2012 College Football Thread

IgnatiusTheKing said:

Johnny Football
Passing: 30/36, 311 yards
Rushing: 29 carries, 129 yards, 2 TD (not including a TD run incorrectly ruled a fumble)

Ags roll 38-13

Click to expand...

That game was pathetic. The lack of effort was staggering. I knew our d-line was weak, but that was sad. The defense also couldn't cover basic, fundamental tackling. There were guys out of position, DBs playing 5 yards off the receiver, and zero effort all around. I have been watching MSU football for 20+ years, and the last time I saw effort that poor was the 2008 game vs. Ole Miss, when the team had basically quit on Croom. Defensive coordinator Chris Wilson should have been fired immediately following that game. And for the first time in 4 years, I'm questioning Mullen.

You shouldn't be questioning Wilson and Mullen. This offense does it to almost everyone. Unless you've got players like Florida, LSU and Bama do, you've got little chance of slowing it down. Hell, even LSU gave up over 400 yards to us, we just made too many mistakes to beat them.

I remember in the early 2000s when OU and Texas Tech first started running it, they put up sick numbers on pretty much everyone in the Big 12 and opened a ton of eyes. Leach never had a (run/pass) QB like Johnny Football, either.

Can't believe we beat Tech today - especially in Lubbock. Glad to see the Horns still have some life in them.

This Pitt/Notre Dame game is a good one. It'd be nice to not have to listen to Notre Dame in the title conversation anymore. EDIT: Notre Dame scores and gets the 2 point conversion. All tied up!

Nice win for UGA. Really thought Ole Miss would play them tough…and looked that way for a half. Better team took control in the second half, though.

eric/ said:

Alabama big over LSU (like 17 point spread)

K State over Oklahoma State by a trillion points

Oregon big over USC (21+)

Georgia 14 points over Ole Miss

Oklahoma over Iowa State barely (3 points or less)

A&M over Mississipi State

Texas over Texas Tech

Click to expand...

Was wrong about a couple of my scores, but 7/7.

I'm flipping back and forth between the Oregon and Alabama game. Wow, talk about two completely different experiences.

Not at all impressed with Oregon's defense, but damn, they sure can score when they want to.

Can they REALLY not come up with something a little better than "Johnny Football"?

LSU showing a lot of fight. Okie State trying to mount a comeback on K-Stare.

gsugolfer said:

Can they REALLY not come up with something a little better than "Johnny Football"?

Click to expand...

Its an old school nickname he's had since high school. He grew up in a small town in the middle of nowhere west of San Antonio.

So probably not, but I like it anyway despite its hokiness.

----------

And LSU has the lead.

What a heartbreaking loss for LSU. Great finish by Alabama!

the Nick Saban league, I mean NCAA football is getting increasingly boring

Boring?!?

dmr727 said:

What a heartbreaking loss for LSU. Great finish by Alabama!

Click to expand...

Crazy ending. I didn't think they were gonna pull it out. Texas A&M won't be easy, either. But the LSU game should keep the Tide from being overconfident.

Roller said:

Crazy ending. I didn't think they were gonna pull it out. Texas A&M won't be easy, either. But the LSU game should keep the Tide from being overconfident.

Click to expand...

Way better than last years game that's for sure!

I didn't understand LSU's DEF game plan on that last drive. McCarron wasn't struggling because he was having a bad day, it was due to LSU was playing excellent press coverage and being aggressive so it was baffling to see them play loose/prevent defense. Being ranked 5th in the nation, I don't know why LSU decided to play cautiously at the end. There was nothing really to lose. You want to make up for the embarrassing BCS game so they should've remained aggressive.

As for 'Bama, this had to humbling experience but also shows them playing a complete game from start to end regardless of stats or situation.

IgnatiusTheKing said:

You shouldn't be questioning Wilson and Mullen. This offense does it to almost everyone. Unless you've got players like Florida, LSU and Bama do, you've got little chance of slowing it down. Hell, even LSU gave up over 400 yards to us, we just made too many mistakes to beat them.

I remember in the early 2000s when OU and Texas Tech first started running it, they put up sick numbers on pretty much everyone in the Big 12 and opened a ton of eyes. Leach never had a (run/pass) QB like Johnny Football, either.

Click to expand...

It's been a problem all year. Wilson like running a "bend but don't break" defense, and I hate it. Receivers constantly have a huge cushion, and the defensive line has been useless all year. The line has single digit sacks between all of them. It's a shame, too, since the secondary is pretty good, but the best secondary is wasted if you can't get any pressure on opposing QBs. Troy and Tennessee put up huge numbers, and we got saved because they shot themselves in the foot.

iLog.Genius said:

Way better than last years game that's for sure!

I didn't understand LSU's DEF game plan on that last drive. McCarron wasn't struggling because he was having a bad day, it was due to LSU was playing excellent press coverage and being aggressive so it was baffling to see them play loose/prevent defense. Being ranked 5th in the nation, I don't know why LSU decided to play cautiously at the end. There was nothing really to lose. You want to make up for the embarrassing BCS game so they should've remained aggressive.

As for 'Bama, this had to humbling experience but also shows them playing a complete game from start to end regardless of stats or situation.

Click to expand...

I was at the game last November - when Alabama looked like they were going to lose again last night, the same feeling came over me. Until the final drive, that is. But some of LSU's play calls were just odd. As Miles said at halftime, he should have kept some of them under his hat. I do have to hand it to LSU, though - they took the game right to Bama and almost came away with it.

