That's already how trademarks work. You have to register them in a class where it's appropriate for your product and someone in a different class can use the word.
You did read the nice summary which explains all of this ?
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Apple Acquired 'Lightning' Trademark from Harley-Davidson
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
That's already how trademarks work. You have to register them in a class where it's appropriate for your product and someone in a different class can use the word.
You did read the nice summary which explains all of this ?
Wait, aren't ALL chaps assless by definition? Otherwise they'd be crotchless pants.
Hahaha, yeah, strangely enough, the topic comes up often here with the wife, who points out assless is what _makes_ them chaps.
+1
Could you explain your reasoning behind this? Or possibly could anyone who marked this up explain your reasoning? What do you think is wrong with buying the right to use a trademark from a company that owns it?
Because a port has nothing to do with bikes, and you'd think that that would be enough product distinction.
The whole point of patenting things is to prevent competitors from mooching off your hard work. That isn't really possible when the two products are in no way similar. Even the way they style "Lightning" is dramatically different. I don't see why they needed permission.
What's not clear (to me) - did Apple negotiate for the trademark before Lightning was announced/released, or did they just announce it and waited to see who (if anyone) would sue?
No problem, they'll buy the whole station, rename it or change the legal set up and then sell it.
I'm sure the regulators would allow that.
And do you really think Apple would spend around $10 billion just so they get hold of a name?
Yep. Apple's changed their charge/sync connector *once* in the past 9+ years. Compared to the various one-phone-only connectors, different size & polarity barrel plugs, USB mini & USB micro, that's *so* darned often!
And the 'everpriced' (I assume you meant overpriced) apple stuff that costs the same as any other name-brand equivalent, and still has the cheap-as-dirt off-brand versions available for the same low-end prices as the generic USB-mini/micro cables.
It's almost like you *want* to complain about something, so you'll just make stuff up to pretend you have some sort of justification.
"King of connectors," huh? There's certainly enough variants to make an empire out of them, indeed.
Seriously though, from an engineering standpoint, USB is pretty big mess. You can tell when even in 2005, Intel (you know, the guys who basically wrote the spec) had bugs with their USB2 controllers.
And that is why Apple didn't license the trademark in regards to motorcycles.
----------
See above...
DING, DING, DING! We have a winner. The Buell X1 Lightning. Harley owned Buell Motorcycles From 1998 to 2009 when it shut the company down.
----------
And here's the Buell Thunderbolt.
I think you forget we're talking about HD here and not Ducati.
I thought HD no longer owned Buell. I was under the impression they finally dropped the line and Eric was on his own now.
Those are hideous abomination variants of the respective motorcycles you pictured above.much prefer the stock look on Buell's
Lightning
Thunderbolt
Last edited:
And apple care warranty will probably last only a year or two, and the bike will cost almost double the price if a non apple one
Yes, Buell shut it's doors in 2009. Eric is doing racing only bikes at this time and yeah, i could have picked better pics.
Sounds like they'll be great competition to Harley-Davidson then.
(I owned 2 harleys before buying my current BMW).