+1. Wouldn't want to go back to my 4s since having the 5. The 4s is definitely not the peak.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Do you think that the iPhone 4S is the peak of Apple's phone designs
- Thread starter SunnyRenegade33
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
+1. Wouldn't want to go back to my 4s since having the 5. The 4s is definitely not the peak.
The 5 is what made me jump ship from android, which were my previous three phones, the last being the galaxy s3. I have friends that had the iPhone since its very first iteration and it never did anything for me.
As far as design goes the iPhone 5 arguably better. The tolerances are lower, the fit and finish are better and the fact that the back is mostly made of metal makes it more durable in the long run. It might scratch easier than glass but drop the iPhone 4 once on its back and it's game over. The taller screen allows for full screen use in 16:9 videos, the now standard resolution for video media. It's quite necessary, inevitable even.
I honestly never understood why a company would make the back of a phone out of glass, one of the most brittle hard materials known to man. It may look nice but it shatters way too easily.
At the end of the day, it mostly comes down to personal preference though but it's hard to argue that glass is more durable than aluminium for long term durability. Personally I don't even know why apple bothered to make the top and bottom pieces out of glass for the iPhone 5, a nice glass like polymer would have made it even more durable and this better in my opinion.
Screen integrated touch sensors are another advantage to the iPhone 5 as there is no discernible gap between the screen and the top glass itself, improving both readability and viewing angle. It also looks a lot better in my opinion.
The fact that the i5 is also thinner and lighter is another advantage as it makes the device easier to handle on one hand and most of all takes up less real estate in your pocket, making it more comfortable if you wear clothes that actually fit lol
Analysts predict that apple will once again sell more iphone 5's than 4s so the general consensus amongst consumers must be that the 5 has a better design and form factor. Every iteration is smaller, lighter and thinner than the previous one and there's a reason for that.
As far as design goes the iPhone 5 arguably better. The tolerances are lower, the fit and finish are better and the fact that the back is mostly made of metal makes it more durable in the long run. It might scratch easier than glass but drop the iPhone 4 once on its back and it's game over. The taller screen allows for full screen use in 16:9 videos, the now standard resolution for video media. It's quite necessary, inevitable even.
I honestly never understood why a company would make the back of a phone out of glass, one of the most brittle hard materials known to man. It may look nice but it shatters way too easily.
At the end of the day, it mostly comes down to personal preference though but it's hard to argue that glass is more durable than aluminium for long term durability. Personally I don't even know why apple bothered to make the top and bottom pieces out of glass for the iPhone 5, a nice glass like polymer would have made it even more durable and this better in my opinion.
Screen integrated touch sensors are another advantage to the iPhone 5 as there is no discernible gap between the screen and the top glass itself, improving both readability and viewing angle. It also looks a lot better in my opinion.
The fact that the i5 is also thinner and lighter is another advantage as it makes the device easier to handle on one hand and most of all takes up less real estate in your pocket, making it more comfortable if you wear clothes that actually fit lol
Analysts predict that apple will once again sell more iphone 5's than 4s so the general consensus amongst consumers must be that the 5 has a better design and form factor. Every iteration is smaller, lighter and thinner than the previous one and there's a reason for that.
To be honest I liked the original iPhone best. If they could squeeze all the iPhone 5 guts into that enclosure I think that would be ideal. That would be the peak. I pulled my original iPhone out of its box a few days ago and it just felt "perfect" in my hand.
I believe your absolutely correct.
The 4 / 4S design is Apples Finest.
Based on my experience owning iPhone 5, I find the "half measure" change in display size, where only the vertical dimension was made slightly longer, creates an odd off balance phone.
As many have reported, it offers little if any advantage, plus it's a stretch to call it an "upgrade".
The soft, easily marred finish is certainly not up to Apples past quality standard, plus the new thinner body feels cheap & a bit flimsy.
Clinging to the mantra that it's easily used "one handed" is a distinctively Apple esq "advantage" that only the most ardent Apple devotee subscribes to.
Out in public, I & others use Androids without a second thought about a few millimeters of difference. Those here who claim Androids are "truck sized, or "massive" or whatever they choose to label them so as to be degrading, may be math challenged, or simply grasping at straws.
After ample time with the intent of enjoying my iPhone 5, it was just too boring, too uninteresting, and lacking in too many areas to be worth using. So the decision was made to take it offline & shelve it. A very good move.
