MacBook Aluminum FREEZE issue - Even with 3 GB of RAM!

[fener]

Hello,

I am an Apple user for the last 7 years, and have been happy with every single one of products, except the new Aluminum MacBooks.

I purchased 4 GB ram, G-Skill, and the MacBook freezes ALL the time after 5 min - 1 hour use. I had tested the ram, and they're good.

So, after reading around, found that the problem is MacBook has 4 GB issues for most of the customers, and until Apple releases a fix, using one of the 2GB chips, to have 3 Gb will do the job.

YES, 3 GB works, 85% of the time. But even with 3GB of ram, there are occasional system freezes!

Anyone having the same with 3GB ram, too?

When will Apple release the RAM fix!?

[mreg376]

Hello,

I am an Apple user for the last 7 years, and have been happy with every single one of products, except the new Aluminum MacBooks.

I purchased 4 GB ram, G-Skill, and the MacBook freezes ALL the time after 5 min - 1 hour use. I had tested the ram, and they're good.

So, after reading around, found that the problem is MacBook has 4 GB issues for most of the customers, and until Apple releases a fix, using one of the 2GB chips, to have 3 Gb will do the job.

YES, 3 GB works, 85% of the time. But even with 3GB of ram, there are occasional system freezes!

Anyone having the same with 3GB ram, too?

When will Apple release the RAM fix!?

Not sure where you got "Macbook has 4GB issues for most of the customers," but that statement is ridiculous. So ridiculous in fact, that it's hard to give any credibility to anything else you say. Either you have bad ram, or a bad Macbook. So put back the original Apple ram, and if it still freezes, and you haven't screwed up OSX, return it to Apple for repairs or replacement.

[akbc]

Are those DDR3 chips?

If so, then I suggest you take it to the nearest Apple Store or Service Provider to consult the issue.

If not, that might be the reason why.

I'm not too sure, but are MacBooks compatible with DDR2 chips at all? (Edit: No, they're not)

[fener]

Are those DDR3 chips?

If so, then I suggest you take it to the nearest Apple Store or Service Provider to consult the issue.

If not, that might be the reason why.

I'm not too sure, but are MacBooks compatible with DDR2 chips at all? (Edit: No, they're not)


Yes, these are DDR3 chips; and if i use 1 stick of 1 GB, and 1 stick of 2GB (G-skill) MacBook works fine; 85% of the time

[fener]

Not sure where you got "Macbook has 4GB issues for most of the customers," but that statement is ridiculous. So ridiculous in fact, that it's hard to give any credibility to anything else you say. Either you have bad ram, or a bad Macbook. So put back the original Apple ram, and if it still freezes, and you haven't screwed up OSX, return it to Apple for repairs or replacement.


MacBook also freezes with Apple sold (samsung branded) 4 GB of ram;

its fine with 2 GB of ram.

Nobody heard of 4 Gb freeze issue with aluminum here?

[akbc]

MacBook also freezes with Apple sold (samsung branded) 4 GB of ram;

its fine with 2 GB of ram.

Nobody heard of 4 Gb freeze issue with aluminum here?

Can you kindly link us to people who have issues?

Even the previous MacBook can support 4GB, and the new DDR3 Alu MacBooks can support upto 4GB officially as well.

It's just you (and maybe a few more people) having a bad RAM or bad MacBook. I suggest you try with other RAM sticks or take your MacBook to a service shop.

[fener]

Can you kindly link us to people who have issues?

Even the previous MacBook can support 4GB, and the new DDR3 Alu MacBooks can support upto 4GB officially as well.

It's just you (and maybe a few more people) having a bad RAM or bad MacBook. I suggest you try with other RAM sticks or take your MacBook to a service shop.


Sure, i can even give out some news and lengthy discussion links about the widely spread issue:

jkontherun - firmware doesn't fix the 4 gb issue (http://jkontherun.com/2008/12/11/mac-firmware-up/)

pcworld - macbook users report lockups (http://www.pcworld.com/businesscenter/article/155186/macbook_users_report_lockups.html)

Apple - random freezes (http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=8415926)


Apple - unstable after ram upgrade (http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=1757875&tstart=15)


Its not that MacBook aluminum doesn't support 4 GB; it does; but there is something wrong with new MacBooks

[tubbymac]

NVidia motherboards (Apple calls them logic boards for some reason) have a fairly notorious history for being finicky with ram.

