PDA

View Full Version : Converting Video for Apple TV (HD)




lokipower
Oct 31, 2008, 08:05 PM
I know this has been addressed a trillion times, but it is confusing as heck. I can not seem to find a clear consensus on what to use to convert my movie collection to a standard format my :apple:TV can use. I think I get it with converting my DVD's... MTR and HB, (or just HB). But I have hundreds of movies and videos in various formats that I would like to convert to :apple:TV format. I realize many options will encode using standard def, but was hoping to convert them using the max resolution :apple:TV provides, (720p). Can someone just tell me what program or hardware device makes converting lots of videos in varying formats to :apple:TV? Paid or Free, at this point I will pay to just make it happen.

Thank you for those that reply...



illegallydead
Oct 31, 2008, 08:18 PM
I'm pretty sure that the solution you have now (MTR + HB) is about as good as it gets. Converting to 720p will do you no good if that is for DVD's, as they are 480p, period. if you somehow have digital Hd files or BD's, I think that handbrake will allow you to convert in HD, so long as you give it a format it can use.

If you want a simple, easy to use approach, with no fighting it, you basically are left with Kaleidescape (http://www.kaleidescape.com/). Expensive as hell, but it certainly will solve your problems :D

The world of digital movies is a pain in the @$$ and a half, due to the MPAA/RIAA's stance on "copyright infringement". So, you either fight your way through it all until the studios can get a decent method of digital distribution underway, or you can stick with DVD's or BD's, as they just work, no questions asked.

Nermal
Oct 31, 2008, 09:16 PM
Converting to 720p will do you no good if that is for DVD's, as they are 480p, period.

Just to nitpick, 576p (and i) DVDs exist too. I expect that 480i exists as well.

serpico
Oct 31, 2008, 09:20 PM
I use iSquint right now. It's great for batch jobs. I got a bunch of tv shows converting right now and being added to itunes automatically. Try to find a copy if you can.

lokipower
Oct 31, 2008, 09:23 PM
Thanks for the reply. I have no issues with the DVD conversion. My deal is with the videos I already have on my home server. I am coming from a PC world, where I would simply load a codec pack, "CCCP" and all videos will play, no matter what they were. Now that I am migrating to Apple products, (iMac, Apple TV, TC, etc), I want to convert all of my videos so that I can stream them to the Apple TV. I want to do so in the highest resolution possible, as many of my videos are HD in nature. The option you gave is great, but I'd rather hang on ot my arm and my leg... :)

I have used a few out there via batch, (que up about 10 to 15 videos) and go to bed..Wake up and they are converted, but none are maxed out with resolution.

lokipower
Oct 31, 2008, 09:25 PM
I use iSquint right now. It's great for batch jobs. I got a bunch of tv shows converting right now and being added to itunes automatically. Try to find a copy if you can.

I looked at that... Is that not for encoding video for an iPod or iPhone? Resolution may be a bit low for a 52 inch screen...

Heb1228
Oct 31, 2008, 09:31 PM
The answer is going to depend, in part, on what format they are in currently.

Will they open in Quicktime? If not, try installing Perian (http://www.versiontracker.com/dyn/moreinfo/macosx/30931) (freeware) and see if they will open.

Since you're asking the question, I'm assuming you've already tried to play them on your Apple TV and they won't play?

lokipower
Oct 31, 2008, 09:36 PM
The answer is going to depend, in part, on what format they are in currently.

Will they open in Quicktime? If not, try installing Perian (http://www.versiontracker.com/dyn/moreinfo/macosx/30931) (freeware) and see if they will open.

Since you're asking the question, I'm assuming you've already tried to play them on your Apple TV and they won't play?


Hello there, true, they will not play. I will try Perian and see what will happen. But I wold say most of them are XvID, AC3 XVID, MKV, AVI, DIVX, a few WMV here and there, maybe even a stray MP4.

I have tried to play them... No dice....

