Samsung tests the durability of their Android phones with a mechanically weighted butt that sits on the phone. Maybe Apple should learn something from Samsung about durability.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Bent iPhone 5
- Thread starter Aaronneil
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Samsung tests the durability of their Android phones with a mechanically weighted butt that sits on the phone. Maybe Apple should learn something from Samsung about durability.
Yeah.. I never thought there was an issue about the iPhone being bent. I have all iPhone generation including the very first iPhone which is also built with aluminum materials, I always put it in front of my tight jeans' front pocket and it never bends.. I already warned my family about the issue including my friends and colleagues. And I hope all iPhone 5 soon to be owners in the whole planet.. I am dissapointed with Apple even if I'm a fan. ;(
Where is the "normal spot" that everyone else's iPhone 5 is bent?
When observing how others carry their phones, it' seems to an extremely common practice for young girls from high school age through college, to carry it in the back pocket of their pants. If the iPhone 5 is carried there I wonder how easily it bends. Anyone know?
iPhone 4 and 4S, models seemed to survive that method of carrying just fine.
S
syd430
Guest
Are you sure you were just observing to see how they carry their phones?
The scenery was a bonus
Since I had a little break from this site I decided to put together a little picture story of the bent phone claims that I could find on here that had any sort of picture or supporting evidence and wasn't just a single post from a random person inside an existing thread.
This is meant to show that the normal spot is near the volume buttons and in most cases, visible signs of stress are present indicating probable user fault. There are a few of these examples that I believe could have (and some have basically proven in this thread) that they came that way out of the box and there is usually a great visible difference in the type of bend in those instances.
(Case #1)
https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/1449978/
Friend received destroyed package from FedEx and phone came out this way. Provided no evidence of the box. Thread died and no resolve was found from the OP. Bent at the volume button. Small enough bend that yes it could have been done inside the package. But the story didn’t quite add up.
(Case #2)
https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/1493448/
Hard to tell here. OP says it was recently purchased and they just noticed it one day. Only a slight indication of stress at the volume button. Could have easily came that way in the box. Good example.
(Case #3)
https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/1502748/
No pictures anymore so I can’t provide visual of what the phone looks like. However it was obvious that it was not like that out of the box.
(Case #4)
https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/1452478/
Hard to tell from the picture what is going on, but it’s obviously around the volume button as the OP describes. Says it came that way and date of post is consistent with the story. Small enough bend that it could have came that way in the box.
Case #5)
https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/1494118/
OP claims it came out of his otterbox like this. Bent again at the volume button. Almost hard to see, but you can make out from the picture the stress point by the volume button. Would have been noticeable if it was like that out of the box.
(Case #6)
https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/1459792/
OP says it bent in his front pocket. Clear fracture/stress mark at volume button. Would have been noticeable if it came that way in the box.
(Case #7)
https://forums.macrumors.com/posts/16149417/
OP claims it magically bent overnight while he was sleeping. Obvious stress mark at the volume button. Obviously not done during production and didn’t come that way in the box.
(Case #8)
https://forums.macrumors.com/posts/16194084/
No story, just a link to twitter by the OP of the thread. Obviously didn’t come like this is box.
(Case #9)
https://forums.macrumors.com/posts/16224559/
OP claims in was in her purse and it magically bent at the volume button.
(Case #10)
https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/1509457/
OP says purchased 3 hours ago. Noticed it out of the box. Valid claim. No stress marks. Bent in the middle of the phone instead of at the volume buttons.
(Case #11)
https://forums.macrumors.com/posts/16517709/
OP was brought this as a replacement phone. Noticed and took pictures in the store. Hard to tell exactly where the bend is occurring but OP says near the volume buttons. No visible stress marks.
(Case #12)
https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/1465403/
Who can forget the amazing spontaneously separating iPhone. User acknowledged it did not come out of the box like this. Obvious stress marks near volume button.
Obiously you're not OC about gadgets or you would of noticed it was bent out of the box. Not saying you knew you did it and are lying, simply lumping you in with most of the others that say they have no clue how it happened. With no better "excuse" for the reason it must of been that way OOB.