[sheltem]

Let's not forget how new laptop DDR3 is. There are bound to be compatibility issues. Have you tried talking to G-Skill about this issue?

I wonder if the Lenevo Ideapad U330 (uses DDR3 as well) has similar issues.

[fener]

*UPDATE*

I just spoke to G.Skill on the phone.

They said, DDR3 is fairly new, and the chips might be having compatibility issues with the new Apple chipset.

They further said that they will be holding some tests and will have a result by Monday.

After this discussion, i am not excited about a firmware fix from Apple. After all, if there is a hardware compatibility issue, could firmware fix it? :confused:

I'll keep it posted.

[yetanotherdave]

*UPDATE*

I just spoke to G.Skill on the phone.

They said, DDR3 is fairly new, and the chips might be having compatibility issues with the new Apple chipset.

They further said that they will be holding some tests and will have a result by Monday.

After this discussion, i am not excited about a firmware fix from Apple. After all, if there is a hardware compatibility issue, could firmware fix it? :confused:

I'll keep it posted.

Sounds like you need to return that ram and buy some from a decent manufacturer like kingston or crucial.

[kastenbrust]

Cheap RAM causes computers to randomly freeze, its to do with the way it assigns tasks, buffers and latency but basically you need crucial or RAM made by a reputable company.

[fener]

Thanks for the responses.

I had never had any issues with previous MacBooks; used Patriot, Crucial, ...

I guess this one is more picky. I was gonna get the mushkin one, but ended up with G.Skill.

If it doesn't get solved, i'll get another set.

What do you guys think of this set? It says made by Samsung parts, which is proven to work, as far as I know.

http://cgi.ebay.com/4GB-SAMSUNG-RAM-MEMORY-APPLE-MACBOOK-PRO-DDR3-1066_W0QQitemZ120360343449QQcmdZViewItemQQptZLH_DefaultDomain_0?hash=item120360343449&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14&_trkparms=72%3A1461|66%3A2|65%3A12|39%3A1|240%3A1318|301%3A1|293%3A1|294%3A50

[kastenbrust]

Just get Crucial, stop looking for the cheapest options, Apple have limited which manufacturers RAM works inside their new computers and as far as i know only Crucial and OWC works perfectly without any problems.

[dinaluvsApple]

maybe you should of read the thread over at notebookreview.com regarding g-skill ram in the macbooks.

ive got 4gb of crucial and its flawless.

[ayeying]

maybe you should of read the thread over at notebookreview.com regarding g-skill ram in the macbooks.

ive got 4gb of crucial and its flawless.

I'm using G-Skill. It works flawlessly. I never had a kernel panic or or any freezes.

[canadian4evr]

I have 4GB of crucial memory (http://www.memoryhouse.com/products/3288/CT25664BC1067/CRUCIAL TECHNOLOGY/)... and having the same freezing issues with the new unibody macbook.

Macbook runs like a dream with the 4GB until it freezes, that is!

With the Apple 2GB memory, the system runs fine.

Called Crucial, they are aware of the issue with the new macbooks. They offered to send me another set, but I chose to RMA the set and wait it out, until the problem has fixed itself.

[neiltc13]

Apple is punishing people for buying 4GB RAM when they really don't need it.

[brop52]

Just get Crucial, stop looking for the cheapest options, Apple have limited which manufacturers RAM works inside their new computers and as far as i know only Crucial and OWC works perfectly without any problems.

As far as you know, maybe. In truth, wrong. I went through two OWC sets to no avail until Apple wanted to do research on my MB and exchanged my computer and RAM.

[kastenbrust]

As far as you know, maybe. In truth, wrong. I went through two OWC sets to no avail until Apple wanted to do research on my MB and exchanged my computer and RAM.

I heard on this forum OWC is good, but sorry if its a poor recommendation, we dont have it in the UK, only crucial, but im sure that works perfectly with 3GB in your model.

[fener]

Anyone got these set?

http://cgi.ebay.com/4GB-2X-2GB-CERTIFIED-RAM-MEMORY-APPLE-MACBOOK-PRO-DDR3_W0QQitemZ320331018160QQcmdZViewItemQQptZLH_DefaultDomain_0?hash=item320331018160&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14&_trkparms=72%3A1205|66%3A2|65%3A12|39%3A1|240%3A1318|301%3A1|293%3A1|294%3A50


People reporting 100% success.

