Panther Memory Leak??

[Grimace]

I've been having some serious issues with lag time recently. Programs take FOREVER to load, they just sit and bounce in the dock - laughing at me.

When launching Safari, Word, iTunes - anything, no matter how small or large, the icon bounces - and the computer accesses the hard drive - doing about 2 HD clicks per second.* That goes on for about 30-40 seconds, and then the app opens and runs smoothly. ...Until I move to a different app and then it goes to the HD again.* It's like the computer has ironically forgotten about its memory.* (512 installed)

What's going on here??

[robbieduncan]

I know that this sounds like a Window solution but have you tried rebooting? If you reboot and it all returns to normal then you can be fairly certain that you encountered a memory leak in some app (unlikely to be in the OS. Note that a memory leak does not mean that the system has lost some of your RAM, but that a program has grabbed some and not given it back).

If you do not want to reboot or simply want to know what is causing this then use Activity Monitor (in the Utilities folder in Applications) and sort the process list by memory size. This should show the culprit pretty quickly.

[Grimace]

sorry, I should have posted that I've done that a few times now. Even a full shut down.

[Mac til death]

Does it take you a while to open or save files?

It could be a problem reading from your hard drive. If the program runs fine after you have launched it, and if your hard drive is going bad, that would be a nightmare when it tries to run these programs, open more, save/open files, and use virtual memory.... (j/w how much RAM do you have?)

You may want to pick up or borrow a copy of Disk Warrior and see if everything is ok with your drive... (after you've done the usual problem solvers: fscking, repairing permissions, zapping of pram, trashing prefs, blah blah blah)

[hugemullens]

Open up terminal and type "top". See if you can find if a certian program is hogging ram. I once had safari develop a memory leak and it would just grow and grow in ram until the computer was unusable. It would actually grow to 2 gigs before the terminal would stop responding. The only solution was to reinstall. I reset safari, reinstall, went back to an older version, everything, but it just wasn;t to be.

[Grimace]

It's a 1Ghz PB with 512MB RAM. Thanks for those tips, I'll see what happens with those ideas.

[Grimace]

Does it take you a while to open or save files?

It could be a problem reading from your hard drive. If the program runs fine after you have launched it, and if your hard drive is going bad, that would be a nightmare when it tries to run these programs, open more, save/open files, and use virtual memory.... (j/w how much RAM do you have?)

Really, it's just opening applications - and then switching between them. Sometimes it's fine with 8 apps open. Other times, I open just one app, and I get pinwheels for a minute or two - and then it's super fast like normal.

[Colonel Panik]

Utilities > Activity Monitor.

Open this, then position it where you can see it, and try opening some apps. It'll show you whether it's disk activity, processor overload, memory...

Perhaps you have some huge automatically generated log files. Do you have MacJanitor? It'll clean out logs that Unix normally clears out on a daily/weekly/monthly basis, but if you don't leave your machine running 24/7, these tasks don't get done.
MacJanitor (http://personalpages.tds.net/~brian_hill/downloads.html)

The other thing I can think of is to repair permissions (on the Panther install disks, I think).

[Grimace]

okay, I think the problem is solved. I narrowed it down to "when Safari is open" - then everything sucks. I ran Disk Utility and fsck -yf and all seems to be well now. Thanks everyone!!

[BillClinton]

okay, I think the problem is solved. I narrowed it down to "when Safari is open" - then everything sucks. I ran Disk Utility and fsck -yf and all seems to be well now. Thanks everyone!!

Safari sucks at memory management. It eats up a huge amount of memory!

[rdowns]

Safari sucks at memory management. It eats up a huge amount of memory!

No *****. I ran "top" after learning of the command above and Safari was at 101MB. I only have one window open with 9 tabs (all MR). Talk about a memory hog.

[benixau]

No *****. I ran "top" after learning of the command above and Safari was at 101MB. I only have one window open with 9 tabs (all MR). Talk about a memory hog.

I beat you - i get 120MB with - wait for it - 0 windows open.
Wow apple - this is your lightweight browser - what about heavy weight OSX or FCP? :D

[Le Big Mac]

I beat you - i get 120MB with - wait for it - 0 windows open.
Wow apple - this is your lightweight browser - what about heavy weight OSX or FCP? :D]

I was at 372 with three tabs. Unbelievable. IT doesn't generally affect performance, but iMovie sure was dragging last night. Quit safari.

What's up with that--is it programmed to take everything available or something?

[jesuisme]

]

I was at 372 with three tabs. Unbelievable. IT doesn't generally affect performance, but iMovie sure was dragging last night. Quit safari.

What's up with that--is it programmed to take everything available or something?
Maybe this IS the Mac virus :D. I still refuse to use Explorer, though...

[Powerbook G5]

I've never had memory issues with Safari, perhaps it's a more specific issue?

[Dub]

I have issues with Safari and memory usgae. I have a 1GHz emac with 640MB Ram. I shut down completely and restart once a week. I always have the same apps open all the time ie

Finder
Safari
Mail
itunes
Appleworks
Textedit
Preview

but my free memory varies between about 150MB and 0MB. Safari's memory usage varies between about 10MB and the most I have seen 150MB. The number of tabs seems to make no difference. I have seen Safari use only 50MB with 10 tabs open and yet use 150MB with none open at all or just the one google page or something. Closing all the tabs and hiding safari does not affect this figure. Even when it is doing nothing it seems to require 150MB or RAM. I find it gets worse the longer the machine is on and a restart gets it back to a more reasonable level.

There are two processes that concern me:
Windowserver and (null). They use 50MB each. What is (null) and why does it need 50MB? Is it meant to be there or is it some piece of spyware pretending to be part of the OS? Any ideas?

Cheers,
Dub.

[iindigo]

I've has memory trouble with Safari as well. It doesn't take effect immediatly, only after the app is left open for a while (4 to 6 hours) with tsome windows and/or tabs open. This is a really bad thing when you only have 128MB of RAM.

In fact, it was such a problem I had to switch over to Camino and OmniWeb. :(

[titaniumducky]

My Virtual Memory is size is a little over 5 gigs! Is this OK/Normal? I have 512 MB of RAM and don't have any performance issues. I usually have a bout 5 MB free RAM, 50 MB Wired, 300 MB Active, and 150 MB Inactive.