Canon G10 with RAW?

dpreview say it has RAW.

Save your money and go with the G9.

yeah, g10 will have raw.

MBX said:

Just looking for confirmation that the G10 will have RAW?

Click to expand...

14MP in a camera that size is kind of nuts. Seems the marketing people are driving the engineering at Canon.

shfreelance said:

Save your money and go with the G9.

Click to expand...

Hi, I'm considering a G10. Got to handle the demo model at the store yesterday. Very impressive. Not familiar with the G9. Seems that the G10's wider angle lens would be an advantage.

Please elaborate on your preference for the G9

thankx

If I was going to spend ~$500 on a camera, I'd pick up an Olympus e-420 or Nikon D40 kit long before I'd consider a G9 or G10...

vga4life said:

If I was going to spend ~$500 on a camera, I'd pick up an Olympus e-420 or Nikon D40 kit long before I'd consider a G9 or G10...

Click to expand...

Unless you already had a DSLR and wanted a fully manual P&S to go a long with it that can use your existing hot shoe flash guns.

But in saying that, I'd still probably get a Ricoh GX200/GRII or Sigma DP1. Just suits my photography more.

While I save up for a digital SLR (still very uncertain which way I'll go, DX of FX, etc), I was thinking of the G10 as a way to get started acquiring images , working with RAW. Then later, the G10 could be a handy 'backup' or 'pocket' camera.

The Sigma sensor is very intriguing. Haven't heard if the images from the DP1 are significantly better in color etc than other large-megapixel cameras. Also, lack of any zoom capability is what is mostly my concern about the DP1. Have you tried it ? thoughts?

anyway, didn't want start with $500 d-SLR and lenses, since I don't know if those lenses would work on whatever high-end camera I end up with.

-Qua

The G10 does RAW. I'm considering getting it to replace my G7. I don't have much need for RAW in a compact, but I could use the wide angle of the G10.

I do use RAW all the time with my SLR (Nikon D200), but I'm getting much better image quality there. I agree with others that Canon should have kept the MP count lower on the G10, considering the size of the sensor. I'd really like to have the best IQ I can get in a compact, and I think the sweet spot for IQ vs. print size would come around 8MP. Oh well... It's otherwise a great design.

qveda said:

While I save up for a digital SLR (still very uncertain which way I'll go, DX of FX, etc), I was thinking of the G10 as a way to get started acquiring images , working with RAW. Then later, the G10 could be a handy 'backup' or 'pocket' camera.

didn't want start with $500 d-SLR and lenses, since I don't know if those lenses would work on whatever high-end camera I end up with.

Click to expand...

I think you can save yourself $500 if you'd just work out which SLR you want. The SLR will have so much better quality ad handling than the G10 that you would only shoot the G10 whaen you needed something smaller and more portable. But the G10 is not the best if you want "small". Get one of those canon Elph models if you need small.

That was my first strategy (put all my $ towards the nice d-SLR). But it may be awhile before I can get one. Not sure the ELF models would satisfy my craving.. but that is a good suggestion, which I'll consider

thanks!

I dont get it, how come Canon highest end P&S gets DiGiC4 whereas Canon entry level DSLR didn't come with DiGiC4, im still new to digital photography arena so my opinions will likely be wrong. Someone care to explain or is this some kind of marketing?

wheelhot said:

I dont get it, how come Canon highest end P&S gets DiGiC4 whereas Canon entry level DSLR didn't come with DiGiC4, im still new to digital photography arena so my opinions will likely be wrong. Someone care to explain or is this some kind of marketing?

Click to expand...

Well obviously the higher-end models need to be the first to get the latest processor.

qveda said:

That was my first strategy (put all my $ towards the nice d-SLR). But it may be awhile before I can get one. Not sure the ELF models would satisfy my craving.. but that is a good suggestion, which I'll consider

thanks!

Click to expand...

What I meant was that SLRs can be bought for less than the price of a G10. If you have the cash for the G10 then you can buy an SLR now.

G10 and camera raw

anyone having trouble opening the raw images in photoshop? raw file will not open in camera raw!

gmilano said:

anyone having trouble opening the raw images in photoshop? raw file will not open in camera raw!

Click to expand...

You probably need a newer version of Camera Raw. Which may, in turn, require a newer version of Photoshop...