Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

LeahM

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Mar 18, 2008
877
0
Are magnets still an arch enemy to all computers?

Sorry I know its a dumb question but I know that you were NEVER supposed to bring a magnet near anything electronic. But then I read a thread where some people said that magnets don’t have any effect on their ipods. And then theres the fact that theres a magsafe charger with the Macbooks. So now I’m confused.
 
Are magnets still an arch enemy to all computers?

Sorry I know its a dumb question but I know that you were NEVER supposed to bring a magnet near anything electronic. But then I read a thread where some people said that magnets don’t have any effect on their ipods. And then theres the fact that theres a magsafe charger with the Macbooks. So now I’m confused.

Magnets are harmful to magnetic media (hard disks, tape, floppy disks) if they are close to the media.

The magsafe connector is not that powerful and not directly near the internal disk.
 
Magnets are harmful to magnetic media (hard disks, tape, floppy disks) if they are close to the media.

The magsafe connector is not that powerful and not directly near the internal disk.

So say if I had a magnet, like a Kinex (sp?) near my MBP nothing would happen to it?

I guess thats why I'm paranoid about my Mac because my nephew (who is the spawn of satan) plays with K'nex everywhere he goes, he keeps them in his pockets, but I want to know if they will damage the MBP.
 
So say if I had a magnet, like a Kinex (sp?) near my MBP nothing would happen to it?

I guess thats why I'm paranoid about my Mac because my nephew (who is the spawn of satan) plays with K'nex everywhere he goes, he keeps them in his pockets, but I want to know if they will damage the MBP.

I'm not familiar with them. Unless these are super-strong magnets I wouldn't worry too much about it. If your nephew is around, just close your MBP until he goes away. :)
 
There was, I believe, a thread where this was discussed in some detail a while back when Apple added the magnetic remote holder to the previous-style iMacs, but I can't seem to find it now.

Basically, though, magnetic storage media (floppies and HDs), by definition, relies on small changes in magnetic field to store data, so they don't particularly like large magnetic fields--have a tendency to corrupt data stored. CRTs also dislike magnets, in that you can screw up the beam in a permanent way under some circumstances (I did this as a child once).

Most everything else in a computer actually doesn't much care about a magnet. And in reality, even hard drives are relatively well shielded from magnetic fields, so they're nowhere near as sensitive as the image I had drilled into my head as a child. Plus magnetic field decreases as an inverse cube, which is to say that it falls off VERY quickly with distance.

Bottom line being actually computers aren't THAT sensitive to magnets, it's just a whole lot easier to teach people "magnets + computers = bad" than "well, it's generally ok, but if you hold one too close to a drive or move it in a certain direction you could cause serious data corruption, particularly if it's not grounded..." etc.

So be sensibly careful, but don't freak out about it; the hard drive is probably far enough inside and well enough shielded that even if you were to hold one of those magnetic blocks right against the case there it wouldn't affect it.
 
There are these new magnets that are a children's toy called Sizzlers. They're super strong magnets that clack together and make a sizzling sound. Apparently some of our friends have had their iPods completely erased due to the little buggers. As a result, they have been banned from all the houses in our group of friends. Watch out, they're deadly! lol

Mick
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.