[mmnz]

i have a macbook alum 2.4ghz with 2gb ram, nothing has been altered but after using it for a month now, the OS freezes after 1 hour of use, what could be the problem??:rolleyes:

[John Jacob]

Yes, these are DDR3 chips; and if i use 1 stick of 1 GB, and 1 stick of 2GB (G-skill) MacBook works fine; 85% of the time

If your MacBook freezes 15% of the time with 2GB of G-Skill RAM, then that is the problem. Running a RAM test once may not detect a problem, ideally you have to keep it running in single user mode with no other programs for hours on end.

I have a 4GB unibody MacBook that is 2 months old not, and I have never had a problem (ordered online with 4GB of Apple RAM).

[emil10001]

i have a macbook alum 2.4ghz with 2gb ram, nothing has been altered but after using it for a month now, the OS freezes after 1 hour of use, what could be the problem??:rolleyes:

I'm having the same issue, 2.0ghz version, 2gb ram. It randomly freezes on me. I've had it for a couple of weeks, and this just started yesterday for me.

[fuzzycuffs]

I upgraded my new unibody 2.0 to 4gb from OWC with no problems. Search the forum and it's been talked about a lot.

OS: 10.5.6 + all firmware updates

I did do a complete reinstall of the system though. I was noticing a lot of instability/freezes when I used it straight from the box as well, even with 2GB.

Reinstall OSX and everything's been fine.

[Young Turk]

maybe you should of read the thread over at notebookreview.com regarding g-skill ram in the macbooks.

ive got 4gb of crucial and its flawless.

Same here.

YoungTurk

[emil10001]

I upgraded my new unibody 2.0 to 4gb from OWC with no problems. Search the forum and it's been talked about a lot.

OS: 10.5.6 + all firmware updates

I did do a complete reinstall of the system though. I was noticing a lot of instability/freezes when I used it straight from the box as well, even with 2GB.

Reinstall OSX and everything's been fine.

I will do a reinstall, I need to put a bigger drive in it anyways, but I am current with all my firmware. I guess that when I install linux on another partition, I'll probably run a memtest, and then see how linux behaves for a few days. Hopefully, it's not a hardware issue.

[MooneyFlyer]

2.4GHz 4G Crucial 10.5.6 + all patches / FW updates. Not a single freeze since the FW updates and 10.5.6 (not sure which seemed to fix the issue for me). Been using this for months without a freeze.

[mtalantikite]

I've been having the same issues with mine for the past two months.

I have 4GB of Kingston in my macbook aluminum, and it freezes all the time -- it's up to something like 5 times a day now. It happens even with the original 2GB installed. I've tested the ram and it passes, fresh installs of os x don't help, nothing gets left in any logs, so I'm not really sure what it could be at this point.

I'm going to have Apple replace it, it's to the point where it's not operational anymore.

[aznguyen316]

Well I'm hoping I don't run into these issues. Just ordered OWC 4GB ram and will install first thing and will test it out and see before sending back the 2GB sticks for rebate. I can always do a system reinstall if necessary as well.

[gumshoe3]

Ive been having some hard freezes with my mbp unibody . Been thinking it was software issues until I put the original 2 gigs of
ram back in and the freezing stopped ,2 weeks so far ! Watch out for that
patriot brand .

[polska9]

mine isnt freezing but since i upgraded to kingston 4gb ram my beachball comes on far too often and sometimes just freezes programs especially microsoft word

[California]

no problems here with 2.4ghz MacBook and four gigs of Apple installed ram.

[WannaApple?]

I came here to get some help in regards to my MB Aluminum starting to freeze and I see this thread, however I am working on a standard out of the box MB with no upgrades to RAM. However, what I find strange is that the freezing just started happening over the last week or so and I've had the computer since Christmas. I know that MBs arent really susceptible to viruses, but I was also wondering about spyware as this is the way my PC got when I had spyware/malware.
Seems strange to me that it wouldnt start happening until 2 months after purchase. With the exception of doing a reinstall, is there anything else we can try?

[aluminumapple]

i honestly find this thread unbelievable. not for a second unless i see for myself there is something wrong with it, and even if its true, you either do have bad ram or a really bad macbook or a crippled OS in either case go see apple!

[sn00pie]

Sounds like an odd problem that is only affecting a handful of users. Have you contacted Apple? What did they say?