If they play using Perian, what then? I ask that, but I will look it up and see in a few moments when I send this message.

lokipower
Oct 31, 2008, 09:39 PM
Will they open in Quicktime? If not, try installing Perian (http://www.versiontracker.com/dyn/moreinfo/macosx/30931) (freeware) and see if they will open.
?

Wow, I did not know about this Perian, seems great. At least for playing on the iMac. Does this pass through to Apple TV? Can you think of a benefit of keeping the files in a single format, (ergo H.264 for Apple)?

Cave Man
Oct 31, 2008, 09:41 PM
Even if you get perian on the ATV, iTunes will not sync or stream content to the ATV that does not fit the expected profile. If you're going to go to that much trouble, you might as well install XBMC onto your ATV.

Heb1228
Oct 31, 2008, 09:42 PM
If they will play in Quicktime, then convert to a Quicktime format using Quicktime Pro and an MPEG-4 codec that supports HD like H.264.

Here's another option you may want to check out: from Engaget on enabling Apple TV to play more content.

http://www.engadget.com/2007/04/10/how-to-play-divx-and-xvid-on-your-apple-tv/

EDIT: How to install Perian on your Apple TV
http://wiki.awkwardtv.org/wiki/Install_Perian

If you can avoid re-encoding, by all means, go without it. There's no benefit to having your videos all in the same format, plus you're going to lose quality each time you re-encode.

lokipower
Oct 31, 2008, 09:50 PM
So what I am hearing from the last two posts is that modding the :apple:TV to play what I have is better than re-encoding my videos to the format? If I install Perin on the iMac and the videos play in QT, then they can be converted using QT Pro? Is that what I am hearing?

Again, which is better, changing the :apple:TV to play any video or re-encode videos to the standard?

Heb1228
Oct 31, 2008, 09:58 PM
I would do everything possible to get the Apple TV to play the videos in their current formats.

lokipower
Oct 31, 2008, 10:02 PM
I would do everything possible to get the Apple TV to play the videos in their current formats.

I should have read more closely to what you said Heb1228... I understand what you are saying. I will look at the links you gave and see how that works. I will post with results as soon as I get it going...

I am curious though, will I still be able to stream the videos or will I have to copy what I want to play to the :apple:TV? 160GB :apple:TV vs 1TB of Videos, might get tedious....:

Okay, Edit here... I just looked at what is required to get this going... I think this is a bit more than I am prepared to do, while it may be easy, I think I would rather go back to just getting my videos in a format Apple TV can read period... I am new to Mac, (like 2 weeks), I am trying to make the switch from PC, but wow what a start that would be...

Heb1228
Oct 31, 2008, 10:06 PM
That'll depend on the bitrates and the speed of your wireless network. If you're getting a high enough throughput, then you shouldn't have to copy them. In other words, try and see.

serpico
Oct 31, 2008, 10:19 PM
I looked at that... Is that not for encoding video for an iPod or iPhone? Resolution may be a bit low for a 52 inch screen...
Yes, but select optimze for tv and it looks pretty good on my 46". I select h.264 too. It all depends on your source of course. Large quicktime podcasts look very nice too on my tv using the hdmi cable from the AppleTV.

I just picked mine up too, so I'm learning as well. Today was my first day converting and it looked nicer than the source.

lokipower
Oct 31, 2008, 10:52 PM
[quote=Heb1228;6537021]If they will play in Quicktime, then convert to a Quicktime format using Quicktime Pro and an MPEG-4 codec that supports HD like H.264.
quote]

I want to clearify something here. If I install Perin, then most of my videos should "play" in QT. If I purchase QT Pro, will I be able to export to MP4-H.264 format directly from an AVI (or whatever) playing in QT via Perin?

Cave Man
Oct 31, 2008, 11:48 PM
For your Mac, Plex is the best app available. Quicktime simply isn't all that good. It has limited codec support and has difficulty in playing high bit rate HD content.

