Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

kiranmk2

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Oct 4, 2008
1,535
1,988
After having ripped most of my DVDs to m4vs, I've recently been ripping the extras (deleted scenes, documentaries etc). At the moment, they're just sat in folders and I know it's going to be a nightmare trying to get everything to look nice in iTunes and on the ATV. However, iTunes Extras gave me hope that a solution was on the way, where all the files (film + extras) could be packaged up into one big .ite file.

I really hope the next version of iLife has the option to export to an .ite file instead of just being able to burn DVDs as I really like the iDVD interface. In the meantime, I'm quite surprised noone has come up with a little gui like metaX or Subler to make simple files.

So you start with some templates for layouts (such as a picture to the side with menu items or, the menu items over one big picture) and then you can add buttons that take you to new pages (such as a chapters page or an extras page each of which also have templates).

For example you would add a new button and a box would pop up asking if you wanted to link to another page, or a video (so the "play film" button would link to the movie file and the "extras" button would take you to another page where the buttons are linked to the individual extras videos). Then you can customise it by dragging a picture onto the template such as the film artwork) and specify a music track to play if you want.

This would seriously get me to box up and put into deep storage most of my DVDs.
 

roidy

macrumors 65816
Dec 30, 2008
1,027
22
Nottingham, UK
No programs yet but all the info you need is here:-
http://www.apple.com/itunes/lp-and-extras/

Including sample files and I think on the mac front Subler is now able to set the xID flag that iTunes extras use.

I started writing a program to create generic iTunes extras but after using some of the iTunes purchased ones on my ATV I came to the conclusion that they suck... There really slow as if there taxing the ATV too much, so I gave up.
 

eddyg

macrumors 6502
Sep 5, 2003
331
0
Christchurch, New Zealand
No programs yet but all the info you need is here:-
http://www.apple.com/itunes/lp-and-extras/

Including sample files and I think on the mac front Subler is now able to set the xID flag that iTunes extras use.

I started writing a program to create generic iTunes extras but after using some of the iTunes purchased ones on my ATV I came to the conclusion that they suck... There really slow as if there taxing the ATV too much, so I gave up.

I came to the same conclusion when cosiderung adding support into HandBrake for automatically encoding the entire DVD and listing te items in a menu with thumbnails. The ATV just isn't fast enough to handle the xtras, it becomes too slow to clik through to watch a movie.

Cheers Ed.
 

roidy

macrumors 65816
Dec 30, 2008
1,027
22
Nottingham, UK
Agreed, the extras are just far to slow and clunky on the ATV. I'm in the process of going through the TuneKit javascript file to see how much of the crap I can remove and see if I can get them to run any faster on the ATV. Some of the ones I've purchased run better than others and after looking at the purchased ones it seems there using a different version of the TuneKit than the apple sample.
 

kiranmk2

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Oct 4, 2008
1,535
1,988
Hmm, I was really after a nice drag and drop app like iDVD as there seems to be a myriad of things to tinker with (and get wrong) with doing it manually. I'm surprised the ATV can't handle .ite files - especially basic ones consisting of simply static wallpaper. Guess I'll see what the the next version of iDVD brings...
 

zedsdead

macrumors 68040
Jun 20, 2007
3,403
1,147
Hmm, I was really after a nice drag and drop app like iDVD as there seems to be a myriad of things to tinker with (and get wrong) with doing it manually. I'm surprised the ATV can't handle .ite files - especially basic ones consisting of simply static wallpaper. Guess I'll see what the the next version of iDVD brings...

I'm sure Apple is working on this, especially for the next Final Cut Studio.
 

ssj2goha

macrumors newbie
Jan 29, 2008
11
0
I'm playing around with designing a program that will do this...
What are the "requests" people think this should have?
I'm thinking about putting it in the mac app store once I am done with it.
But I will have it on my website for sure... (new site i'm working on, not up yet...)
 

Aidoneus

macrumors 6502
Aug 3, 2009
323
82
I'd pay for an app which would rip out the main feature, and use menus and extras as .ite fomat.
 

ssj2goha

macrumors newbie
Jan 29, 2008
11
0
I won't be doing a "ripping" program purely because I want to put it on the app store and any video ripping will guarantee it being rejected by apple.

Now is it possible I will eventually make a ripping program that works with this one? maybe....

This is what I'm thinking, a program that will import videos (mkv,avi,mp4,mov) then master a DVD/iTunes extras with an interface similar to iDVD. It will create a iso you can burn to dvd.

In addition to the DVD video you can include the iTunes extras on the disc as a bonus feature. Ie. A digital copy that you get with out the iTunes store...

Thoughts?
 

Omne666

macrumors 6502a
Sep 16, 2010
503
0
Melbourne, Australia
I won't be doing a "ripping" program purely because I want to put it on the app store and any video ripping will guarantee it being rejected by apple.

Now is it possible I will eventually make a ripping program that works with this one? maybe....

This is what I'm thinking, a program that will import videos (mkv,avi,mp4,mov) then master a DVD/iTunes extras with an interface similar to iDVD. It will create a iso you can burn to dvd.

In addition to the DVD video you can include the iTunes extras on the disc as a bonus feature. Ie. A digital copy that you get with out the iTunes store...

Thoughts?

I have a mate who rips all his DVDs to iso files (i think iso), and using the atv1 with atvflash, gets exactly the DVD when he plays them...extras, commentary, whatevers on the original DVD...is this what your aiming at??
 

kiranmk2

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Oct 4, 2008
1,535
1,988
I'm playing around with designing a program that will do this...
What are the "requests" people think this should have?
I'm thinking about putting it in the mac app store once I am done with it.
But I will have it on my website for sure... (new site i'm working on, not up yet...)

I'd definitely be interested in something like this (as you might expect as I started the thread). The idea I've got in my head is for something fairly simple and foolproof:

The main working window is shaped as a 16:9 TV. You drag pictures into the window to set backgrounds. As it's unlikely most artwork will fit, there should be an option (either button or right click context menu) to allow horizontal or vertical cropping. The picture can be moved and resized as desired.
In addition, audio files can be dragged and dropped onto the window to set a background soundtrack for the menu and options to allow looping of the track or not.
Next, links (the equivalent of hyperlinks) can be added with options for setting font, size, colour etc like a standard word-processor. If these menu options are supposed to link to a video then the video file can be dragged into the "hyperlink" configuration menu. If a link leads to a submenu (e.g. extra features) then a menu pops up asking if you want to duplicate the main menu (i.e. the background art / audio) or create the submenu from scratch.

I'm not sure of how much interaction the iTunes extras menus can have with the video files (i.e. can you have a menu where you can select which audio track to select - AC3 or stereo - or turn the subtitles on and off), but this would be good to do too. A sub-page for chapter selection should be able to read the chapter names from the video file and even the still frames associated with the chapter (as seen in recent versions of Subler - if they aren't present, offer to create them). Perhaps with various templates for how the chapter selections are laid out to choose from. But these are a luxury as chapters and audio options can be selected once the video is underway (on the ATV1 at least).

As a first pass all I'd be looking for is a page with links to the main feature (which plays the main m4v file) and an "extra features" page, which contains links to each of the extra features m4v files. Both these pages should have customisable text and background art (and maybe audio). Of course, it should then out put everything as one nice iTunes/ATV-compatible .ite package file.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.