Of all the rancor and complaining about the new ATV...something weird has happened for me...I am actually RELIEVED that I am lucky enough to have the old ATVs.
I have no desire for ATV2 and I agree with others that its 3 steps backwards and 1 step forwards (price).
However, anyone else notice that this is typical apple behavior when they have lost vision for their products? Apple has great vision for some of their products and with those, you'll notice value is always enhanced...never decreased. Iphone has continually got more compelling since its release. Apple hasn't stripped it of anything. The same can be said for the Ipod Touch and most Macs as well as OSX.
But then there's apple's island of misfit toys...
You realize, the same rancor that is occurring here with ATV is also occurring over in the Ipod Nano forums. Another product apple has lost vision for. One time around it has a camera, one time it has a touch screen, one time is has a radio, one time it has a clickwheel, one time it has a mic...apple continues to add/subtract features from the nano, just like the ATV because they honestly have no idea what to do with them. They are simply throwing things at the wall, trying to find out what sticks. The ipod shuffle when through this last year with the buttonless version. The backlash for that was swift and severe. The same will most likely be the case with both the nano and ATV this time around.
Wait a year or two...Jobs calling ATV a hobby STILL was NOT a good sign. Apple still has no idea what to do in the living room...they completely lack vision there.
We will either end up with ATV2 for another 4 years with minimal updates as it continues to sell poorly, or it will get canned all together.
Either way, man am I happy to have my first gen ATVs at this point...never thought they would look so good!
(I also still love my 1st gen nano and wouldn't trade it for any of the others...)
Apple is their own company and they can make and sell whatever they want...the truth is in the pudding (sales)...if they don't release ATV2 sales numbers (just like ATV1 and the macbook air)...you can be sure its flopping...
I have no desire for ATV2 and I agree with others that its 3 steps backwards and 1 step forwards (price).
However, anyone else notice that this is typical apple behavior when they have lost vision for their products? Apple has great vision for some of their products and with those, you'll notice value is always enhanced...never decreased. Iphone has continually got more compelling since its release. Apple hasn't stripped it of anything. The same can be said for the Ipod Touch and most Macs as well as OSX.
But then there's apple's island of misfit toys...
You realize, the same rancor that is occurring here with ATV is also occurring over in the Ipod Nano forums. Another product apple has lost vision for. One time around it has a camera, one time it has a touch screen, one time is has a radio, one time it has a clickwheel, one time it has a mic...apple continues to add/subtract features from the nano, just like the ATV because they honestly have no idea what to do with them. They are simply throwing things at the wall, trying to find out what sticks. The ipod shuffle when through this last year with the buttonless version. The backlash for that was swift and severe. The same will most likely be the case with both the nano and ATV this time around.
Wait a year or two...Jobs calling ATV a hobby STILL was NOT a good sign. Apple still has no idea what to do in the living room...they completely lack vision there.
We will either end up with ATV2 for another 4 years with minimal updates as it continues to sell poorly, or it will get canned all together.
Either way, man am I happy to have my first gen ATVs at this point...never thought they would look so good!
(I also still love my 1st gen nano and wouldn't trade it for any of the others...)
Apple is their own company and they can make and sell whatever they want...the truth is in the pudding (sales)...if they don't release ATV2 sales numbers (just like ATV1 and the macbook air)...you can be sure its flopping...