Plex, while a little complex to learn, is substantially better than Quicktime.

But if you want to play videos on the Apple TV, the path of least resistance is transcoding your files into a compatible format. Easiest thing is to dl the current Handbrake snapshot and try it with your non-compliant video first. If it is standard def, then use the built in Apple TV preset. If it's high def, click on the Apple TV preset, then change the picture size to no more than 1280x720 and the bit rate to 6000.

If your HD content has Dolby Digital AC-3, then you'll preserve that. If it has DTS, DTS-HD or True-HD, you're out of luck. No tools exist on the Mac side to transcode those to AC-3.

lokipower
Nov 2, 2008, 05:33 PM
I started using Roxio Toast to convert one of my videos (an episode of 24). I played around with the settings but we will see. I have two questions, as I configure what will ultimately be my iMac..


What are the best settings for :apple:TV for standard definition videos (say normal DVD rips) and the best settings for :apple:TV for high definition videos, (like blu-ray rips or other HD video). I guess what I am asking is what are the max settings the unit can take and what are the normal units to make it look respectable on a large TV.
If I install Perin on QT, (which I have) and it plays my videos, (which it does), will Quick Time Pro convert the videos that it would not normally play? Another way of asking is will QTP convert videos that play, only as a result of Perin?
Thanks for the advice everyone.. I do not want to spend money on every program out there before I find what works....

rhett7660
Nov 3, 2008, 09:18 AM
lokipower

For your Mac, Plex is the best app available. Quicktime simply isn't all that good. It has limited codec support and has difficulty in playing high bit rate HD content.

Plex, while a little complex to learn, is substantially better than Quicktime.

But if you want to play videos on the Apple TV, the path of least resistance is transcoding your files into a compatible format. Easiest thing is to dl the current Handbrake snapshot and try it with your non-compliant video first. If it is standard def, then use the built in Apple TV preset. If it's high def, click on the Apple TV preset, then change the picture size to no more than 1280x720 and the bit rate to 6000.

If your HD content has Dolby Digital AC-3, then you'll preserve that. If it has DTS, DTS-HD or True-HD, you're out of luck. No tools exist on the Mac side to transcode those to AC-3.

It is right above your post.

lokipower
Nov 3, 2008, 09:32 AM
Yes it was, thanks for the reminder...:cool:

I saw Handbrake and thought someone was thinking I wanted to convert DVD's, which is what Handbrake was for. I assume this version of Handbrake allows for videos as well...I will try it out...

And for that , my thanks to Caveman...

asluiter
Nov 7, 2008, 03:50 PM
Here's the easiest, 2 step process for converting an MKV file with DTS 5.1 to an iTunes friendly MP4 file with 5.1 Dolby Digital.

Here's what you need:

Windows - Converting audio from DTS to AC3 5.1
Windows/OSX - Coverting MKV file to MP4

Popcorn MKV Audio converter (windows only) :

http://www.digital-digest.com/software/PopCorn_MKV_AudioConverter.html

Handbrake Snapshot Build (windows/osx):

http://handbrake.fr/?article=snapshot


Step 1: Run the audio conversion using Popcorn Audio Converter. You do not need to preserve the DTS track. You do not need Vorbis. Convert to AC3 5.1.

Step 2: Use handbrake to transcode the the output file from the audio converter. On the audio/subtitles tab, use the passthrough method for the audio track.

Step 3: There is no step 3. Sit, wait, grab a beer, grab a second beer, and so on. Once Handbrake is done with it's magic, feel free to MetaX the file, or simply add it into iTunes.


_______________________________________________
Do I really need a signature? I suppose...

Hand: iPhone 1G 8GB
Lap:MBP C2D 2.33, 2GB, 200GB 7200RPM, 15"
Serv: Athlon 64 2800+, 1.5GB, 3TB, Windows Server 2003
Body: Millions of GHZ, Billions of Cores, TBs of RAM, 2 Oval Shaped Cameras, Natures OS, Force Feedback Joystick.

rhett7660
Nov 8, 2008, 01:58 PM
To add another question to this thread... is there a sheet or link to a site somewhere that tells you the max average bitrate one can have for a movie based on how long the movie is?

