thanks tri but it still make decision harder. i won't mac mini. i prefer media streaming box. because i need airplay ,but xbmc maybe be option 2. if i bought atv, i afraid it will update soon. so it my problem in there. If i bought fire tv, i afraid can't use airplay on mac and other.
so if u in postion what u will bought?
thanks
Here is the airplay data from the XBMC wiki
An AirPlay password can be optionally set.
All platforms support video (without DRM, meaning videos downloaded from the iTunes store will not play in XBMC). Audio within the video will also work on all platforms.
All platforms support pictures.
All platforms support music (with or without DRM).
AirPlay mirroring is currently unsupported.
Videos recorded from an iDevice might not display with the correct rotation on Windows.[1]
AirPlaying music will show meta data (song/artist info, etc). Currently only works when AirPlaying from iTunes on a desktop computer.
Here are some costs:
Apple TV 2 with XBMC : $150 (if your lucky) up to $300+ and no 1080p
Amazon Fire TV with XBMC: $100 + tax and airplay good but likely not as good as ATV
ATV3 (refurb) and Fire TV (with xbmc): $175 + tax (you'll get xbmc, native airplay with ATV and can watch all HD content.
06/07 mac mini (C2D) : ~$100-~150 (depends on ebay luck) XBMC, airplay, local media access (usb), web browser. Airplay mirroring is not supported in xbmc.
I personally would go with the mac mini. I've had several ATV2 with xbmc and still found the mac mini to be a better all in one solution. I've actually sold several ATV2s and bought other goodies with the money. I don't airplay from any of our macbooks because the web browser on the mini works great. Pictures and videos airplayed from my idevices work great on minis. There have been talks of a new ATV for years and present rumors state that there could be an announcement later this your or next year. But only Apple knows.
again my $0.02.