Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Smart Case or Smart Cover?

E

Eahdawn

macrumors member
Original poster
Jul 15, 2012
49
0
Buying my iPad tomorrow, and wondering which case should I opt for? The Smart Cover or Case? Hearing lots of negative things about the Case (jagged edges, loose fit), but can someone with the case tell me how they feel about it?

Thank you, from an over-enthusiastic first time iPad buyer. :)
 
Well first try them both in the store and see what you like.

If you decide you want a smart cover I suggest buying one off eBay and saving $20. Trusted sellers sell them on ebay because they were returned to the store etc..

Examples http://www.ebay.com/itm/Genunie-App...Accessories&hash=item2ec043ca89#ht_3006wt_689

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Genuine-App...?pt=US_Tablet_Accessories&hash=item2ebf9e0f1d


Then since you might want some scratch protection on the back then I would recommend a skin. This is the one I use. http://www.icarbons.com/collections/featured/products/new-ipad-ipad-two-black-carbon-fiber
 
I purchased a Smart Case and it is the worst product that Apple have ever made. It fits badly, very loose, horrible to hold, looks and feels really cheap.

I had a Smart Cover with an Incipio Smart Feather back on my iPad 2 and that was a million times better.

I shall be ditching the Smart Case and getting a new Incipio soon.

Don't waste your money - it is dreadful.

Jason
 
Hey guys, I really like that smart cover apple makes, but are non-apple smart covers (like that carbon fiber) just as good as apple's? Or should I go for the branded :apple: one?
 
Imagine the original apple iPad case tweaked slightly and that is the new case, it works and does the job but apple has dropped the ball, not a polished product.

I ordered it with a new iPad, if it was £10 cheaper it would be fine but its overpriced, even if you can inscribe it!

I do get the impression however it would offer decent protection if dropped as the corners are somewhat robust!

I will keep it, and use it and hopefully learn to love it.........
 
The smart case was a loose fit, and the top cover did not work well. It lasted a day on my iPad 3 before I took it off and returned it.

I am also using a smart cover and Incipio Smart Feather back.
 
I actually like the Apple case. The texture feels fine to me and feels solid enough. Doesn't feel sharp or rough and is cleanly manufactured. No complaints.
 
personally i like to take my smart cover off when using the iPad, so the smart case is a no go as it's always connected. i use a smart cover + cheap $10 gel back case that's compatible.
 
I have been using my Smart Cover for over a year, first with the 2 and now with the new. I have it paired with the Incipio back case.

I decided I wanted to try the Smart Case. Like others, I found the fit horrible and the edges so sharp, it was uncomfortable to hold. It has been returned to Apple and I have gone back to the tried and true.

Strongly recommend you check out both in person if you have an Apple Store near you before deciding.
 
orfeas0 said:
Hey guys, I really like that smart cover apple makes, but are non-apple smart covers (like that carbon fiber) just as good as apple's? Or should I go for the branded :apple: one?
Click to expand...

The carbon fiber is a skin for the back of your ipad. There are genuine apple smart covers sold on eBay for $20..
 
The  Smart Case is awesome, the fit is really snug actually had a tough time getting the iPad in the thing. Feels great, the material is slip resistant and feels good in the hands. I love it.
 
The Smart Cover is ingenious.

It is thin and sleek, looks pretty sexy, can be removed quickly and is integrated into the hardware and software of the iPad.

The Smart Case is an eye sore.

It adds thickness, is a pain to remove, prevents you being able to dock the iPad, has sharp edges, but it does protect the back.

It’s upto you which you prefer.
 
Im very fussy about my gadgets and after looking through many products I finally settled on a Belkin Snap shield for the back and a smart cover for the front.

Im very happy with it, check it out:

7642491300_7eeda0d243_b.jpg
7642492416_f0b4da7383_b.jpg
7642492990_0dd7bb17bb_b.jpg
7642493456_00e7554c8e_b.jpg
7642491904_76251db2ef_b.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'll toss my vote in for the smart case. I've been using it for a week, and I'm content with it. Luckily, my doesn't seem to have the fit issues other people are reporting.

GL
 
Sir Ruben said:
Im very fussy about my gadgets and after looking through many products I finally settled on a Belkin Snap shield for the back and a smart cover for the front.

Im very happy with it, check it out:

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image
Click to expand...

YES!!!! I love the Belkin stuff. I use the clear SnapShield on the back and the light gray Apple Smart Cover on the front. Perfect combination--keeps the iPad thin and light, but protects from scratches. Not sure I'd say it will protect from dents in the case of a drop, but.......
 
I got the green smart case,and it fits tight I even had a hard time popping the edges in,no loose fit at all,and I love it!
Everyone I know including myself have had issues with the smart cover,either it coming off all the time,or the iPad slips loose of it and it can also scratch your iPad,I recommend the cover hands down,but it's your choice,so far I am loving my smart case and would never go back!
 
I bought a green smart cover and have been pretty happy with it. I tried the smart case for a week thinking the extra protection might be nice (even though I haven't had a problem with the back scratching) and returned it. I really didn't like the added bulk, especially on the edges.

Smart Cover all the way.
 
Eahdawn said:
Buying my iPad tomorrow, and wondering which case should I opt for? The Smart Cover or Case? Hearing lots of negative things about the Case (jagged edges, loose fit), but can someone with the case tell me how they feel about it?

Thank you, from an over-enthusiastic first time iPad buyer. :)
Click to expand...

A lot of people are talking about scratch protection but it's not just scratch protection you want, you also want drop protection. I've dropped mine two or three times, e.g. fell asleep reading, and if I didn't have a case it would have been at the least dented badly (aluminum is soft).
 
orfeas0 said:
If you check that carbon fiber page, they also sell a carbon fiber smart cover.
Is that as good as apple's? Anyone knows?
Click to expand...

They are carbon fiber strips t put on your smart cover. I have them and like them.

----------
Kludge420 said:
A lot of people are talking about scratch protection but it's not just scratch protection you want, you also want drop protection. I've dropped mine two or three times, e.g. fell asleep reading, and if I didn't have a case it would have been at the least dented badly (aluminum is soft).
Click to expand...

Some people need drop protection and some don't.. I have never dropped my iPad so I feel fine with just a skin and a smart cover.
 
Smart Case is terrible, makes the iPad even wider, and as others said is a loose fit. I convinced my brother to buy it and he took it back same day and just went with a Targus case, that fits like a glove. I personally use a smart cover with an invisible shield on the back to prevent scratches. Works great.
 
I have both and I almost always end up using the Smart Cover. I just prefer holding the iPad when the back is not covered. The HDMI adapter doesn't seem to fit when using the case either, which is a problem for me too. Saying that, case is good if you're planning to take the iPad outside a you can shove it down on grass etc without needing to worry about getting it dirty. Still, the back of the iPad is pretty durable IMO so I stick to the cover.

If you mainly use the iPad indoors and carry it about in a bag, then smart cover is fine. If you often carry it around on its own and use outside, case is better.

Also forgot to add, you can get the Case engraved for free, which is a boon over other manufactures' products.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back