphone and hated the results. I was very particular with the installation of the complete body shield but it never really looked like it should, ie. basically invisible. Within 24 hours I removed the rear shield, another 48 hours later I removed the front shield because tiny bubbles (like an orange peel) never went away. Next I got the iSkin Solo and love the feel and looks. I did apply the front shield from the Solo but once again, I wasn't completely satisfied.

Today I got the Power Support Anti-glare shield and love it. Install was VERY easy and appearance is great. No finger prints, no bubbles. It is very easy to believe there is nothing on the the LCD screen. This is a keeper.

[Poat84]

What about the Griffin Screen Protector? I got it with the iClear. Does anyone like it? I haven't put it on yet.

[zdblue11]

SGP anti-fingerprint is much better than the PS anti-glare. I wonder how many ppl who voted have actually used both.

did you try both sgp crystal anti-fingerprint? i only tried the crystal and want to know which one you give your vote to :rolleyes: