PDA

View Full Version : iMac G5 - worth buying?




iann1982
Aug 17, 2009, 03:30 PM
Hi - I've come across an iMac G5 for 200, it's the 17" model, 1gb of ram.

I primarily want to use it as an apple TV server / file server, with occasional use as a tv (with dongle)

Any views? Good price / bad price?

I'd been looking at the G4 - yet, they seem more expensive for what you get.



Hellhammer
Aug 17, 2009, 03:33 PM
Looked at eBay and they were +300 so you have a nice deal. I would get it. It's good machine for server use (HD is easily changeable).

Shake 'n' Bake
Aug 17, 2009, 03:38 PM
I'd try to find a PowerMac G4. It was intended to be used as a server. The drives are easier to replace as well.

As long as it has gigabit ethernet, you should be good.

rtrt
Aug 17, 2009, 04:44 PM
Hi - I've come across an iMac G5 for 200, it's the 17" model, 1gb of ram.

I primarily want to use it as an apple TV server / file server, with occasional use as a tv (with dongle)

Any views? Good price / bad price?

I'd been looking at the G4 - yet, they seem more expensive for what you get.

I have an iMac G5 ALS 20" and tbh if it was me i wouldn't get a G5 iMac for anything that involved long hours powered on like a server.

There's a lot of hearsay/evidence that they're susceptible to overheating which might be combined with/caused by capacitor issues in the psu or on the main logic board. A couple of links below give you a flavour

http://www.jimwarholic.com/2008/07/how-to-repair-apple-imac-g5.php
http://www.xlr8yourmac.com/systems/iMacG5_cooling/imac_g5_cooling_fan.html

Of course you can't tell whether a specific machine will have problems or not, but in my opinion it's reasonable to say that as a model they're not as reliable as other Macs. Others on here may disagree.

If I were to buy one - i'd look to get as much of a trial period as i possibly could - for example I've just retrieved mine from home as it was shutting down regularly - as best i could tell it would last around 6-8 hours before shutting down with no warning. So someone could easily sell an iMac like that and the new owner might not discover there was a problem for days.

I've traced my problem to the psu overheating and i'll either leave it outside the machine as it is now - working fine, buy a refurb one or replace the capacitors and see if that fixes it permanently.

FireArse
Aug 17, 2009, 04:55 PM
At this age they're dropping like flies. Better off putting your money on the G4 - the chap above is spot on. Far greater reliability. I've seen these go on and on.

+1 on the Gb ethernet or newer.

F

MTI
Aug 17, 2009, 04:59 PM
The capacitor problems weren't from overheating, it was just a case of bad industrial espionage winding up with defective parts being used in many brands of computers.


200 is a bit dear, but not unreasonable.

Shake 'n' Bake
Aug 17, 2009, 05:02 PM
At this age they're dropping like flies. Better off putting your money on the G4 - the chap above is spot on. Far greater reliability. I've seen these go on and on.

+1 on the Gb ethernet or newer.

F

Are you talking about my response?

Here's (http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?p=8293402) a guide to setting up an iTunes server.

rtrt
Aug 17, 2009, 05:07 PM
The capacitor problems weren't from overheating, it was just a case of bad industrial espionage winding up with defective parts being used in many brands of computers.

agreed.

but apparently one of the symptoms of the poor electrolyte is the caps overheating and or drifting out of spec and so causing the machine to display probs like unexpected switch off, display corruption and other things.

i have no personal experience apart from what i said about my psu above, rest i've picked up from reading around to try to understand my problem.

Shake 'n' Bake
Aug 17, 2009, 09:07 PM
If you end up getting a PowerMac, beware some are quite loud. If you want it to be quiet, you can make a wood box with a door. Put a 60 mm case fan in the back and power it with one of the smaller nine-volt batteries. Then line the box with melamine foam aka Basotect aka Mr. Clean Magic Eraser. I've always wanted to do this, but haven't gotten around to it.

kuebby
Aug 21, 2009, 12:29 AM
I wouldn't get it, for not much more (I'd guess since I don't really know UK prices) you should be able to get a Core Duo, even a Core 2 Duo, both of which will be SO much faster and will be supported by Apple at least through the next OSX upgrade; and since Snow Leopard will be out in a month at most does it really make sense to buy a computer that won't even support it?

California
Aug 23, 2009, 10:21 AM
I'd only buy the iSight iMac G5s, the last and best revision. They came with an Apple remote, too. I like the 17" 1.9ghz iMac G5s. Can take 2.5 gbs of ram.

Macky-Mac
Aug 24, 2009, 02:29 PM
i'm still using my G5 iMac, and it's working fine..........but I don't think you should get a G5 at this point. Buying the cheapest intel based iMac you can find would be a better idea