Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

isephmusic

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Oct 31, 2012
416
0
are you kidding me ? in google play you pay 99 cents its NINTY-NINE cents not a dollar+.06, what does that even accomplish. so if you pay a 25$ app like the big cloud/ office apps will it charge you that extra 7% tax ? thats kind of rediculous who does it go to and why does android not require it but iOS does ?
 

Menel

Suspended
Aug 4, 2011
6,351
1,356
are you kidding me ? in google play you pay 99 cents its NINTY-NINE cents not a dollar+.06, what does that even accomplish. so if you pay a 25$ app like the big cloud/ office apps will it charge you that extra 7% tax ? thats kind of rediculous who does it go to and why does android not require it but iOS does ?
That's how sales tax works. Always has. From toilet paper at the general store to gadgets online. State regulation. Talk to your representative.

No tax on my iOS apps.
Where are you located?
 

Brian Y

macrumors 68040
Oct 21, 2012
3,776
1,064
are you kidding me ? in google play you pay 99 cents its NINTY-NINE cents not a dollar+.06, what does that even accomplish. so if you pay a 25$ app like the big cloud/ office apps will it charge you that extra 7% tax ? thats kind of rediculous who does it go to and why does android not require it but iOS does ?

Depends where the transaction takes place. If you buy a 10p sweet - 1p of it will be tax - all purchases are taxed, regardless of size (unless it's considered an essential/exempt item - and I don't think an "app" is classed as an essential)
 

Michael CM1

macrumors 603
Feb 4, 2008
5,681
276
Did the OP just wake up inside some Internet bubble and never buy anything from an actual store? Are we really asking what sales taxes are for? Really?
 

isephmusic

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Oct 31, 2012
416
0
i know what tax is for im asking WHY is the app store is taxed and not the android one. why the difference ? just curious

haha im not used to paying tax because

Amazon
 

araje

macrumors regular
Apr 15, 2012
121
0
So which states have sales tax in iTunes or App Store ? Is it the case that some states don't have this tax component?

I heard CA residents will now have tax on amazon purchases starting 2013 but not sure if its really true.
 

duneriderltr450

macrumors 6502
Sep 20, 2012
365
2
Oregon
are you kidding me ? in google play you pay 99 cents its NINTY-NINE cents not a dollar+.06, what does that even accomplish. so if you pay a 25$ app like the big cloud/ office apps will it charge you that extra 7% tax ? thats kind of rediculous who does it go to and why does android not require it but iOS does ?

I don't pay tax. :D
 

jazzbo

macrumors member
Oct 11, 2008
45
5
Bangor, ME
i know what tax is for im asking WHY is the app store is taxed and not the android one. why the difference ? just curious

haha im not used to paying tax because

Amazon

Generally catalog (on-line, phone or by mail) retailers are required to collect sales tax if they have a physical presence in the same state as the purchaser, based on your billing address usually. Otherwise you get into issues of taxing interstate commerce which can be dicey, and why there is occasionally a move in Congress to tax internet sales.

Is there an Apple Store in your state? You'll get taxed in the app stores or other online purchases from Apple.

Does Google have offices in your state? If not, they probably won't collect tax.

Amazon has generally been trying to dodge collecting taxes but my understanding is they generally will in states where they have offices or warehouses.

btw, even if the retailer isn't collecting sales tax, law in your state may mean that you should be declaring a use tax as part of your tax return each year.
 
Last edited:

Rocko1

macrumors 68020
Nov 3, 2011
2,070
4
So which states have sales tax in iTunes or App Store ? Is it the case that some states don't have this tax component?

I heard CA residents will now have tax on amazon purchases starting 2013 but not sure if its really true.

Yes, it's true and it started late this year. Items purchased in CA while living in CA will have CA tax. Amazon has where-houses in CA.
 

