PDA

View Full Version : System upgrade - How much of an increase?




joe.cavers
Mar 11, 2010, 10:57 AM
Hey,

So I'm currently running Live and Logic on a MBP 2.33Ghz with 3Gb of RAM. It's starting to choke on my Live sessions, dropout and crackles, even with the buffer raised quite high (4096).

I'm considering buying an iMac (I never do much in the way of location recording any more, much more of a bedroom producer/composer these days), and I was wondering what sort of an increase I could expect if I upgraded to a 3.06Ghz Dual Core with 4Gb of DDR3?

On some of my toughest sessions just now, when everything is playing the CPU is spiking around 80% in Live and still not coping.

I'd like it to be future proof for at least a while (I bought this one second hand, definitely regret that now), but if the increase isn't going to be massive, I'll probably wait for the quad-core MBP refresh, rather than save money by going with a 21.5" iMac.

Cheers
J



newuser2310
Mar 11, 2010, 01:37 PM
I'm running the base spec 21" Imac, I probably use 25 audio/software tracks on average each with loads of plugins/effects, with the i/o buffer set to 64.

Performance has been faultless. I'm not sure how much of an increase you would notice though and I wish I had spent more money and got the i5 or i7.

ChrisA
Mar 11, 2010, 01:59 PM
Hey,

So I'm currently running Live and Logic on a MBP 2.33Ghz with 3Gb of RAM. It's starting to choke on my Live sessions,
J

In general you have to about double the specs on the computer to see a noticeable improvement. That would put you square into "Mac Pro Land".

joe.cavers
Mar 11, 2010, 02:20 PM
I'm running the base spec 21" Imac, I probably use 25 audio/software tracks on average each with loads of plugins/effects, with the i/o buffer set to 64.

Performance has been faultless. I'm not sure how much of an increase you would notice though and I wish I had spent more money and got the i5 or i7.

This sounds encouraging, any chance of a screenshot of a typical session? That said however, if you reckon I wouldn't see much of an increase, holding out for an i5 (at least) is probably worth it.

J

newuser2310
Mar 11, 2010, 04:34 PM
I noticed a huge difference because my old machine was a lowly ibook 64! I couldn't even play most of my tracks in real time, they had to be bounced down first!

I'm not running logic in 64bit mode as it causes quite a few third party plug ins to become glitchy and cause crashes.

I am running logic along with itunes, firefox and transmission(torrent) though.

Currently my set up is more than adequate but I plan to buy an Access Virus ti polar later on this year so I will probably look to upgrade to an i7.

The track is just something I made the other day, not overly taxing on the computer but gives you an idea.

joe.cavers
Mar 11, 2010, 04:44 PM
That's definitely superior to my machine, that's for sure! I might ask the local Mac Store if I can take some of my heavier sessions in and try them out on the iMac's in store, I know they have a 21.5" in there.

Cheers for the help!

I checked out the Geekbench scores for the quad iMacs vs my current machine and they absolutely slay it, so still could be well worth saving for.

Any other input?

J

Comma
Mar 11, 2010, 08:54 PM
Quitting Firefox should give you a fair amount of RAM back. Also. Show me a screenshot of your Mixer page.