I soooooo wanted ND to lose
Pitt lost the game, ND didn't win it
Not sure ND will be the Trojans

Dawgs looked good in the second half
Auburn is a rivalry game for us, regardless of the records

Bama looked mortal, and they better come to play next week with the Aggies

Roller said:

I was at the game last November - when Alabama looked like they were going to lose again last night, the same feeling came over me. Until the final drive, that is. But some of LSU's play calls were just odd. As Miles said at halftime, he should have kept some of them under his hat. I do have to hand it to LSU, though - they took the game right to Bama and almost came away with it.

Click to expand...

That fake field goal was ridiculous. Also, that early offensive pass interference call against Bama was 100% wrong.

iLog.Genius said:

I didn't understand LSU's DEF game plan on that last drive. McCarron wasn't struggling because he was having a bad day, it was due to LSU was playing excellent press coverage and being aggressive so it was baffling to see them play loose/prevent defense. Being ranked 5th in the nation, I don't know why LSU decided to play cautiously at the end. There was nothing really to lose. You want to make up for the embarrassing BCS game so they should've remained aggressive.

As for 'Bama, this had to humbling experience but also shows them playing a complete game from start to end regardless of stats or situation.

Click to expand...

McCarron was struggling because the 3 pass then punt routine wasn't getting there, especially when almost every single running play netted Bama at least 4-5 yards. That game goes much differently, and much less close, had we kept the ball on the ground more. IIRC, he was also flirting with finally getting round to throwing a pick for most of the night.

On a side note, LSU (u mad breaux?) has now lost 4 times in Death Valley at night. All 4 losses were to UA.

There was also that pass interference call against LSU, which wasn't pass interference at all

----------

My AP Top 10:

1. Alabama
2. Oregon
3. K State
4. ND
5. Georgia
6. Ohio State
7. Florida
8. Clemson
9. Florida State
10. LSU/Louisville

steve2112 said:

It's been a problem all year. Wilson like running a "bend but don't break" defense, and I hate it. Receivers constantly have a huge cushion, and the defensive line has been useless all year. The line has single digit sacks between all of them. It's a shame, too, since the secondary is pretty good, but the best secondary is wasted if you can't get any pressure on opposing QBs. Troy and Tennessee put up huge numbers, and we got saved because they shot themselves in the foot.

Click to expand...

Obviously what Miss St did, didn't work, but getting pressure on Manziel isn't always the thing to do, oddly enough. Florida shut him down by not rushing him in the second half, because they wanted to make sure he didn't beat them with his feet. Not 100% sure that will work now, given his comfort level in the offense and the coaches' confidence in the passing game, but it certainly worked in Game 1. LSU mixed it up, but they also didn't need to bring extra guys to generate a pass rush because their DEs are so good.

Bottom line, Mullen is probably the best coach at MSU outside of Sherrill, and while he hasn't gotten you guys over the hump, yet, I think it would be an awful mistake to get rid of him.

eric/ said:

There was also that pass interference call against LSU, which wasn't pass interference at all

----------

My AP Top 10:

1. Alabama
2. Oregon
3. K State
4. ND
5. Georgia
6. Ohio State
7. Florida
8. Clemson
9. Florida State
10. LSU/Louisville

Click to expand...

Looks pretty good. I'd put K-State above Oregon and LSU above Clemson, FSU and Louisville, but otherwise I'd agree.

IgnatiusTheKing said:

Looks pretty good. I'd put K-State above Oregon and LSU above Clemson, FSU and Louisville, but otherwise I'd agree.

Click to expand...

Also, to clarify I'm making a prediction. As for who would actually beat each other that would probably be a bit different. Clemson and Louisville wouldn't be near the top 10

1. Alabama
2. K State
3. Oregon
4. Georgia
5. ND
6. Florida
7. Clemson
8. Florida St.
9. Louisville
10. LSU

*Ohio State not in because of their probation

eric/ said:

There was also that pass interference call against LSU, which wasn't pass interference at all

----------

My AP Top 10:

1. Alabama
2. Oregon
3. K State
4. ND
5. Georgia
6. Ohio State
7. Florida
8. Clemson
9. Florida State
10. LSU/Louisville

Click to expand...

I was close:

1 Alabama
2 Oregon
3 Kansas State
4 Notre Dame
5 Ohio State
5 Georgia
7 Florida
8 Florida State
9 LSU
10 Clemson

eric/ said:

I was close

Click to expand...

Yep, good call. New BCS rankings are out...

1. Alabama
2. Kansas State
3. Oregon
4. Notre Dame
5. Georgia
6. Florida
7. LSU
8. South Carolina
9. Louisville
10. Florida State
11. Oregon State
12. Oklahoma
13. Clemson
14. Stanford
15. Texas A&M
16. Nebraska
17. Texas
18. UCLA
19. USC
20. Louisiana Tech
21. Mississippi State
22. Texas Tech
23. Rutgers
24. Northwestern
25. Toledo

Roll tide.....hell of a game!

IgnatiusTheKing said:

Yep, good call. New BCS rankings are out...

1. Alabama
2. Kansas State
3. Oregon
4. Notre Dame
5. Georgia
6. Florida
7. LSU
8. South Carolina
9. Louisville
10. Florida State
11. Oregon State
12. Oklahoma
13. Clemson
14. Stanford
15. Texas A&M
16. Nebraska
17. Texas
18. UCLA
19. USC
20. Louisiana Tech
21. Mississippi State
22. Texas Tech
23. Rutgers
24. Northwestern
25. Toledo

Click to expand...

Good grief, how are we even still ranked after the last two weeks? Well, that should be fixed after the LSU game.