IE
The movie is between 1hr30min to 1hr59min use the following setting for the max resolution
The movie is between 2hr00min to 2hr30min use the following setting for the max resolution

I have been ripping using the AppleTV setting and then increaseing the ABR to 3200 to 3500 and the files are coming in under 5gig a pop. Usually around 2+ gigs in the m4v format.

Anything like this around?

dynaflash
Nov 8, 2008, 05:23 PM
is there a sheet or link to a site somewhere that tells you the max average bitrate one can have for a movie based on how long the movie is?
huh? what does abr have to do with how long the movie is ?

rhett7660
Nov 8, 2008, 06:01 PM
Hmmm... isn't there a limit on the size of the file? IE 5 gigs is the magic number? Am I missing something? I only want them ripped for apple tv. No ipod/iphone etc. Just apple tv.

dynaflash
Nov 8, 2008, 06:12 PM
Hmmm... isn't there a limit on the size of the file? IE 5 gigs is the magic number?
Negative. For a 32 bit mp4 the magic number is 4 GB. which is totally unrelated to HB or the atv.
However, the atv preset and any derivative of it should include 64 bit mp4 file formatting, which basically means it can be as big as you want. The atv could care less.

rhett7660
Nov 8, 2008, 07:03 PM
Negative. For a 32 bit mp4 the magic number is 4 GB. which is totally unrelated to HB or the atv.
However, the atv preset and any derivative of it should include 64 bit mp4 file formatting, which basically means it can be as big as you want. The atv could care less.

Hmmmm...... Ok, how do I get the 64 bit mp4 file? Is there a setting in HB?

Edit:

Ok I found the 64bit setting, it says this breaks the compatiblitiy with many target devices, such as iPod as well as iTunes streaming to AppleTV. In essence, if I want the 64 bit, I have to have the files stored locally on the AppleTV correct?

I have found some sites that says you can stream and others that say you can't. Wondering if this will work.


Thanks

Diveflo
Nov 8, 2008, 07:41 PM
I have many movies which are bigger than 4gig and they work just beautiful.

rhett7660
Nov 8, 2008, 08:01 PM
I have many movies which are bigger than 4gig and they work just beautiful.

Thank you very much. That is what I wanted to hear. Ripping some test movies now.

Thanks again.

dynaflash
Nov 8, 2008, 10:12 PM
Ok I found the 64bit setting, it says this breaks the compatiblitiy with many target devices, such as iPod as well as iTunes streaming to AppleTV. In essence, if I want the 64 bit, I have to have the files stored locally on the AppleTV correct?
Yes, and no. Yes, at the time HB 0.9.2 was released, the atv software had some issues with streaming 64 bit mp4's (I forget the atv sofware rev). However, at this time, atv software 2.2 streams 64 bit mp4's just fine. So, yes any atv encode should include 64 bit mp4 formatting and can be however large and the atv will do just fine with it.

Note: the atv seems to always be a moving target as they improve the software.

rhett7660
Nov 9, 2008, 10:31 AM
Yes, and no. Yes, at the time HB 0.9.2 was released, the atv software had some issues with streaming 64 bit mp4's (I forget the atv sofware rev). However, at this time, atv software 2.2 streams 64 bit mp4's just fine. So, yes any atv encode should include 64 bit mp4 formatting and can be however large and the atv will do just fine with it.

Note: the atv seems to always be a moving target as they improve the software.

Thanks again for the tips and suggestions. I am now off to rip some 600 dvd's.... well maybe I won't rip them alllllll :D

rhett7660
Nov 10, 2008, 01:31 PM
Please delete post.......