@ above I believe the gently rounded with no stress points can be explained by but not exclusive to this explanation. A large bottome person places the phone in a rear pocket and bends/sits. The roundness of the bottom with the most likely tightness of the rear pants pocket would put even stress over the length of the device and not necessarily show a specific stress point. It would IMHO be possible to stress the phone slightly over its length to produce such a bend. I just don't see OP, being as OC as they say would not of noticed this out of the box. It's obvious by looking at the picture so would of easily been seen when checking over the phone.
Obviously the phone bends easier than most but it's a phone not an anvil. What are you people doing to abuse... yes abuse the phone in order for it to bend. Now don't give me X phone doesn't bend if I do the same exact thing..... Ok great. This phone does not bend when subjected to normal use. You know how I know.... Millions of people aren't blowing up the interwebs with stories of bent iPhones. So obviously the very very minority are doing something unusual with their phones to have them bend in such ways.
It shouldn't be discouraging as these phones are the very slim minority, not the rule. I will however agree 100% with you when it comes to the thin phone obsession.... this however is not an Apple issue it's a consumer issue. Read back on ANY iPhone/iPad/iPod unveiling thread. How many people B&M about how it's not thin enough. I thought the 4/4s was just fine.
Last edited:
After seeing these images, no matter what the cause, it's very discouraging to see. Perhaps Apple will reconsider it's ongoing obsession with thin devices.
Made a quick FEA for iPhone5 shell. Model doesn't have much details but may represent quite well the stress concentration at the edge of volume button hole. For an accurate analysis would need exact dimensions. Load case is such that shell is smoothly clamped from bottom area (up to 60 mm from bottom) and load is distributed on topsurface.
10N force (1kg, about the weight of 6 Lumia 920 bricks) results a stress of about 60MPa at the edge of volume down button opening. That is about the yield point of 6061 in non-tempered condition. It doesn't look good very good to me and I wonder why they didn't for example change the volume button to a thin rocker type to have more material at the cross section.
![]()
![]()
10N force (1kg, about the weight of 6 Lumia 920 bricks) results a stress of about 60MPa at the edge of volume down button opening. That is about the yield point of 6061 in non-tempered condition. It doesn't look good very good to me and I wonder why they didn't for example change the volume button to a thin rocker type to have more material at the cross section.
Last edited:
Modified the shell model to represent iPod, which has different design for volume buttons. There was less good pictures of inner details available, so this is even a bit more guesstimate than the iPhone shell FEA. The load case is the same. Because the openings are longer the stress spreads a little better and there is also bit more material in the cross section. The highest stress appears to be about 50MPa (compared to 60MPa for iPhone shell under same load). But it is rough model so not an accurate estimate...
![]()
What your models don't account for though, are the internals being in place. And no offense, but who are you? Why should we all believe that you've made an accurate model just because you show some pretty pictures? Where is the actual data from this test?
I again ask you both, where is the actual proof of the type of aluminum alloy being used by apple? The only thing that has been released is "anodized 6000 series". Show me where you've discovered that its non-tempered blah blah blah. So far no one has been able to do that. Everyone avoids the question.
As a profession I'm a design engineer with about 20 years of experience in design of different kinds of heavier equipment than phones. Did I give an impression that the models were accurate? Wasn't my intention...
(model and analysis was created in about 30 minutes, on 'coffee' break... and about significance of other parts to bending resistance, I thought about it and of course the display glass can be considered as structural part, but it seems ultimately to pop off. For other, electrical internal, parts I suspect that there is no significant structural role given)
The pictures of bended phones make me suspect that the aluminium is not tempered. That because there is signs of plastical deformation. In tempered (T4 or T6) condition the 6061 is quite brittle and cracks sharply.
Last edited:
Are you completely sure about that? Check this at just past 1:50...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wT8xI4PEU8c
Explains why no one cracks their glass anymore.
Also, when was it confirmed that gorilla glass is used in iPhone 5? If it is, then apple better get their money back...