I got my GF a pink bumper first and I loved it (other than the color) so I was excited to get my black one but it sucks because it feels so damn rubbery, it's harder to slip in my jeans pocket and every day I have to wipe all the crap off of it because dust, pocket lint and hair cling to the damn thing
hers is fine
i also noticed hers fit better out of the box, mine is not as snug