Maybe a dumb question about airplay/eyetv. I was thinking about picking one up for our imac since we took the tv out of that room-but are you guys saying that you can actually access eyetv thru your atv or iphone or ipad and control it. If so, that would be huge. I have not played with airplay much because it appears you have to have access to both devices physically to tell it to airplay (ie atv and ipad,atv and iphone etc). I would love to have access to live tv thru my atvs via eyetv without having to go and physically tell it to airplay.live tv thru my iphone woukd be cool but not really necessary, but access with my atv via eyetv-i may actually be able to get rid of some boxes also. I will read up some more-but any comments would be appreciated. Thanks, Mike.
not sure I really understand what you mean by airplaying to the ATV without having to tell it to airplay.
the setup would be the eyetv hd connected to your imac at one end, at the other, a cable box/DVR. from here, your imac can display live tv as well as recorded events from the eyetv library as well as control the cable box.
now, on your idevise, you can install the eyetv app, and from there can stream live tv and recorded content to the device via wifi (I have not set mine up for over the internet as I dont think it can support that well enough). now with the update to airplay for the eyetv app, you can send whatever is going to your idevice to your apple tv2 via airplay by just clicking on the airplay icon.
essentially, you could get away with only one cable box in your home and essentially as many apple tv's as you have tv's for (im using 4 ATV2's, and 2 ATV1's). the only downside to this is you can only record one show at a time, and stream live tv from one channel at a time. if thats not an issue, then its probably the best thing in my opinion since the HD DVR!
also, if you throw airvideo into the mix, you can then airplay other formats to your apple tv without having to convert them to the itunes format. I have been watching some mkv's that I have saved off without any issues.
I think the key will be the wifi speed of your home network, I have the 802.11N extreme dual band and all of my apple tv2's are on the 5ghz band as well as my ipad's.