iPad mini Finally got to see mini in person

vastoholic · Nov 30, 2012

I was at the Apple store yesterday looking at the MBA and I almost completely forgot about the new iPad mini's. I had to see if all the hype/complaining was true.

First thing.......holy crap it's light!!

After that first initial shock wore off and staring in amazement at the form factor, I focused on the screen. I didn't spend a whole lot of time looking at them so I didn't pay attention to what the brightness setting was, but my first thought was, it definitely doesn't pop out at you like the 3rd and 4th gen iPad does. As far as the resolution is concerned, it wasn't that bad to me at least. Yeah I could make out the pixels when looking at a normal distance, but only just barely past the point of being noticeable for me. It didn't distract me from enjoying using it and looking through the apps and playing the videos on it.

I still don't know if I'll ever get one as I recently sold my 3rd gen iPad because it wasn't getting as much as use as it use to and it's not really as good at the tasks I was asking for it at school. Hence, why I was looking at the air. However, I had Zinio on my iPad and I loved it. I still have active subscriptions (that I can view on my computer as well), but just wondering if anyone uses the mini as a magazine reader and how they like it compared to the full size. I loved my magazines on the full size, but the mini seems so convenient and easy to handle like it's built for reading material. I didn't happen to see if they had any on it.

MonkeySee.... · Nov 30, 2012

I think the more people who see it and not pin all their opinions on blogs etc realise its actually pretty good and there has been a massive over reaction.

DaveOP · Nov 30, 2012

I think for Magazine reading, you will not be as happy as you were on your full size iPad. Simple fact is, things won't look as crisp and clean, and you'll be reading smaller text in general. Stick with the MBA, if you were not happy enough with your bigger iPad for this task, you will not be happier with a mini.

danish1542 · Nov 30, 2012

DaveOP said:
I think for Magazine reading, you will not be as happy as you were on your full size iPad. Simple fact is, things won't look as crisp and clean, and you'll be reading smaller text in general. Stick with the MBA, if you were not happy enough with your bigger iPad for this task, you will not be happier with a mini.

Agreed. I have both right now and I read magazines a lot. Holding the mini is nice but you have to use both hands when trying to turn a page or read something on the screen because the bezel is so small. Also the magazines that have been upgraded to retina quality look noticeably better on my iPad 3. Text is much clearer, photos are similar.

vastoholic · Nov 30, 2012

DaveOP said:
I think for Magazine reading, you will not be as happy as you were on your full size iPad. Simple fact is, things won't look as crisp and clean, and you'll be reading smaller text in general. Stick with the MBA, if you were not happy enough with your bigger iPad for this task, you will not be happier with a mini.

danish1542 said:
Agreed. I have both right now and I read magazines a lot. Holding the mini is nice but you have to use both hands when trying to turn a page or read something on the screen because the bezel is so small. Also the magazines that have been upgraded to retina quality look noticeably better on my iPad 3. Text is much clearer, photos are similar.

Thank you both for that. Perhaps I'll wait until the inevitable retina version comes out and see how it looks. I guess I feel dumb for having all of these iPad apps, many that were not free, and now I have nothing to use them on.

poloponies · Nov 30, 2012

DaveOP said:
I think for Magazine reading, you will not be as happy as you were on your full size iPad. Simple fact is, things won't look as crisp and clean, and you'll be reading smaller text in general. Stick with the MBA, if you were not happy enough with your bigger iPad for this task, you will not be happier with a mini.

The comparative analysis isn't really the way to look at it. Sure, just like with audio speakers if you do a side-by-side comparison, the higher-end speaker will easily sound better, but once you take home a lower-end it's not like you're going to be sorely disappointed. On its own merits the mini is fine for most people.

Awakener · Nov 30, 2012

vastoholic said:
I was at the Apple store yesterday looking at the MBA and I almost completely forgot about the new iPad mini's. I had to see if all the hype/complaining was true.

First thing.......holy crap it's light!! After that first initial shock wore off and staring in amazement at the form factor, I focused on the screen. I didn't spend a whole lot of time looking at them so I didn't pay attention to what the brightness setting was, but my first thought was, it definitely doesn't pop out at you like the 3rd and 4th gen iPad does. As far as the resolution is concerned, it wasn't that bad to me at least. Yeah I could make out the pixels when looking at a normal distance, but only just barely past the post of being noticeable for me. It didn't distract me enjoying using it and looking through the apps and playing the videos on it.

This cannot be said enough. A store is a terrible place to judge any display. The Mini looks okay in the store, but ugly at home. It is difficult to understand if have no experience comparing displays. Environment makes a huge difference. It's why so many people return products with displays after seeing them in the home.

maverick22 · Nov 30, 2012

Awakener said:
This cannot be said enough. A store is a terrible place to judge any display. The Mini looks okay in the store, but ugly at home. It is difficult to understand if have no experience comparing displays. Environment makes a huge difference. It's why so many people return products with displays after seeing them in the home.

Someone please explain why the mini would look okay in the story but ugly at home. Lighting? I'm confused

I don't really have experience comparing displays by the way.

