Wow, really touched on some nerves here! Nowhere did I say I personally wanted iOS gutted. I voted for a slight update and widgets. Sheesh, thin-skinned bunch. Didn't think some people would take the merest suggestion of change so personally. 
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Should Apple Gut it's iPhone OS and start over?
- Thread starter BlindMellon
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Starting over worked well for Microsoft, right? Ah, never mind. Windows Phone didn't really catch on.
Then, if you want Android-like customization and widgets and rooting abilities, there's a very simple solution that does not require Apple making a giant mistake.
Get an Android phone.
Then, if you want Android-like customization and widgets and rooting abilities, there's a very simple solution that does not require Apple making a giant mistake.
Get an Android phone.
How is it perfect? You can't save anything that's not a picture in iOS unless you have a third-party app that supports it (ex. You cannot save a Word file from an email). iOS is great but it still has a long way to go.
I think its pretty rudimentary now to be honest!
Works ok of course but everything just seems like it could be smoother and done better now.
It needs a major update and a new lease of life. However, keep the concept and simple style.
Works ok of course but everything just seems like it could be smoother and done better now.
It needs a major update and a new lease of life. However, keep the concept and simple style.
If something's not broken why get rid of it? They can introduce new features with iOS 7 that will make the iOS up to date without being stale. However, there is no need to start over. That would destroy pretty much all the Apps. You don't start over unless something is about to bankrupt like RIM.
I think you're confusing "vocal" with "most".
It just needs to evolve like most other software does. If people are bored with it then they should move on to something else.
Do people not realize that most of what's happened with iOS happened on Steve's watch? iOS didn't just get stale after Steve died. And skeuomrphism was something Steve pushed for. If Steve was pushing all this groundbreaking and innovative stuff with iOS how come we haven't seen it?
If anything they can start again with iOS 5. Don't like some changes they made in iOS 6.
In spite of that, I still have to say that I like iOS better. Sure it might be boring now or whatever, but the main thing I find is that I prefer if it works - which it does quite well.
In spite of that, I still have to say that I like iOS better. Sure it might be boring now or whatever, but the main thing I find is that I prefer if it works - which it does quite well.
No question iOS needs an overhaul. Not from the ground-up, restart no, but at least get away from "App drawer, left open look" A screen full of app icons, is outdated. And the Fisher-Price toy theme has got to go already.
To me the iPhone OS, still looks pretty much like from 2007. Time to freshen it up already. Add live tile icons or something. Like the weather app icon, should show today's current temp, it's not 73 degrees and sunny in Chicago today.
To me the iPhone OS, still looks pretty much like from 2007. Time to freshen it up already. Add live tile icons or something. Like the weather app icon, should show today's current temp, it's not 73 degrees and sunny in Chicago today.
I really enjoy some of the design elements of Android 4.2. The fonts look great, the interface is really clean in general but for some things it feels like they over-minimalized.
Take a look at this:
![7HOg3.png]()
Compare to this:
![AV8YG.png]()
The iOS version definitely could use with a visual refresh, but on first glance it looks as if you know approximately what's a button, where you can interact and generally what you should be doing.
This is just one case out of many comparisons that could be made.
Take a look at this:
Compare to this:
The iOS version definitely could use with a visual refresh, but on first glance it looks as if you know approximately what's a button, where you can interact and generally what you should be doing.
This is just one case out of many comparisons that could be made.
According to the poll, seems like 'most' people here do agree that iOS needs updating.
I didn't vote because none of the options apply to me.Updates are always welcome and even eagerly anticipated,but no,I don't see iOS as stale and NEEDING updating,whatever that means.It gets updated yearly so I'm not sitting around sad or angry that it's sooo icky.
Most people would vote for the second option without agreeing with your apparent premise that it needs to be dumped and replaced with.....what?Android?
Flawed poll
iOS as a whole is awesome! BUT.... Apple needs to make widgets, ncsettings, and more customization an option out of the box... Like include the default winter board options... Please apple... Make iOS more funner...
----------
Oh gawdddd.....
----------
Oh gawdddd.....
Point taken, should have chosen my words a bit more carefully. There will always be features that we want added. I guess what I was trying to get it is what it does do it does extremely well with a few exceptions. I like what we have we have. To put in into car terms I'd like to see a body refresh and a couple bolt-ons rather than a complete rebuild with a brand new chassis.
Make it possible to activate a "non-iTunes setting" where you're given access to the file system when connecting the phone to any computer, and a file explorer in the actual phone. That would be my one wish if I could only get one.
Another thing I'd like to do is pair my MBP and my iPhone with Bluetooth, or change that wifi-sync, so that it's more like Nokia PC Suite than iTunes.
Don't get me wrong, I love iTunes (yes, I do), but I don't want to be locked into it and I would prefer being able to save any kind of file to the phone without it having to be app specific.
Another thing I'd like to do is pair my MBP and my iPhone with Bluetooth, or change that wifi-sync, so that it's more like Nokia PC Suite than iTunes.
Don't get me wrong, I love iTunes (yes, I do), but I don't want to be locked into it and I would prefer being able to save any kind of file to the phone without it having to be app specific.
Ive has told the New York Times that he will waste no time overhauling the design of iOS to make it fit in more with his own minimalist hardware designs.
Ives iOS makeover will incorporate clean edges, flat surfaces to replace the textures that are all over the place right now. From a practical perspective, AppleInsider says this means that software designed to look like real-life textures, such as linen or felt, is expected to become a thing of the past. In other words, expect the next version of iOS to have a sleeker, more industrial look to it than the current version.
http://bgr.com/2012/11/01/apple-ios-rumor-ive-makeover-planned/
Ives iOS makeover will incorporate clean edges, flat surfaces to replace the textures that are all over the place right now. From a practical perspective, AppleInsider says this means that software designed to look like real-life textures, such as linen or felt, is expected to become a thing of the past. In other words, expect the next version of iOS to have a sleeker, more industrial look to it than the current version.
http://bgr.com/2012/11/01/apple-ios-rumor-ive-makeover-planned/
There should be an option between gut it and start over and slight update. I think it needs to be overhauled with more than just widgets and live icons (setting default apps, better multitasking, and more freedom for starters) but not completely gutted.
Last edited:
You'd be surprised at the small percentage of android users who actually do this. Many people saying iOS needs a refresh are iOS users seeing where the competition is going and are wanting some of that to be seen on iOS. Some people don't like how slow the OS is advancing. And others, like you, are fine with it. Having options is a good thing.
Last edited:
Common misconception. Google actually does strive to ensure compatibility. Most device makers don't. Big difference.
The 2010 Nexus S has been updated with Jelly Bean and the Galaxy Nexus and Nexus 4 will be getting more updates in the future. Immediately. Guaranteed. Google themselves is as good as apple in the regard.
The pre iPad 2 Motorola xoom got Jelly bean
The year and a half old Galaxy SII is getting Jelly bean early this year.
There's other examples but this should suffice.
The fact that device makers have to spend time and resources in order to figure out how to make their devices compatible with the newest Android upgrade is exactly what I was referring to. Asus spend tones of cash trying to make their Transformers upgradable to JB, and they still haven't successfully made the transition. Sure the Prime and Infinity technically support JB, but it still runs poorly.