PDA

View Full Version : Logo criticism please!




Hector Domingo
Aug 9, 2009, 10:42 AM
Hi guys, i am soon to be launching a personal website, and i am mid in the process of creating a logo for it. It is attached underneath. Please be as critical as possible, and give as many improvement suggestions as possible. The colors are the website's theme colors, and i have used 'The Gimp' on a mac to create this logo.
Thanks



sthursby
Aug 9, 2009, 11:00 AM
What's the website's purpose? Potential market? Is it for a company or just for your own personal site?

Frankly, I find it uninspiring, but there could be meanings to the circular shape, colours & pattern which haven't been properly explained. Logos depend way more on meaning than they do on pure aesthetics.

LeviG
Aug 9, 2009, 12:12 PM
sthursby - the op states its for his personal site that will be launching soon :rolleyes:

Personally, I think the R would work better if it was one colour but other than that without more info on your site theres not really much else I can comment on.

bntz313
Aug 9, 2009, 12:26 PM
The R is just not sitting right with me. I think it is the more amount of space on the left than the right.

Also, I'll say it before everyone else does...Try working in black in white first.

Designer Dale
Aug 9, 2009, 04:02 PM
Hi.

The idea of working in black and white that is mentioned above is this: if it ever moves beyond a personal website, you have something that can go straight to the print shop for a business card without having to reinvent the wheel. "Work small and work in B&W" are often heard in these threads, and that is why.

Balance is something to keep in mind no matter what you are designing. The R is a bit off to me, also, and I don't care for the stepped effect used on the right. I would go with something clearly symmetrical, with the space on right side identical to that on the left (as I view it), like parenthesis. Or make the right seem more purposeful and extend it evenly to the right and give it a flag look.

Just my thoughts. This is what it looks like in black.

Note: An R is an awkward letter to place in a circle shape. Flat on one side and curvy on the other, especially with a leggy serif like this.

Dale

bntz313
Aug 9, 2009, 04:32 PM
yeah, I think the logo needs a little more thought. I'm just not feeling the whole thing, not to be a a**.

I like what the person ^ said maybe try a different font to make it look a little better.

AngryApple
Aug 9, 2009, 08:33 PM
I think it would be more 'interesting' if the R was backwards. Looks good in my head.

SwiftLives
Aug 9, 2009, 10:01 PM
Try some other variations on the "R." Sans Serif? Something very rounded along the lines of Gotham or Avant Garde. Or perhaps make the "R" yourself using a circle. Heck - try a lowercase 'r'.

I wouldn't call what you have a final logo. But you do have a solid jumping off point. I look forward to seeing some further explorations.

THX1139
Aug 10, 2009, 12:49 AM
Another classic example of why logo development should be left to professionals. Well, that is if you are serious about your business or what you are trying to achieve.

However, if you are only offering a local service type of business and just need a quick logo- then what you have is lovely. Just slap it on the side of your pickup truck and you're good to go! "Roscoe's post hole digging service" :D

ezekielrage_99
Aug 10, 2009, 02:39 AM
IMHO the R without the boxy stuff but with the same colour treatment would look good.

Hector Domingo
Aug 10, 2009, 03:37 AM
Thanks for the quick reply, and sorry i didn't give enough information.
I am a part-time website designer, who currently designs for local businesses, looking to expand to the internet to attract a wider range of customers.

one question i have is:
With work in B&W do you mean the entire scale, or just the two shades?

My name is Patrick Rice, and the domain name is patrickrice.co.uk, as i am based in the UK. Here are a few of mock-ups of the suggestions that you have put forward:

ezekielrage_99
Aug 10, 2009, 04:26 AM
Try combining the P and R together, I think a simple concept like that will work well.

yoyo5280
Aug 10, 2009, 04:28 AM
I like the first one you posted, but maybe you can make the R a solid dark red, or something.

P.S. You want critique I think, criticism generally is negative I think

-Omi

AlexisV
Aug 10, 2009, 04:43 AM
First thing I saw with the logo was IRF.

Logos with just letters are a nightmare at the best of times. Just write your name out in full in a suitable font (not the naff serifed R you have going on at the moment).