Don't they say TVs are better at home than in store (HD TVs actually running HDMI and not red/blue cables, better home equipment/sources)?

vastoholic · Nov 30, 2012

Awakener said:
This cannot be said enough. A store is a terrible place to judge any display. The Mini looks okay in the store, but ugly at home. It is difficult to understand if have no experience comparing displays. Environment makes a huge difference. It's why so many people return products with displays after seeing them in the home.

Not in my experience. Every time I have looked at an item in the Apple Store before purchasing, it actually looks better once I get home because I spend more time with it and looking at it. Don't assume everyone has the same experience or judgement as you. I have never been displeased with the quality of a screen after looking at one in store, and then bringing it home.

maverick22 · Nov 30, 2012

vastoholic said:
Not in my experience. Every time I have looked at an item in the Apple Store before purchasing, it actually looks better once I get home because I spend more time with it and looking at it. Don't assume everyone has the same experience or judgement as you. I have never been displeased with the quality of a screen after looking at one in store, and then bringing it home.

Thank you. This makes more sense in my opinion. Once again though, I don't have much "experience in display comparison."

davideotape · Nov 30, 2012

DaveOP said:
I think for Magazine reading, you will not be as happy as you were on your full size iPad. Simple fact is, things won't look as crisp and clean, and you'll be reading smaller text in general. Stick with the MBA, if you were not happy enough with your bigger iPad for this task, you will not be happier with a mini.

personally I like magazine reading better on the mini. it's much lighter, i can hold it with one hand and for magazines like the New Yorker that scrolls down, i can read an entire article just by swiping my thumb. plus the size and weight just gives the device more of a "magazine" feel if that makes any sense at all.

and while yes text is crisper on the ipad, I can still read quite clearly and if you're distracted by pixel resolution while you're reading, you're not reading right.

photos in the magazines look fine too. some of them i was even surprised by how good they looked. for comics and magazines, if I have both devices right next to each other I'll grab the mini.

rockyroad55 · Nov 30, 2012

MonkeySee.... said:
I think the more people who see it and not pin all their opinions on blogs etc realise its actually pretty good and there has been a massive over reaction.

Yup, it doesn't take long to go into a store to look at one unless you live in a place that doesn't have any stores nearby.

Trat · Nov 30, 2012

maverick22 said:
Someone please explain why the mini would look okay in the story but ugly at home. Lighting? I'm confused I don't really have experience comparing displays by the way.

Don't they say TVs are better at home than in store (HD TVs actually running HDMI and not red/blue cables, better home equipment/sources)?

You're confused because its ********. It will look the same at home as in the store. Some people just have vivid imagination and want to project that onto others.

maverick22 · Nov 30, 2012

Trat said:
You're confused because its ********. It will look the same at home as in the store. Some people just have vivid imagination and want to project that onto others.

I'm confused about what. I know what others have said. I didn't say myself that I think one looks better than the other at home vs. the store. I know what people have told me. When I was shopping for TVs I was told at Fry's AND Conn's that the TV would look a little better at home.

Trat · Nov 30, 2012

maverick22 said:
I'm confused about what. I know what others have said. I didn't say myself that I think one looks better than the other at home vs. the store. I know what people have told me. When I was shopping for TVs I was told at Fry's AND Conn's that the TV would look a little better at home.

How much is 'a little' 1? 2? Half times? If you believe it looks better, you will see it looks better. 101 retail business school rule. The whole audio fools habitat is founded on that principle.

maverick22 · Nov 30, 2012

Trat said:
How much is 'a little' 1? 2? Half times? If you believe it looks better, you will see it looks better. 101 retail business school rule. The whole audio fools habitat is founded on that principle.

Oh, like I said in my reply though, I didn't believe them. That's simply what I was told. Heck, I couldn't remember what it looked like in the store anyways to make a decent comparison haha. I just wanted the user who said it looks "ok in the store but ugly at home" to elaborate some more. I just don't see how it could look different at home if it looked good at Best Buy (fingerprints covering the screen, not so great lighting).

Bokes · Nov 30, 2012

I also use the iPads for reading comics,magazines and books.
I have the mini with the holiday extended return (Jan-3 I think)- so I'm giving it a test while holding on to my iPad 3.

I totally dig the feather weight of the mini, but then- I don't find the ipad 3 all that heavy or cumbersome when using at home.

When out and about- cafe, subway, bar- The mini has been great,
but whenever I'm home- I have a hard time not reaching for the iPad 3 vs the mini.
For comics and magazines- it's no contest.
It's not just the higher resolution- it's also a better size to read magazines and comics on a slightly larger screen. Text and graphics pop and far less zooming.

I had hoped to sell the iPad 3.
I'm not sure if I will return the mini. It's so easy to handle out and about.
I may have to bite the bullet and keep both.
Ipad 3 for home and leave the mini in my bag for on the run.

Apple planned it this way- right?

Awakener · Nov 30, 2012

maverick22 said:
Someone please explain why the mini would look okay in the story but ugly at home. Lighting? I'm confused I don't really have experience comparing displays by the way.

