PDA

View Full Version : Mac Pro Motherboards




r0ger
Feb 6, 2010, 12:24 PM
Do all flavors of current Mac Pro use the same motherboard?
i.e. same one for bottom of range and top of range?



robbieduncan
Feb 6, 2010, 12:35 PM
Yes. But the CPUs and memory are mounted on a slide-in daughter board which varies between the 4 and 8 core models.

r0ger
Feb 7, 2010, 09:27 AM
Does the single processor model have the daughterboard as well, (unpopulated).?

robbieduncan
Feb 7, 2010, 09:32 AM
Does the single processor model have the daughterboard as well, (unpopulated).?

There is a single daughterboard. It is not the same between the single and dual CPU machines: the single CPU machines do not have an unpopulated CPU socket. If you buy a single CPU machine and want to upgrade it to dual CPU you would need to find a dual-CPU daughterboard (Apple do not sell them to consumers) as well as the extra CPU and an extra heatsink (again Apple do not sell them). You cannot easily use other parts: the daughterboards and heatsinks are unique Apple parts.

alphaod
Feb 7, 2010, 09:41 AM
There is a single daughterboard. It is not the same between the single and dual CPU machines: the single CPU machines do not have an unpopulated CPU socket. If you buy a single CPU machine and want to upgrade it to dual CPU you would need to find a dual-CPU daughterboard (Apple do not sell them to consumers) as well as the extra CPU and an extra heatsink (again Apple do not sell them). You cannot easily use other parts: the daughterboards and heatsinks are unique Apple parts.

Even the dual processor CPU is a custom Apple part since it does not have an integrated heat-spreader. Of course you can make do with a regular processor, but you risk damaging the socket which does not have a CPU clamp either.

r0ger
Feb 8, 2010, 05:01 AM
So it appears to mean that the processor choice you start with is what you are stuck with. I had hoped that going in at an entry level model, I could later on say 2-3 years, purchase a CPU and sink and improve it a modest cost so as to make the investment last longer.
I am retired so I tend to think long term now.

robbieduncan
Feb 8, 2010, 05:05 AM
So it appears to mean that the processor choice you start with is what you are stuck with. I had hoped that going in at an entry level model, I could later on say 2-3 years, purchase a CPU and sink and improve it a modest cost so as to make the investment last longer.
I am retired so I tend to think long term now.

In 2-3 years the CPUs that fit those sockets will be out of production anyway (Intel change sockets every 18 months or so) and you would be looking on eBay. So, really, this changes nothing with regards to that.