Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

hiptobesquare

macrumors regular
Apr 20, 2003
177
8
Iowa
Sooooo....

You get a dock that only works with an iPhone, not an iPad, due to the audio jack location...

And a car charger that is single-purpose use..

Why would anyone buy either of these? Maybe the dock if they really MUST have it, and only have an iPhone 5 to consider.

A dock with just the Lightning connector would be fine, and perhaps if you need analog audio output from the dock, have a D/A converter in the dock. Maybe even a high quality one.

And a car 12V DC to 5V DC USB adapter, or even TWO USB ports, works so much more modularly than having twice as many cables due to single-use ends. like having a 12-volt power plug fixed to the end of the cable.

So many small electronics with Lithium Polymer batteries are charging directly from 5V DC USB ports, that it just makes sense to keep it modular.
 

BiggAW

macrumors 68030
Jun 19, 2010
2,563
176
Connecticut
$30 for a car charger?

That is insane.

Exactly. One reason I got a Scosche charger with dual-USB. It can charge the iPhone 4S just as well as an iPhone 5 or an SGS III or Nexus 4, or iPad or Kindle...

----------

How hard is it to spell Lightning? Seriously?? Light. Ning.

This has got to be the most misspelled word on MR right now, ever since the iP5 launch.

If they are all from the US, UK, Australia, Canada, South Africa, any other part of the former British Empire, or any other English-speaking countries, then they clearly are idiots. However, not everyone on here is from English speaking countries, and thus our bizarre and confusing language might trip them up. Just sayin'.
 

whyamihere

macrumors 6502a
Jun 30, 2008
623
1,262
'nati
1st impression from the headline: awesome, finally some new lightening accessories.

final impression after reading the whole post and seeing 1) a $30 car charger and 2) a dock that doesn't come with a lightening cable or adapter: we still have no reasonable lightening accessories.
 

faroZ06

macrumors 68040
Apr 3, 2009
3,387
1
Uhhh nope. I think it's best to buy cheap docks from Chinese eBay sellers instead of overpriced and bad-quality Belkin docks.

----------

What's the point of dedicated car chargers? I mean seriously, I'm sure everyone already has a car charger with a USB port. Just use the USB>Lightning cable.

Exactly.
 

croooow

macrumors 65816
Jul 16, 2004
1,044
206
nope these things are proven to degrade battery life

the usb ported ones.

I think its something to do with the wattage not being delivered into the cable efficiently. thats why you always buy specific car chargers, not the usb plug in ones

You went from "these things are proven" to "I think it's something..." I have never had an issue with my iPhone/iPod batteries. Never noticed reduced life. Do you have any actual proof or a link of from anyone?!?!
 

duncanapple

macrumors 6502
Jun 12, 2008
472
12
Great to see a 3rd party Lightning cord but I will just stick with my USB car charger adapter.
Image
I purchased an extra USB/Lightning cord from Apple but I would also like to be able to charge other devices.

Exactly. That was the first thing I noticed about that belkin/lightning charger. I have the older one by them that originally came with a 30 pin cord but that cord came out of the 12V plug via a USB end. So #1 it gave me another spare cord that could be used inside too and, #2 it allowed me to buy "just" a $19 usb/lightning cord from apple on iphone5 launch day and have a car charger immediately vs a month later.

I don't understand why its attached other than it will fray and break, causing people to buy a whole new charger sooner. Plus I am sure it saves them a whole 10 cents in manufacturing :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:

macs4nw

macrumors 601
how is the dock a "lightening accessory" its a lump of metal with a hole. You have to provide your own Lightening to USB cable to make it work. that is a gip.

The lightning cable should have come with it, I agree. It does look like a very solid dock though, and I noticed on the BELKIN website that the headphone jack swings out of the way, so I wonder if this dock is solid enough to also charge iPad4 and/or iPad Mini?

Great to see a 3rd party Lightning cord but I will just stick with my USB car charger adapter. Image I purchased an extra USB/Lightning cord from Apple but I would also like to be able to charge other devices.

For maximum versatility, this seems like the way to go.
 

doctor-don

macrumors 68000
Dec 26, 2008
1,604
336
Georgia USA
how is the dock a "lightening accessory" its a lump of metal with a hole. You have to provide your own Lightening to USB cable to make it work.

that is a gip.

It is NOT a "lightening accessory" since it does not lighten anything, only makes it heavier and darker (if you bought the white iPad). :p

----------

Exactly. One reason I got a Scosche charger with dual-USB. It can charge the iPhone 4S just as well as an iPhone 5 or an SGS III or Nexus 4, or iPad or Kindle...