Returning to my excellent, fast fun & ever so reliable iPhone 4S with iOS 5 & the stellar Google Maps, reminded me of just how great that model is.
It's absolutely the best of all iPhones to date.
An early adopter, I've preordered every model of iPhone since the original. Thankfully I did not sell my 4S before giving the 5 a good long test.
Moral of the story? Once again experience reminds me that newer is not always better.
Yes on paper, but it doesn't work that way in practice, unfortunately. Factory workers rushed to meet the heightened demand and many arrived with slightly off fit and finish in addition to nicked and scratched out of the box. While mine didn't have a nick or scratch, it came with glue stuck between the gap where the glass and aluminum meet on the back. They're said to be more difficult to assemble and the factory allowed many slightly-off iP5 to slip past QC, essentially throwing the lower tolerances out of the window.
Yes, it has the better design overall, but poorer build quality thanks to the stupid factory workers and/or their supervisors.
Ah
The 5 doesn't photograph well - you only realize how modern it looks when you actually hold it in your hand.
Kind of like some girls I know (I kid, I kid!)..
The 5 doesn't photograph well - you only realize how modern it looks when you actually hold it in your hand.
Kind of like some girls I know (I kid, I kid!)..
Great smartphone pico projectors are about 5 years out.Maybe something like the discovery of a technology that could project digital projections from your phone or something
For anyone that wants to know what that means for society, watch the TED talk on "sixth sense computing". We're in for some really exciting things.
Nope. I'm not sure how anyone can proclaim the Apple has peaked without knowing how much longer Apple will be around or what they'll do in the future. It seems to make about as much sense as stating that everything to be invented has already been invented.
Of course others do. I don't understand why people think that no one could possibly share an opinion when you're talking about millions and millions of people.
You should try reading the responses in this thread. If you think everyone thinks Apple's latest is always the best then you just aren't paying attention and you're seeing what you want to see. Posts #28 and #29 are even on the same page as yours (at least for me they show up on the same page).
Wow, how incredibly wrong you are. Obviously you've never seen, held or actually 'used' the iPhone 5. Lol.
Amen! As an owner of each iteration of iPhone, you're correct! I'm also a casual Android 'enjoyer', and I've got a pair of original Notes in the house as well as the Galaxy SIII. The only correction I'd make to your statement is that the iPhone 5 is not only the best iPhone to date--it's the best mobile phone. Period
Lol. You never, ever cease to amaze me...and for the life of me, I can't figure out why you don't 'leave us' and find yourself an Android forum to rejoice and extend your praise for better ideas, platforms, offerings and functionality. I don't believe for a second that you've owned every iPhone and Android device you've proclaimed. Nor do I believe you just 'shelve' a creation like the iPhone 5. If you don't understand or 'feel' the incredible performance increase in the '5' over it's 4/4s brethren, you're not nearly the tech 'guru' you've tried to paint yourself as.
It's not flimsy, it's definitely not nearly as damage prone as the 4/4s, it's lighter, it's got the best, most accurate colors to date...the screen is absolutely incredible. The horsepower increase alone is noticeable immediately. The lightning connector is awesome, LTE is beyond fast...and the unibody construction bests ANYTHING available with Android's OS. Shoddy plastic construction sucks and is my biggest complaint about my Droid gear. As a 'true' fan of both OSes...I find your constant posting against every Apple product to be an absolute, utter Joke! Whether you're bagging on your newly purchased, just returned rMBP, dissing the iPad 4 update, or chastising the iPhone 5... It seems to me your full of it. You don't actually own these products. Never have. You're an armchair quarterback spewing negative info you've read online somewhere
Real, true users of the iPhone 5 know the truth. Obviously...as far as aesthetic design is concerned...opinion is subjective. However, you take OP's posts about thirty six steps to far, every time.
Seriously, isn't there another forum you could frequent instead of MR? Or is there a real need in your mind to try to make others that are less experienced question there purchases, look for goofy, non usage affecting flaws...or utter BS that's actually false?
Sorry...but you really, truly annoy me. And you tend to pop up in every 'new' product query...as you own EVERY device Apple has ever released...only to put them on the shelf cause they're no good. I'd think you'd learn. Or stick with a 2009 MBP, because that's the iconic design and pinnacle of performance.
