Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Tim Cook: I've Given Up Physical Keyboards, Use iPad "80% of the Time"
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
You can just get a mechanical keyboard or even the IBM Model M. I'm sure there are still loads lying around out there.
Where did he say he was going to take away your keyboard?
Where did he say he got rid of his keyboard?
Fail, indeed.
I don't think this is really about virtual keyboards vs physical keyboards, or relative typing speeds.
What is really interesting to me is that mobile devices are changing the way we work and get things done. In the past, people took meeting notes with pencile and paper. If they wanted to refer to a document, they would print hard copy to take to meetings. Email, calendaring and contacts were completely handled by desktops and laptops. Internet searches for reference materials required a full sized computer. Outlines and rough drafts of proposals were handwritten or typed on desktops. But now, folks can do all of this stuff and more on their mobile devices...so, a higher percentage of workers productive time is spent using devices with virtual keyboards.
This doesn't mean computers with physical keyboards are no longer needed, it just means that folks are doing more of their routine tasks with other devices, so when it is time to do the heavy lifting on a full computer, most of the back office and preparatory work were completed whilst mobile.
For Cook, this percentage split is 80/20. For others, it might be 50/50....and so on. But nobody can deny that an ever increasing percentage of routine work is being done on mobile devices using virtual keyboards.
What is really interesting to me is that mobile devices are changing the way we work and get things done. In the past, people took meeting notes with pencile and paper. If they wanted to refer to a document, they would print hard copy to take to meetings. Email, calendaring and contacts were completely handled by desktops and laptops. Internet searches for reference materials required a full sized computer. Outlines and rough drafts of proposals were handwritten or typed on desktops. But now, folks can do all of this stuff and more on their mobile devices...so, a higher percentage of workers productive time is spent using devices with virtual keyboards.
This doesn't mean computers with physical keyboards are no longer needed, it just means that folks are doing more of their routine tasks with other devices, so when it is time to do the heavy lifting on a full computer, most of the back office and preparatory work were completed whilst mobile.
For Cook, this percentage split is 80/20. For others, it might be 50/50....and so on. But nobody can deny that an ever increasing percentage of routine work is being done on mobile devices using virtual keyboards.
Touch typing for secretaries came about because they would do data entry from paper based documents into a typewritter/computer. So you're not looking at the screen or the typewriter's piece of paper, you're looking at your source. Since I also Touch type, I can look at someone and talk to them while typing out an e-mail or whatever because I neither need to look at my screen or the keyboard to know what I'm typing and if I make mistakes, I know without seeing it from the way I felt myself stumble in my finger movement.
You can't really expect the younger generation to know this or have any use for this though as these days, text entry is done through copy/pasting or scanning, not direct typing and people don't look at each other anymore, they talk via SMS or Facebook.
This is obviously because you don't write hahahaha often, so autocorrect hasn't learnt ur writing patterns, it adapts to how you write.. choosing a random word isn't a fair test.
I think people are not using autocorrect correctly. It makes typing so easy.
I try my best to TRUST autocorrect and I can type like a BEAST on my iPhone and iPad.
Don't you mean BAEST?
I have done nearly that. It is slower sure, but not as bad as people make it out to be. I use a Das Keyboard on the desktop and I love mechanical keyboards. I prefer using a real keyboard. However, I am not always in a situation where that is feasible. I suspect most people find the virtual keyboard fine for their every day use. I have typed 1000 word messages on my iPhone and 10,000 word papers on the iPad. Neither is ideal, but it is certainly doable.
I type the longer document when something came up while I was on vacation. I will toss a bluetooth keyboard in my bag next time (just in case), but I would not say it was frustrating.
Most business users appreciate and need the tactile feedback of a physical keyboard... virtual keyboards are not ready for business use yet.
