Is Apple TV's hard drive really big enough??

I stream all of my content from my computer and have never had an issue. i have easily over 160GB of content too.

I have the 40GB version.

Not if you intend to store everything on it. In that case you either need to hack it to allow for a USB HDD extension, open it to put in another HDD, or buy a Mini, which would be easier all the way around.

If you just store current seasons of shows on there then yes, it's probably enough. If you watch more than maybe 10 shows per season then it will fill up fast and then I'd question if the ATV is right for you.

I have a 40GB version and it's more than enough storage for me because I don't sync anything to the device, I just stream.

It's really not meant to hold your whole library, its meant to allow you watch your library on your HDTV. In that case, you set it to automatically sync a portion of material to it. Not that larger harddrives aren't a help, but its clearly not meant to house all of your media.

harpal999 said:

I've heard that people have modded their apple tv and put bigger hard drives in, but I don't really like the idea of this because if I screw it up (which i probably will), im guessing its going to invalidate the warranty and stuff...

Click to expand...

There are several popular Apple TV programs you can download an install to enable the USB port to be turned on, allowing use of external hard drives attached to the Apple TV. Doing this will not void the warranty as you don't have to open up the box.

I think it depends on your set-up. I have a terribly old router and a laptop. If I want to sync content or reliably stream HD content I end up connecting my ethernet cable to my laptop which is a pain. I usually sync all unwatched TV shows, maybe some random shows to watch if I'm bored and a movie or two and at that point the drive is pretty full... mind you, I have the 40GB version. That's not really an issue with the Apple TV, but with my home network. Having an always-on desktop that was serving up the content would also make a difference.
The one time I DO wish it had a bigger hard drive is when I go away for the weekend (parent's, partner's, vacation, etc) and want to take my Apple TV with me. I end up having to be very picky and wish I could have 500GB-1TB in there. There are workarounds to adding bigger hard drives and/or external storage but I would prefer to have an internal solution.

harpal999 said:

I've heard that people have modded their apple tv and put bigger hard drives in, but I don't really like the idea of this because if I screw it up (which i probably will), im guessing its going to invalidate the warranty and stuff...

Click to expand...

There is no problem with enabling the USB port. The whole patching operation will NOT void your warranty.

There are several tools available. A good start is this free tool.

I have well over a terabyte of stuff and I only use the 40GB version. I stream everything except that I just keep my podcasts on the ATV's HD.

I'm with the others: I have about 250 GB of content stored on an external NAS streaming to my 40 GB Apple TV (through a Mac Mini running iTunes).

It appears just as any other content that is synced.

tom1971 said:

There is no problem with enabling the USB port. The whole patching operation will NOT void your warranty.

There are several tools available. A good start is this free tool.

Click to expand...

Also note that if you do mess it up, you can recover the ATV back to it's factory settings quite easily and start again:

http://support.apple.com/kb/HT3180

I bet you can't guess how I found that out

No, that was one of the reasons I didnt buy an TV. It either needs to have a 2tb harddrive or it might as well not even have one. I am just about to fill up my 1tb external with just movies and tv. Luckily my Mini has 5 usb ports and FW800

harpal999 said:

Oh ok, so is it easy to move stuff between your apple tv and pc, even under the same itunes account?

eg. if i downloaded a movie straight onto my apple tv and watched it, could i move it to my pc? and vice versa?

Click to expand...

It is synced to your PC so, yes you would be able to view it on your PC. And any music, movie or podcast file I have in iTunes on my iMac is available to me on my AppleTV....though I have none of those files actually stored on the AppleTV...it's all synched together and my content streams between ATV and PC. No need to 'move it'...it just works.

At least it works this way with my Mac...I am assuming the premise is the same on the PC side. iTunes is the key to the operation.