Rant. Over.
Happy Turkey Day everyone! I'm taking my iPad mini that ixodes has proclaimed a 'pile o' crap' down to the kitchen. Excellent honey glaze recipe found for my ham
J
While I adore iPhone 5¨s design I must say I like the back of the iphone 4/4S. the glass just makes it feel.. Premium?
I dont know .. I love the 4/4S design but the screen size is hard to live without.
I dont know .. I love the 4/4S design but the screen size is hard to live without.
Rant. Over.
Happy Turkey Day everyone! I'm taking my iPad mini that ixodes has proclaimed a 'pile o' crap' down to the kitchen. Excellent honey glaze recipe found for my ham
J
LMAO
Happy Thanksgiving bro.
Whatever you said times 1000 from me.
That's why I put that particular user on my ignore list a long time ago.
You hit it spot on.
I think the 4/4S design is the base design of where Apple wants to go with their phones and the 5 is a tweak and improvement on that design foundation.
I have to say, I don't really like the 5's design or dimensions at all, and think it feels cheap in the hand.
I've owned every model of iPhone but am skipping the 5 and keeping my 4S
If Apple stay true to form and release a 5S with the same layout / case next year, I'll probably keep hold of my 4s even longer!
I've owned every model of iPhone but am skipping the 5 and keeping my 4S
If Apple stay true to form and release a 5S with the same layout / case next year, I'll probably keep hold of my 4s even longer!
I've had the 4 for 2 years and it's very nice in its own right. It's instantly recognizable with the silver band sandwiched between two layers. However, the 5 is very nicely designed (if you get one with no gaps and scratches) and looks much better in person. I was extremely skeptical about the design and about renewing my 3 year contract, but on just walked to a store one day, played with one for a few minutes, and called my carrier the same day. When I first saw the iPhone 5, especially the black one, it reminded me of some alien technology
You think the iP5 feels cheap in the hand but the plasticky 3G/3GS doesn't? How funny.
Of course the 5 is the best, the headphone jack is on the bottom!
I love the look of the 4 and will really miss its long term durability vs. the black anodized aluminum. But I'm very happy with my 5 and wouldn't trade back.
I love the look of the 4 and will really miss its long term durability vs. the black anodized aluminum. But I'm very happy with my 5 and wouldn't trade back.
In terms of design - not performance. Does anyone else feel like the iPhone 4S will be the
peak of Apple, Inc.'s phones aesthetically speaking? I have no doubt that Apple will continue to release better performing products - but as far as design goes, I think iPhone 4S is the peak.
I'm not a huge fan of the iPhone 5's design. I feel that it's actually a little bit too thin (never thought I'd be complaining about that) and I think it's awkwardly tall. I also dislike the the back of the iPhone 5 in terms of it's color.
Even if Apple released a transparent glass phone, I still would prefer the iPhone 4's design to it. The only thing that would prompt me to upgrade my phone at this point would be a SIGNIFICANT technological upgrade (something more than a tiny bit faster, or a tiny bit more resolute). Maybe something like the discovery of a technology that could project digital projections from your phone or something
What do you guys think? Has Apple reached it's peak in terms of design when it comes to phones with the 4S? Or do you prefer the new design of the 5, and think that Apple's future products will trump what we're familiar with today?
There won't be anything to top the 4 version. Gorilla glass on both sides made it look sharper than any other phone out there. 5 has dings and scratches on the back and the black is wearing off the sides. 5 should have kept the glass front and back and it should have been wider. The Samsung Galaxy 3 feels like a plastic toy. I like a heavy phone in my hands. Do you think 6 will be better? Don't hold your breath. 5 was supposed to be the super phone....cough cough. Keep dreaming.
Exactly. They looked at the band that goes around the 4/4s and realized that you can take the same design, thin it out a bit, and make the edge cut more noticeable.
Take that formula and make a single body with a back rather than sandwiching two pieces of glass, and you have iPhone 5.
The engineering of the tech inside, however, is a whole different beast.
Hate to tell you... but... Liquid Metal usually looks more like pewter or a satin finish. See the LM golf club below:
Since it's a metal alloy with plastic characteristics, a more accurate name would've been "Plastic Metal", but that doesn't have the same sexy Terminator feeling.