PDA

View Full Version : Ripping Tracks - can we still do it?




sparky76
Aug 21, 2003, 04:39 PM
I recently purchased (in the UK) a CD by Kings of Leon from an online retailer. However, when I received it, the disc was copy-protected, so it would play in a CD player or on a PC (after installing its own proprietary player), but not on the Mac, so I could not put it on the ipod. I rang the supplier and said I was rejecting the goods as they were not a true "red book" CD and was refunded.
But I still want the album.
Does the US version have copy-protection?
If so, do you know where I can download it? I am happy to pay for my music, but not if I am to be treated like a criminal for wanting to put it on the ipod.



Billicus
Aug 21, 2003, 05:40 PM
Originally posted by mark.borland
I recently purchased (in the UK) a CD by Kings of Leon from an online retailer. However, when I received it, the disc was copy-protected, so it would play in a CD player or on a PC (after installing its own proprietary player), but not on the Mac, so I could not put it on the ipod. I rang the supplier and said I was rejecting the goods as they were not a true "red book" CD and was refunded.
But I still want the album.
Does the US version have copy-protection?
If so, do you know where I can download it? I am happy to pay for my music, but not if I am to be treated like a criminal for wanting to put it on the ipod.

There are several on the iTunes Music Store, but it doesn't work in the UK, so that's no good for you... Any other ideas anybody?

iGav
Aug 23, 2003, 11:24 AM
Originally posted by mark.borland
I recently purchased (in the UK) a CD by Kings of Leon from an online retailer. However, when I received it, the disc was copy-protected, so it would play in a CD player or on a PC (after installing its own proprietary player), but not on the Mac, so I could not put it on the ipod. I rang the supplier and said I was rejecting the goods as they were not a true "red book" CD and was refunded.
But I still want the album.
Does the US version have copy-protection?
If so, do you know where I can download it? I am happy to pay for my music, but not if I am to be treated like a criminal for wanting to put it on the ipod.

If it's from an online retailer it might not be a UK disc...

You could be sneaky.... I went into HMV once to see if I could get away with it, I took my PowerBook in and asked if I could try a CD because I wasn't sure if it had copy-protection that would stop it working on my Mac, and as my PowerBook was my major music playing device then I didn't want to travel home to find out it doesn't work and then require me to travel back in to return it!

Anyway's, they hand me the CD I slot it in, (and lets face it, most saturday staff don't really know their arse from their elbow) so I just started importing it whilst playing, right in front of them... :eek: :eek: :p

I then said it wasn't the actual album I wanted, handed them back their CD and left...

Bad, Bad, Bad iGav... *slap's wrists several times* I've never done it again though... :D

sparky76
Aug 23, 2003, 11:30 AM
sorry - the UK version was what I got - I went into HMV today and saw that the copy they were selling had the same copy-protection. Any ideas?

iGav
Aug 23, 2003, 11:43 AM
Originally posted by mark.borland
sorry - the UK version was what I got - I went into HMV today and saw that the copy they were selling had the same copy-protection. Any ideas?

doesn't the magic marker line trick work on some of these CD things??

I've never bought a CD with protection on so I don't really know...

You would have thought that some clever techie would've come up with a first rate hack for this wouldn't you?

I haven't the foggiest then bud... soz. :(

idea_hamster
Aug 23, 2003, 12:19 PM
Originally posted by iGAV
...so I just started importing it whilst playing, right in front of them...
Dude! That's a special kind of chutzpah you've got. That's not your garden-variety brass set. Reminds me of a Futurama episode:

Clamps: Are you trying to rip off the DonBot?
Bender: I'm trying, but he's not making it easy.

Tequila Grandma
Aug 23, 2003, 07:25 PM
Originally posted by iGAV
doesn't the magic marker line trick work on some of these CD things??

I've never bought a CD with protection on so I don't really know...

You would have thought that some clever techie would've come up with a first rate hack for this wouldn't you?

I haven't the foggiest then bud... soz. :(
This is also what I'd like to know. I'm interested in getting Shiina Ringo's "Karuki Zamen Kuri No Hana", but it's copy-protected :(