MKV can be Lossless, but 99.99% of MKVs on the internet are not lossless.
MKV can be, but does not mean a file is lossless.
Kinda like aac can be lossy or Apple Lossless
Please don't confuse the newbies with a declarative statement such as MKV=Lossless.
It causes more redundant threads requesting clarification.
So much information
Ok, so I use the Lossless option in iTunes, for obvious reasons.
I'm encoding my DVD rips on my Mac Pro using the
m4v (MP4) H.264 codec at VRF and Constant Quality around 17. Audio was the tricky part. Much research got me to this:
Track 1) AAC Stereo ~192-256 kbps (depending on film)
Track 2) AC3 (5.1) for full surround sound on my entertainment system
XBMC allows me to choose which audio track on my ATV 2 (hooked up via SMB through ethernet to a "Time Capsule" in my media center to use the HDD as a media storage device, works well, no need to stream from any system).
I
place the stereo track first as iDevices default to the first track. This info about AAC being "lossless" doesn't ring true for m4v's as AC3 Passthru should be as close to lossless audio (this is technically a 2-channel digital signal that is processed as 5.1 in your AVR). OS X QTX can play AC3 audio now with the new Perian 1.2.2 codec.
Additional tracks such as "Director's Commentaries," etc. are placed in audio tracks 3+
Are the above audio settings the best for maintaining near DVD source quality (DVD's being compressed I'd like to lessen the lossy with any unnecessary compression)?
High quality encodes are crucial for digitizing my DVD collection, keeping the quality as close to original as possible but allowing playback on a multitude of devices (most of mine are jailbroken).
I'm assuming AC3 is a better codec than AAC, and Passthru is a better option for AC3 (5.1) tracks (although I have noticed AC3 (5.1) 6-Channel discrete at 640 does sound better) with DTS being the best
Advanced Video settings are below . Spent four months researching, speaking with experts, etc. It may be overkill but size isn't as important as quality (it's the "motion of the ocean" theory - sorry, couldn't resist
):
b-adapt=2:rc-lookahead=50:me=umh:ref=10:bframes=8:subq=10:merange=30:trellis=2:analyse=all
sy-rd=0.4,0.20:deblock=-1,-1
Subtitles (not burned it) and chapters if I have the csv (otherwise you MetaX for tagging).
Haven't started BD encodes, but these settings have given great quality m4v's that play perfectly on my Pioneer Elite VSX-33 and 50" Pioneer Kuru Elite. As ATV 2 accepts 1080P (outputs 720P to TV) I'm planning on using m4v's at the highest HD settings as they'll play on the current ATV 2 fine and will allow for future 1080P support.
From what I've learned mkv and m4v files are just containers, mostly for mp4 (h.264) video files. MKV can hold more, and the mp4 can me extracted/muxed if need be. MKV files cannot be tagged via MetaX, etc. but the container can hold subtitles/chapter info/etc. with some work while m4v's can me tagged using Subler/MetaX/iDentify, etc.
I do not believe that mkv files are any different or better than m4v's, they both hold the same video mp4, it's the settings/quality of the encode that is crucial. If I'm wrong, let me know
. I honestly don't know why mkv files are sometimes preferred as they aren't always supported and require more steps with little difference in overall quality. Any info contrary to that so I know for certain? Thanks!
In the end, there are a TON of options, and as I learned I wish there was a simple "one encode fits all" close to lossless lossy DVD's lol. It takes trial and error, encode a few of the same movies, play them, compare, get friends/family to compare them, and do not forget to save the settings in Handbrake (and use the nightly builds) for each encode you try in case you find the one you need.
Thanks for the help and I hope my $.02 helps someone (trying to pay it forward for all the help you guys gave me)
Oh and important: Select "Anamorphic" = Loose with Modulus=16 Detelecine and Decomb to Default/On. (Done in "Picture Settings"). Need this for compatibility on differing screens (WS, 16:9, 1:53, etc.) without losing picture quality.