Just do an Internet search. It's common knowledge everywhere but this forum it seems.

maverick22 · Nov 30, 2012

Awakener said:
Just do an Internet search. It's common knowledge everywhere but this forum it seems.

No biggie. I've been satisifed with most of my purchases so far anyways. If I don't like it when I get home I'll return it. Thank you though.

kodeman53 · Nov 30, 2012

Awakener said:
Just do an Internet search. It's common knowledge everywhere but this forum it seems.

I did a search. Seems Apple has special 'Apple light bulbs' installed in every Apple store AND at every Apple display in all other stores. These 'Apple light bulbs' make non-Retina screens look like Retina and Retina screens look like Super Retina screens.

WilliamG · Nov 30, 2012

MonkeySee.... said:
I think the more people who see it and not pin all their opinions on blogs etc realise its actually pretty good and there has been a massive over reaction.

I think that may be true for some people. But not for me. I was pretty open-minded about the iPad mini. It really is a premium tablet. But that resolution just pains me. PAINS me. It's 100% a deal killer - the ONLY reason I don't own one right now.

That said, when I reviewed the original iPad 1st generation, I was not happy with 1024x768, either. My opinion has not changed.

uniforms · Nov 30, 2012

Well, I LOVE my mini!!!!!!! It is the perfect companion with my 13" MBP Retina. I have the 3rd generation iPad retina, but I just love the weight of this mini. I do miss the retina and will buy a mini with retina as soon as it comes out. But for now, I love how light this is and I can carry it everywhere. The performance is fine. Apple really did an great job with it. That's why you can't find them anywhere.

knucklehead · Nov 30, 2012

Awakener said:
Just do an Internet search. It's common knowledge everywhere but this forum it seems.

Here's the result of the internet search you recommended:

https://www.google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en&q=why+the+mini+would+look+okay+in+the+story+but+ugly+at+home.+Lighting%3F&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8#hl=en&sugexp=les%3B&gs_nf=3&gs_rn=0&gs_ri=serp&gs_mss=why%20the%20mini%20would%20look%20okay%20in%20the%20story%20but%20ugly%20at%20home.%20L&pq=why%20the%20mini%20would%20look%20okay%20in%20the%20story%20but%20ugly%20at%20home.%20lighting%3F&cp=58&gs_id=z&xhr=t&q=why+the+mini+would+look+okay+in+the+story+but+ugly+at+home&pf=p&client=safari&tbo=d&rls=en&sclient=psy-ab&oq=why+the+mini+would+look+okay+in+the+story+but+ugly+at+home&gs_l=&pbx=1&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.&fp=5fd9d6b9f90edb74&bpcl=39314241&biw=2560&bih=1378&bs=1

Do you actually have anything useful you to add ... or would you like to just like to try and and maintain the illusion that you do .... ???

Edit: Awakener = wast of internet space.

I'm open to being proven wrong

give it a shot AW ....

MisterDisney · Nov 30, 2012

The mini is my absolute favorite piece of technology. I do about 90% of every day browsing, email, and reading on it. And I probably watch as much TV on it, as I do at my actual television.

vastoholic · Nov 30, 2012

knucklehead said:
Here's the result of the internet search you recommended:

https://www.google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en&q=why+the+mini+would+look+okay+in+the+story+but+ugly+at+home.+Lighting%3F&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8#hl=en&sugexp=les%3B&gs_nf=3&gs_rn=0&gs_ri=serp&gs_mss=why%20the%20mini%20would%20look%20okay%20in%20the%20story%20but%20ugly%20at%20home.%20L&pq=why%20the%20mini%20would%20look%20okay%20in%20the%20story%20but%20ugly%20at%20home.%20lighting%3F&cp=58&gs_id=z&xhr=t&q=why+the+mini+would+look+okay+in+the+story+but+ugly+at+home&pf=p&client=safari&tbo=d&rls=en&sclient=psy-ab&oq=why+the+mini+would+look+okay+in+the+story+but+ugly+at+home&gs_l=&pbx=1&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.&fp=5fd9d6b9f90edb74&bpcl=39314241&biw=2560&bih=1378&bs=1

Do you actually have anything useful you to add ... or would you like to just like to try and and maintain the illusion that you do .... ???

Edit: Awakener = wast of internet space.

I'm open to being proven wrong

give it a shot AW ....

http://www.life123.com/technology/h...to-know-before-you-buy-a-flat-screen-tv.shtml

This is the only thing of relevance I found after searching for "do screens look better in the store". It also mentions that you achieve the in store results by changing your settings at home.

iPad mini Finally got to see mini in person

macrumors 68000

macrumors 68040

macrumors 68000

macrumors member

macrumors 68000

Suspended

macrumors 6502

macrumors 6502a

macrumors 68000

macrumors 6502a

macrumors 6502a

macrumors 601

macrumors regular

macrumors 6502a

macrumors regular

macrumors 6502a

macrumors 6502

macrumors 6502

macrumors 6502a

macrumors 65816

macrumors G3

macrumors regular

macrumors 6502a

macrumors 6502a

macrumors 68000

Our Staff