----------



If they are all from the US, UK, Australia, Canada, South Africa, any other part of the former British Empire, or any other English-speaking countries, then they clearly are idiots. However, not everyone on here is from English speaking countries, and thus our bizarre and confusing language might trip them up. Just sayin'.

How difficult is it to LOOK at the article - even the title has the word. Copy. Past. Simple. :)
 

albusseverus

macrumors 6502a
Nov 28, 2007
744
154
I got a really great iPhone 5 case from Belkin, only a few days after the 5 shipped.

And that's all I have to say on this subject.
 

brucku

macrumors regular
Jun 19, 2003
193
20
this dock is a dud

one of the coolest parts about having both ports on the bottom is that a dock can come out that allows "full docking" for external accessories... guess what - this dock clearly has a 2-ring 3.5mm wire. This means that headsets like the apple headphones or a Pop-dock receiver will not be able to answer or hang up calls....

It could have been perfect.... what a shame.
 

haruhiko

macrumors 604
Sep 29, 2009
6,529
5,874
What's the point of dedicated car chargers? I mean seriously, I'm sure everyone already has a car charger with a USB port. Just use the USB>Lightning cable.

I have been using Griffin's car charger with USB port (it came with a 30 pin cable). After I bought the iPhone 5 I just purchase one more lightning to USB cable to plug into the USB port.
 

Orange Furball

macrumors 65816
May 18, 2012
1,325
6
Scranton, PA, USA
The reason the cable is permanently attached is so they don't intrude on Apples Lightning territory. If they did a USB to Lightning + a USB car charger dongle they would be taking away Apple's shares of Lightning sales.

Instead of going through Apple for every cable, you would be buying one from Belkin and getting the features of a car charger too. If they just sold the USB to car adapter no one would buy it. I may be wrong, but it may be Apple's fault. Too bad.

The dock is just stupid though.
 

croooow

macrumors 65816
Jul 16, 2004
1,044
206
The reason the cable is permanently attached is so they don't intrude on Apples Lightning territory. If they did a USB to Lightning + a USB car charger dongle they would be taking away Apple's shares of Lightning sales.

Instead of going through Apple for every cable, you would be buying one from Belkin and getting the features of a car charger too. If they just sold the USB to car adapter no one would buy it. I may be wrong, but it may be Apple's fault. Too bad.

The dock is just stupid though.

Good point, I would have to guess it is Apple's idea. Belkin does sell car chargers for 30 Pin Apple devices that have separate USB->30 Pin cables. I have one. I have quite a few non-Apple USB->30 Pin cables and have NEVER purchased one from Apple (other than the ones that come with Apple devices, of course) It would make sense that Apple has changed the rules for 3rd party accessory makers.

I guess once we see other chargers we will have a better idea. Perhaps the only 3rd party USB->Lightning cables we will see are unauthorized ones.
 

viewfly

macrumors 65816
May 1, 2009
1,263
24
I haven't purchased a hard wired car charger in a few years.

Better to buy a car charger with female USB port that you can plug any device into, just using your current connector or a $19 extra one from Apple.
 

jrbdmb

macrumors 6502
May 19, 2008
454
49
USA
All of the above.

Nobody wants to go back to days where the cable was permanently attached to the charger.

The real question is this: How on God's Green Earth does Belkin not implicitly understand this?
Well then you already have a solution - any of the USB car chargers with an extra Lightning cable. But a few people *do* want the cord attached - one less thing to lose in their car.

I like my Scoche dual-USB with an extra Lightning cord, but my wife only charges her iPhone 5 and wants a one-piece solution. It's good to have the choice.
 
Last edited:

Gurubarry

macrumors newbie
Oct 25, 2010
26
0
"Nobody wants to go back to days where the cable was permanently attached to the charger."
Apple does...and it will all be obsolete in 3 years .....like thunderbolt and my 2 iMacs ...... :D
 

nightjar99

macrumors newbie
Aug 9, 2010
1
0
The dock is a big disappointment

The dock is a BIG disappointment.

I ordered one direct from Belkin when first mentioned here.

It came yesterday.

Very well made.. solid, attractive..

BUT, BUT BUT !!!!!!

The function is CRAP!

When you snake your own Lightning cable thru the bottom... all seems good.

UNTIL YOU TRY TO LIFT YOUR PHONE OUT OF THE DOCK!

Then the cable pulls up with the phone thru it's channel instead of releasing form the phone.

There is no "one-handed" removal of your phone from this dock.

You have to constantly "re-snug" the cable back into it's channel.

HUGE, IRRITATING FAIL.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.