I just got my apple case in today. Here are my initial thoughts.
The incase case feels really nice and sturdy with the leather, there is also an elastic strap to keep everything closed. Though it makes it bulkier. The main problem I have had with this case is that no matter how much I have tried to stretch it out, the connection ports don't line up with their corresponding places in the leather. I can push it into place, and then it slowly slides back out. The case also sits up nicely but not as high as the apple case.
The apple case is nice, but almost feels cheap in comparison. The sides are pressed together and fused from what I can tell. The main thing that I like about the apple case is just how thin it is. It looks much smaller in my bag, but still feels nice in your hands. The case stands up nicely when you fold it back on itself, but still folds flat for reading. it would be nice if there was some sort of elastic strip like the incase model.
Overall, I'm still out on which one I like better, I still have a little time to decide as I should be able to take it back to Apple within 14 days.
I'm still out on which one I'll keep.