Here's the problem with autocorrect: Even if it's correct 75% of the time (which I believe is optimistic), it takes too much time to correct the remaining 25% on the iPad/iPhone. Furthermore, everyone I know (including myself) make many more typos on the touch keyboard. God forbid you have to use the magnifying glass to change/add/remove a couple of characters. If you don't use laser-guided precision then half the time it'll change position when you release your finger, and for some reason Apple has declared jihad on the arrow keys so you're forced to fiddle with the magnifying glass again and again. There's a reason why entire websites exist just for the comedic value of the iOS autocorrect feature.
Honestly, I get such a kick out of people who argue that things like this are somehow more efficient. The lack of an accessible file system is another great example. No, we shouldn't need dozens of apps just to manage different file types and print a freekin photo.
Honestly, I get such a kick out of people who argue that things like this are somehow more efficient. The lack of an accessible file system is another great example. No, we shouldn't need dozens of apps just to manage different file types and print a freekin photo.
People could learn to use a stenotype for word processing if they really want to. That says more about the proficiency of the human brain than it says about what the best tool for the job is.
Tap typing = regular typing minus tactile feedback. I take away one of your senses, how is that better? Apple also owns a patent for tactile feedback on a touchscreen - that either means they're patent hoarding or are aware of the virtual keyboard's deficiencies
But I'll concede. If people want to tap type for the rest of their life, who am I to stop them
I'm not that young. Implying that I am does make you sound old, though.
I know what touch typing is, and I even do it myself. I just don't know why, in this day and age, you are transposing documents from paper to computer (the only real use case I can think of where touch typing without at least glancing at the screen makes sense). When I'm typing on my iPad, I'm doing e-mail, chat, a bit of word processing, and web form filling. Don't really need to spend tons of time while I'm typing looking at other things. Sure, physical keyboards are great and a lot faster in general, but I don't think it's impossible to do serious typing on an iPad, because I do it regularly.
You mistook what I meant (look at screen != look at on-screen keyboard).
Sounds vaguely reminiscent of the BlackBerry fanboys who thought Android and iOS were not serious enough or "ready for business". We know how that one turned out.
Last edited:
LOL... I hope you didn't damage your rectum when you pulled out that "over 90% of the population" BS
Cook makes what, over $300 million per year? And the work year is about 2,000 hours? So he's effectively compensated at something in the neighborhood of $150,000/hour. Wow, imagine how much money goes down the drain due to his insistence on using an inefficient tool. Probably in the tens of millions over the course of a year. Get over it and use an Air!
To me, whatever Tim cook says does not matter too much. When Job said something, it would seem like that's where the trend is going from bottom of the heart. When Tim says it, because he wants to sell the ipad... I don't know.. this guy.. Look what's happening in china.. Apple is getting killed.. do something dude.
lol... I hope you didn't damage your rectum when you pulled out that "over 90% of the population" bs
Speaking of rectums, almost **** myself at work reading this
I think people are not using autocorrect correctly. It makes typing so easy.
I try my best to TRUST autocorrect and I can type like a BEAST on my iPhone and iPad.
I agree here. I think part of the problem is auto correct isn't going to be good at first for you because it learns how you type. If you try it a small bit and decide it sux and turn it off, it will always suck. You have to let it get used to how you type. It amazes me now how good my autocorrect is at figuring out what I was trying to type when I type something like dpmtj (and then it predicts something <- I was trying to simulate the bad typing I do sometimes as right now I'm on my computer with a real keyboard).
Still, I agree with others that as some one who can touch type I still can type far better on the keyboard than on the ipad or iphone and I'd rather write anything long with a keyboard. One nice thing about the screen keyboard of the ipad/iphone is that I'm wordy and it encourages me to find shorter ways of saying things or not over elaborating like I tend to do.
Thats interesting because I've given up Lion and Mountain Lion and use Snow Leopard 100% of the time.
Can someone source at what time in the interview Tim Cook actually says, "I've Given Up Physical Keyboards"? Because I don't remember hearing him say that.
No it's not. But, when submitting a 500 word post the typical response tends to be tl;dr, "I didn't read all that but," "Nice wall of text", etc. Maybe this is where the world is headed. I can imagine a future where professors ask students to summarize lessons in 140 characters or less. Sad, isn't it?