Baggio

macrumors 6502
Oct 18, 2012
442
1
i know what tax is for im asking WHY is the app store is taxed and not the android one. why the difference ? just curious

haha im not used to paying tax because

Amazon

By law, even though Amazon doesn't charge you tax in your state, you are still supposed to file and pay that tax directly to your state. That being said, not many people do it.
 

isephmusic

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Oct 31, 2012
416
0
when taxes are due early next year where would i even put it ? i buy A LOT from amazon because of the free shipping and no tax. would i add it all up ? or is it individual. sorry im a young guy.

but back to the main point. does anyone in any state pay tax on google apps ? i really dont think so and im not sure why the app store in the iOS would charge tax on an app
 

saberahul

macrumors 68040
Nov 6, 2008
3,645
111
USA
That's how sales tax works. Always has. From toilet paper at the general store to gadgets online. State regulation. Talk to your representative.

No tax on my iOS apps.
Where are you located?

From the math, I assume NJ - 7% sales tax. Though many other states could have it but I only know of NJ.
 

strider42

macrumors 65816
Feb 1, 2002
1,461
7
when taxes are due early next year where would i even put it ? i buy A LOT from amazon because of the free shipping and no tax. would i add it all up ? or is it individual. sorry im a young guy.

but back to the main point. does anyone in any state pay tax on google apps ? i really dont think so and im not sure why the app store in the iOS would charge tax on an app

Google probably doesn't have a physical location in your state, hence no tax. That will probably change in the future, ebcause taxes on internet purchases I think are going to have to happen eventually.

And yes, your state tax return likely has a place where you total up all your receipts and enter them as a "use tax". California does anyways. no one actually pays it, but legally youa re required to. This is why california moved to force amazon to collect CA state sales tax (as have other states).
 

Blorzoga

macrumors 68030
May 21, 2010
2,560
66
when taxes are due early next year where would i even put it ? i buy A LOT from amazon because of the free shipping and no tax. would i add it all up ? or is it individual. sorry im a young guy.

but back to the main point. does anyone in any state pay tax on google apps ? i really dont think so and im not sure why the app store in the iOS would charge tax on an app

It's called Use tax. It is sales tax that you should have paid on a purchase but because the seller is not obligated to collect it (they don't have a physical presense in your state). Very few, if any, states enforce its collection from individuals. However, businesses are routinely audited. Businesses will file a sales and use tax return to report sales tax they collected as well as sales tax they were not charged (use tax).

Depending on your state, apps may or may not be subject to sales tax. In PA, they're considered canned software and are subject to tax.

Incidentally, Amazon just recently began charging sales tax to PA customers because they apparently have established distribution hubs in the state, thus establishing nexus. Sucks for me. Now I have up decide whether its worth driving to Delaware to avoid the tax.

Back to your question, though, don't bother paying the use tax to your state, they won't come after you. Apple has to charge tax on Apps because they have a physical presense in the state.
 

jazzbo

macrumors member
Oct 11, 2008
45
5
Bangor, ME
Here in Maine, the income tax form has a 'recommended calculation' of use tax where they take some small % of your net income, or you can declare an exact amount.

If you go multiple years just filling in 0 in the box, you get a 'compliance letter' from the state offering to settle for a certain amount, but I've never heard of anyone getting any type of legal response for not paying. We have ads on TV every now and then reminding people to declare their use taxes.

Subsequently, we have the highest use tax reporting rate at around 10% of tax filers: http://www.governing.com/blogs/by-the-numbers/state-use-tax-collection-revenues.html Nationally it is like 1.6% of taxpayers declare use taxes.
 

darster

Suspended
Aug 25, 2011
1,703
1
Generally catalog (on-line, phone or by mail) retailers are required to collect sales tax if they have a physical presence in the same state as the purchaser, based on your billing address usually. Otherwise you get into issues of taxing interstate commerce which can be dicey, and why there is occasionally a move in Congress to tax internet sales.

Is there an Apple Store in your state? You'll get taxed in the app stores or other online purchases from Apple.

Does Google have offices in your state? If not, they probably won't collect tax.

