Help needed: MacBook or iMac?

[ManuelGnR]

You've probably all heard this question a lot before, but, should I buy a MacBook or an iMac?

What I am going to do:
- Dowload
- Music, music music! =)
- Movies
- Maybe some 3D building creating stuff, I now use the free Google SketchUp program..
- I would like to connect my electric guitar to it, and play on amps I can download or whatever, so plug the guitar in.
- Some light stuff like MSN, poker, internet, text stuff (mostly for school) etc.

The iMac would be:
20'', the cheapest model, with:
2 or 4 GB
wireless Mouse

The MacBook would be:
The Cheapest Model, with:
- Remote Control stuff, so I can control my music from anywhere in the room
- Maybe after a while an extra lcd monitor and/or mouse/keyboard. Already got wireless (black) mouse and keyboard, not that great quality.

I would love an iMac because: The screen, cool for movies and cool because you have space. screens of internet and some kind of Word next to it.

I would love a MacBook because: The Portability ofcourse. Take it on the couch, take it downstairs, even better couch, take it to school, and I'd love to take it with me on vacation. As long as it don't get stolen. But I got to admit, I don't think I'd take it to school to often, and not very much on the couch either. But I would sometimes..

As you can hear, I don't really know what I want. Help needed.

I really appreciate any help and reactions!

P.S. I also have an CRT 17'' LG monitor. Could be connected to a MacBook I Think.

[jav6454]

MacBook can handle everything you listed here. Also it gains on the portability side. One note I see here is that you play the guitar. iMac will not be ideal if you play the guitar while you're moving and/or the guitar itself alot (you can pull the iMac to the floor).

As for the LCD you described, it will work if you buy the correct adapter from Apple.

[ManuelGnR]

I do have a 9 meter cable for my guitar however, so if I have a short cable-piece-thing to put between guitar-cable and iMac I can jump around my bedroom without moving the iMac.

Thanks for your help so far.

[DannyBres]

id either get an iMac or a Alu 2.0 MacBook but i think the Macbook will be better (but as its outside your budget id defo get the iMac :D)

[ManuelGnR]

Btw, I would buy it a little cheaper, at the online edu store..

[Roessnakhan]

I'd get the MacBook for now and save up for an external monitor. They get cheaper everyday and you won't be stuck with replacing the entire computer when better display technology comes around.

[The Samurai]

I'd get the MacBook for now and save up for an external monitor. They get cheaper everyday and you won't be stuck with replacing the entire computer when better display technology comes around.

I second this. Get the MacBook and buy an external monitor at a later stage.

[tiartrop]

I'd vote for iMac because it doesn't seem like you need the portability, for the same price you can get a better machine with a much bigger display.

If I don't have to move around between three cities and two countries every so often, I'd absolutely get an iMac. And I never take my laptop with me on vacation, because: 1) I might lose it, 2) I'd rather bring a nintendo DS or DSLR instead, 3) with 20kg baggage restriction I think I'd rather leave this 2.5 kg machine at home!

So, unless I absolutely need to do some work during my vacation (which sucks), it stays locked inside the bedroom.

[ManuelGnR]

Hm.. so says a friend of mine..

But I still don't really know :confused:
It's a lot of money for me, so I wanna be sure I make the right choice..

[tyreal]

Go with the Macbook and a 22" Dell monitor. This combo offers more flexibility and will be sufficient for your needs.

[ManuelGnR]

Why do you call specific a Dell monitor? The cheapest Dell monitor I found (I only search for 22'' and higher) is 260 euros while the cheapest other 22'' I found were a Samsung 22'' and a LG 22'' - both 160 euros.

LG - http://lg.hardware.nl/p/LG/W2234S-BN
Samsung - http://www.computerland.nl/ProductDetails.aspx?en=NS00631483

[The Samurai]

Go with the Macbook and a 22" Dell monitor. This combo offers more flexibility and will be sufficient for your needs.

Thats my setup and it works a treat.

OP - watch my videos in my sig ;)

EDIT: here (http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=ETozFlcmw48)

[ManuelGnR]

If the iMac get's updated monday, I will think about it again then. If they will not get upgraded monday, I might wanna buy a MacBook. I don't want to wait 2 more months for an up to date iMac but I don't want a not-up to date iMac either...

Reactions and advice still very welcome!

[Vulcan]

If the iMac get's updated monday, I will think about it again then. If they will not get upgraded monday, I might wanna buy a MacBook. I don't want to wait 2 more months for an up to date iMac but I don't want a not-up to date iMac either...

Reactions and advice still very welcome!

The iMac update won't be something too major. I'd get the iMac if I were you to be honest, do you really need the portability? Most laptop users waste cash thinking they are actually going to move with it, but only take it off their desk once a week, if that.

Do keep in mind, most replies will be in favor of the MacBook as you are in that subforum. If you were in iMac you could expect a different result.

[ManuelGnR]

I know that ;)

In iMac no responses came.. But if the iMac get's more GHz, GB RAM etc. in january, I wouldn't like buying one now..

[DannyBres]

I know that ;)

In iMac no responses came.. But if the iMac get's more GHz, GB RAM etc. in january, I wouldn't like buying one now..

and a mini display port ;)

[ManuelGnR]

Which means?

[DannyBres]

display port is becoming the new standard in display interface... and means u can use it with the new LED LCD ACD

[ManuelGnR]

Okay, cool, but I don't think I'll ever buy a ACD, or, not before I'm a millionaire:) Can get a 22'' for 150/160, or a 20'' ACD for 500 or so (euros)..

I believe you if you say ACD is better bla bla, that's why I'll buy it when I'm rich, not now:D

[alphaod]

I believe you if you say ACD is better bla bla, that's why I'll buy it when I'm rich, not now:D

Well the ACD uses a better panel; worth it if you plan to make money off of it. ;)

[ManuelGnR]

If I think clear, I think I should wait till january for an iMac. But I'm not sure if I can wait that long. Plus the MacBooks look awesome.:)

But all that problem-topics make me afraid..:eek:

[ManuelGnR]

Any more advice, please?

The iMac's ain't coming tomorrow, are they:(

[yoppie]

Not a difficult choice really. If you need/want the portability then you go with a MacBook. If you don't care about portability, the iMac isn't a bad choice.

I personally would go with a MacBook but that's because I'm a student and take my notebook with me to school everyday. Also, like previously mentioned you can hook it up to a monitor if you want the feel of a desktop.

[patrickmacrumor]

Not a difficult choice really. If you need/want the portability then you go with a MacBook. If you don't care about portability, the iMac isn't a bad choice.

I personally would go with a MacBook but that's because I'm a student and take my notebook with me to school everyday. Also, like previously mentioned you can hook it up to a monitor if you want the feel of a desktop.

Very well put. It all comes down to whether the OP needs portability or not. I use my MacBook with a monitor 99% of the time. But, when I'm vacation, I like to be able to backup my photos, and write down all my expenses.

[Vulcan]

I honestly wish I got the iMac now instead of the MacBook. It's an awesome computer will a screen that is much better than the MacBook's for less the price.

I feel like it was stupid to get, I never move with it, I freak out if I get anything on the plastic, and even though it has enough power for me, that iMac is more future proof.

[ManuelGnR]

Thanks, that really helps!:)

[ManuelGnR]

It's probably gonna be iMac now...

Counting down till MacWorld '09...

05-01-09 right?