Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Google Maps for iOS Downloaded More than 10 Million Times
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Try leaving the country and see how great it is. No. really. Try.
you also have to understand that its difficult for Apple to map out on its first try city streets that were carved out by donkey and mule trains.
There is one thing that Apple maps is terrible at and that is finding the place I am looking for. The best routing doesn't help one little bit if the destination is never found or wrong. To give you an example of how bad the search algorithms are, when I search for my home address abbreviating the Road to Rd., the search fails. Of course I can correct that spelling myself, but often enough I get an Address dictated over the phone and don't necessarily know the correct spelling, Google almost always finds me the place I am looking for in no time, whereas with Apple maps I needed multiple tries to find places I sort of already knew.
And honestly, I don't care if it is hard to develop a map app. I don't care that Google has had a 10 years head start. I am not an Apple guinea pig and I am not a beta tester. I am a customer who paid a premium price for my iDevice and I want it to work now, not in a couple of years when Apple fixed their problems (and they don't seem to be to eager to do that at the moment).
T
----------
you also have to understand that its difficult for Apple to map out on its first try city streets that were carved out by donkey and mule trains.
You have to understand that sarcasm conveys really badly over the internet, even with the smilie face. And it is not even funny given the current state of the US infrastructure, but that is besides the point.
What? It isn't that bad around here. I haven't seen anything remotely resembling a mule train in, like, weeks.
...since they got hijacked by all those highwaymen. WELCOME TO OBAMA'S AMERICA, PEOPLE!
I suppose I should have put a smiley face or something, but those always feel so obvious...
Please, take this as an interesting diversion, not a serious argument, because this is really meaningless, but measurably less meaningless than "Google Rocks Apple Sucks!".
Yes, he was making up numbers. I just found it entertaining that he couldn't make up a set that was self consistent.
Different samples of the same population have the same underlying probabilities, but different sample statistics. In this case the underlying probability is unknown. He has one sample statistic. Since we're judging by success or failure alone, it's basically a binomial distribution. Maximum likelihood (as in, "there are likely") estimator for the probability of success in a binomial distribution is the sample mean-- in this case 1 in 5, not 1 in 51.
There's maybe a 15% chance (I can't find a t table with enough resolution), given that sample of 5 trials, that the true success rate is 1 in 51 or worse, but there's really no support for that particular point estimate in the empirical data.
I know pedantry and you, sir, are no pedant.
Now if there were a way to make google maps the default mapping software......because when I use my Geocaching app to locate caches, it uses Apple's maps....which does not allow me to zoom in as tight as I could under iOS 5, which used to use google.
Yeah we had a working maps app, but it was lacking features, yes to some people it was inferior in some ways, but it is superior in others, and again in my area it was not inferior in any way. its all a matter of opinion.
Im not sure why you call it unnecessary to add new features, fact is if Apple didnt make their own maps app in order to add turn by turn, people would be giving Apple flak about that. Why should Apple have waited even longer, when the sooner they released their own maps the sooner they can perfect it?
----------
the fact that he has never developed an app has nothing to do with his comment. And I doubt 8 years ago he would have called google maps a failure, but that does not mean it was a success either. His point was that 10 million downloads of a free app does not indicate success. In fact many failures are given away for free because they are a failure. does that suddenly make them a success?
----------
Some may say that 10 million downloads in 2 days is impressive, I never argued that. But it does not make a free app a success. If that were the case it would be far too easy for an app developer to make something a success through marketing. I could easily write an app that does absolutely nothing, and use social media hype and marketing to get more than 10 million people to download it less time.
Yes, and it would be a success in marketing. Success is not a measure of quality or anything other that popularity really.
After all this I still use the default maps app over Google. The truth is Apple's app is more useful to me. Google has a more advanced mapping system, but their app has a problem with looking up places. iOS Maps keeps every search entry saved in the way that bookmarks work. Looking places up while on the road is difficult with Google. Not being biased, I think Android is an excellent platform. I just never had much of a problem with Apple's app.
I honestly don't understand why people spend so much energy defending Google maps. I have an Android phone running 2.3.7 gingerbread and I've never had a good experience with maps. It doesn't crash or anything but it always brings back spaghetti results. I remember on one occasion it asked me to drive around the block just for the hell of it!!!
If you want decent navigation from your smartphone then invest in one of the paid apps out there like Garmin, Navigon or Destinator. I got Navigon Europe and I'm never looking back.
If you want decent navigation from your smartphone then invest in one of the paid apps out there like Garmin, Navigon or Destinator. I got Navigon Europe and I'm never looking back.
Last edited by a moderator:
I've used google maps all over croatia and tuscany. They were excellent. That being said - it was interesting that when cross comparing Garmin to Google Maps to whatever was in our rental car in the dash (I forget now) - only about 80 percent of the time were they in "sync" (meaning - giving the same driving directions/exits to use). Ultimately they were all correct.
Last edited by a moderator:
They all have problems for me. You guys need to relax. I have:
Garmin
TomTom
Apple
Google
paper maps from local companies
other meaningless map apps
They all have occasional issues. Even the local mappers that only handle my city. Heck, even the maps I can pick up at city or county offices can be behind. Just the other day I had to go to a street, it's been there a few years, not on Google maps. Didn't really slow me down, found it no problem. Didn't even open another map.
I will say that I am impressed with the new Google app's turn by turn. What it says and how it says it is more useful than TT or Garmin.
Garmin
TomTom
Apple
paper maps from local companies
other meaningless map apps
They all have occasional issues. Even the local mappers that only handle my city. Heck, even the maps I can pick up at city or county offices can be behind. Just the other day I had to go to a street, it's been there a few years, not on Google maps. Didn't really slow me down, found it no problem. Didn't even open another map.
I will say that I am impressed with the new Google app's turn by turn. What it says and how it says it is more useful than TT or Garmin.
I'm still wondering how in the world is 10 million downloads not a success.
If Apple isn't on top it doesn't count to some of you people.
If Apple isn't on top it doesn't count to some of you people.
Same here!
In Australia, Apple Maps still misplaces some towns and my own country is a barren wasteland.
