PDA

View Full Version : AE CS4 on 13" MBP?




JustLikeYou
Jul 10, 2009, 09:08 AM
Hey guys! So I've been browsing, and I'm pretty sure this is where I should be posting this question. If not, sorry... :(... I haven't posted in quite some time.

Anyhow, I'm a design student and for the past year and a half I've been using my 13" 2.16 model macbook for all my design work, paired with a 22" widescreen Samsung LCD monitor. I always told myself I would get a 15" or 17" MBP for my senior year and for the "real world", but honestly, I've fallen in love with the portability of my 13" when not in the class or in my room connected to the external monitor.

When they made the announcement of the upgrades for the "new" 13" MBP, I really started considering that instead. However, up to this point, I've only used the Design Premium CS3, and I need to upgrade to CS4 to get After Effects. My question is, do you think the 13" MBP would be able to handle it? I won't be doing any major 3D work (unless you consider converting 2D text and vector layers to 3D layers), and it will mostly be motion graphics that aren't really 3D render heavy. I know the interface will feel a bit squished, since the resolution requirements are 100 pixels higher than the 13" screen allows, but again, I compensate for that by attaching to the 22" widescreen when I'm not "on the go"

So opinions? Do you think the computer will physically be able to handle it? Or will I have to go with the bulkier 15" model?



lucidmedia
Jul 10, 2009, 11:23 AM
I have done "light" AE work as you describe on my macbook air (rev b) and been pleased with it, so I don't think you should have major issues. Handles it just fine! Like you, I do plug in to a larger monitor when in studio tho...


Hey guys! So I've been browsing, and I'm pretty sure this is where I should be posting this question. If not, sorry... :(... I haven't posted in quite some time.

Anyhow, I'm a design student and for the past year and a half I've been using my 13" 2.16 model macbook for all my design work, paired with a 22" widescreen Samsung LCD monitor. I always told myself I would get a 15" or 17" MBP for my senior year and for the "real world", but honestly, I've fallen in love with the portability of my 13" when not in the class or in my room connected to the external monitor.

When they made the announcement of the upgrades for the "new" 13" MBP, I really started considering that instead. However, up to this point, I've only used the Design Premium CS3, and I need to upgrade to CS4 to get After Effects. My question is, do you think the 13" MBP would be able to handle it? I won't be doing any major 3D work (unless you consider converting 2D text and vector layers to 3D layers), and it will mostly be motion graphics that aren't really 3D render heavy. I know the interface will feel a bit squished, since the resolution requirements are 100 pixels higher than the 13" screen allows, but again, I compensate for that by attaching to the 22" widescreen when I'm not "on the go"

So opinions? Do you think the computer will physically be able to handle it? Or will I have to go with the bulkier 15" model?

JustLikeYou
Jul 13, 2009, 01:03 PM
Hey, thanks. Yeah... if your Air can run it, I should be fine. I always thought the bias against the little computers was funny... every time I had a problem with a file, my teacher's response was always "Well, your first problem is this computer..." even though it never crashed or froze or anything.

I've been test-running the After Effects CS4 download on my current macbook the past couple days to see how it runs... I've got the one with the GMA 950 chip and 2GB ram... and it's been slow but runs it, so I'm sure the new 13" MBP will do fine.

NathanCH
Jul 13, 2009, 02:07 PM
It's a shame you need to go to CS4 to get AE. CS4 is way heavier than CS3 in my experience.

JustLikeYou
Jul 13, 2009, 02:27 PM
Yeah, I would like to keep CS3, but I can't buy After Effects separately... unless I want to spend $500. But in that case, I can just go through my school and get the whole Master Collection CS4 for the same $500, which is what I'm doing (yes, it's real, not an upgrade or partial programs... my school gets awesome deals on adobe and apple products for some reason).

We also get pretty good discounts above and beyond apple's education pricing as well. $1050 for the new base model 13" MBP and $1500 for the base model 15" one. Score. I love being a student.

lucidmedia
Jul 13, 2009, 08:21 PM
It's a shame you need to go to CS4 to get AE. CS4 is way heavier than CS3 in my experience.

Personally, on the Air, I found CS4's performance much better... mainly due to the hardware/graphics acceleration.

OCSpersonel
Jul 14, 2009, 12:29 AM
i have the UMB 2.4 with 4 gigs of ram, it runs after effects perfectly. i havent done anything incredible but i havent had an issue with it yet

poematik14
Jul 15, 2009, 03:11 PM
Yeah, I would like to keep CS3, but I can't buy After Effects separately... unless I want to spend $500. But in that case, I can just go through my school and get the whole Master Collection CS4 for the same $500, which is what I'm doing (yes, it's real, not an upgrade or partial programs... my school gets awesome deals on adobe and apple products for some reason).



Or you could just get it on torrents.

jive
Jul 28, 2009, 10:23 AM
I have CS4 running (Photoshop, Illustrator, DreamWeaver and After Effects at once most of the time tbh) perfectly well on my 13" MBP with SSH and 4Gb RAM.