Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

dtrobson099

Suspended
Original poster
Apr 19, 2010
5
0
I have a music library of 3,000+ songs. Some of that was tagged properly, some of that was TBD. About 6 months ago, I was researching a way to make this easier and downloaded a program called MusicBrainz Picard. Apparently it was supposed to automatically tag all my music by its digital audio fingerprint. Sounds great!

However, there were a couple of OCD rules I had when tagging my music, and after running MusicBrainz across my entire iTunes library, it was apparent that my rules were not being observed. First, I want the year the song was first released in the Year field, and I don't want the greatest hits version of the song, I want the song on it's originally released album or single. Without this, I can't make a smart playlist of 90's music without getting 60's tracks that were tagged by the compilation album they showed up on in 1994. Other than that, I'm not really that picky. Album art should be there if possible.

Anyway, MusicBrainz messed this up. What's worse, it started messing up my folder structure, and started nesting folders like the Land O' Lakes butter lady in some cases. I stopped what I was doing and said I'd go back and fix it later, but other things were more important.

I had curated my library quite well up through the letter "G" before I did this, and now I'm staring at a huge task - and I'm not even sure where all the problems are. I noticed this morning (I've been shuffling the "Music" folder around several Macs as this has been an upgrade season for me), that there is a "Previous iTunes Libraries" folder within this "Music" folder. I'm intrigued as to how this might be used to rollback my music library to something before the MusicBrainz experiment.

Since iTunes Match came out I've been taking advantage of it, but using iTunes to expand my library instead of the legacy methods I used to build it in the first place. So I'm confident that if rolling back to an old library is necessary, I won't lose anything since everything that's been acquired since then has been purchased through iTunes.

How would I go about rolling back to a previous library, would it even help me fix folder structure and ID3 tags (I'm suspicious that it wouldn't since that metadata is stored in the files themselves), and are there any gotchas I need to look out for if I go down this route?
 

dyt1983

macrumors 65816
May 6, 2014
1,365
165
USA USA USA
edit: To remove personally identifying information not relevant to the thread.

How would I go about rolling back to a previous library, would it even help me fix folder structure and ID3 tags (I'm suspicious that it wouldn't since that metadata is stored in the files themselves), and are there any gotchas I need to look out for if I go down this route?

I would think you're going to need to look at those previous libraries to see if they're helpful. If you're library is not too big, it might be better just to go with Matched files. Someone who knows more about that can probably give you more info.
 
Last edited:

dtrobson099

Suspended
Original poster
Apr 19, 2010
5
0
I would think you're going to need to look at those previous libraries to see if they're helpful. If you're library is not too big, it might be better just to go with Matched files. Someone who knows more about that can probably give you more info.

Yeah, that's the deal. I'm not really sure what's involved in "looking at those previous libraries". Oh well. It sounds like you're giving a recommendation to give MusicBrainz Picard another shot, but take some time to get the settings right this time.

I think I'll just export all the music I have from iTunes into another folder, then try re-doing it with longer and more descriptive file names (I like the iTunes folder structure, but sounds like MusicBrainz won't be able to do those right) then blow away the iTunes library and import everything back in. Hopefully Match doesn't hold on to wrong stuff.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.