Amazon has generally been trying to dodge collecting taxes but my understanding is they generally will in states where they have offices or warehouses.

btw, even if the retailer isn't collecting sales tax, law in your state may mean that you should be declaring a use tax as part of your tax return each year.


Incorrect. I live in a state where Apple has no presence, but they add a sales tax on every purchase. Apple chooses to apply the state sales tax for every state that has one. Google and amazon choose not too. Honestly, I think they should. The money is used by your state to fund education, road work, snow removal and so on. I live in a state with no income tax, and the sales tax is what funds these projects.
 

Michael CM1

macrumors 603
Feb 4, 2008
5,681
276
i know what tax is for im asking WHY is the app store is taxed and not the android one. why the difference ? just curious

haha im not used to paying tax because

Amazon

Some states are starting to pass laws taxing online sales. Retailers such as Walmart are rightly pissed that they get punished for having an actual store. But laws have to get passed to do it since its still uncharted territory.

As for why the App Store is and Amazon isn't, that's strange. Must be a quirk of the local law. Maybe it has something to do with Apple having physical stores and Amazon not.
 

jazzbo

macrumors member
Oct 11, 2008
45
5
Bangor, ME
Incorrect. I live in a state where Apple has no presence, but they add a sales tax on every purchase. Apple chooses to apply the state sales tax for every state that has one. Google and amazon choose not too. Honestly, I think they should. The money is used by your state to fund education, road work, snow removal and so on. I live in a state with no income tax, and the sales tax is what funds these projects.

Are you sure Apple doesn't have a presence? Very often their educational contracts -- i.e. having a dedicated store at a university or a depot for a local school district, often will be enough to make the nexus.

Or is that some statement somewhere that says that Apple collects for every state, just because. I have heard of no retailer doing that voluntarily and I'm very surprised that Apple would. I really think it is because Apple has a bigger presence that many of us realize. Why don't they collect local taxes on top of that -- and stop at just the state level?
 

From A Buick 8

macrumors 68040
Sep 16, 2010
3,114
127
Ky Close to CinCinnati
are you kidding me ? in google play you pay 99 cents its NINTY-NINE cents not a dollar+.06, what does that even accomplish. so if you pay a 25$ app like the big cloud/ office apps will it charge you that extra 7% tax ? thats kind of rediculous who does it go to and why does android not require it but iOS does ?

what state you in op
 

thekev

macrumors 604
Aug 5, 2010
7,005
3,343
i know what tax is for im asking WHY is the app store is taxed and not the android one. why the difference ? just curious

haha im not used to paying tax because

Amazon

That's an unusual area. Online retailers still have to charge sales tax if they have a physical presence in your state. If they lack one, you're technically still liable for applicable "use tax" which is the same amount as you would have paid in sales tax. Generally in countries where sales tax is applied at a national level, the stated price is sales tax inclusive. Sometimes they still price things to the nearest .99, and when you look at your receipt you'll see how much was sales tax. The odd thing about apps is that in some cases with certain states, non-tangible items are not considered sales taxable assuming they aren't accompanied by tangibles. It's a weird mix and this varies according to the laws of your state of residence and where the seller is set up. In the end retailers aren't going to charge you sales tax unless they feel it is required, and they do not profit from it. If anything it's an added expenses accounting for it.
 

darster

Suspended
Aug 25, 2011
1,703
1
Are you sure Apple doesn't have a presence? Very often their educational contracts -- i.e. having a dedicated store at a university or a depot for a local school district, often will be enough to make the nexus.

Or is that some statement somewhere that says that Apple collects for every state, just because. I have heard of no retailer doing that voluntarily and I'm very surprised that Apple would. I really think it is because Apple has a bigger presence that many of us realize. Why don't they collect local taxes on top of that -- and stop at just the state level?

They have been collecting sales tax since I can remember. I live in South Dakota. The only presence Apple has here is best Buy. lol
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.